Comment on Would you rather trust a state-run police organization or a civillian militia composed of local residents? Or something else (such as like total disbandment of any such organized groups)?
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments
Comments
The mistake here is thinking that different superficial characteristics would gain the trust of the public. State run police can be good or bad, depending on their accountability to the public they serve and the quality of governance systems in place and the collective good will of those most reponsible.
State run, citizens militia or robot army are inconsequential factors. They could all be good just as easily as they could all be absolutely horrific. Ending poverty doesn’t end crime either. Mental illness, crimes of passion, greed, jealousy and a lust for power make rich people do terrible things too.
There is a complex web of responsibilities in policing between various interest groups. Finding balance is difficult even if everyone shares the best intentions. Power and corruption go hand in hand without vigilance making it a nearly impossible job, so the most reliable indicators are accountability to the population being policed, high quality altruistic leadership and good governance systems including transparency and a functional media landscape.
Sign in to comment. Sign in