Comment on New law ‘may be needed’ after Google rejects call to remove Russell Brand’s YouTube prison message
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above
Comments
Show me the law that says people married to prisoners aren’t allowed to speak in public.
The law is the Prison Act 1952 which gives the secretary of state powers to restrict prisoner communications. https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1952/52
This is enacted through Rule 34(3) of the Prison Rules 1999 (SI 1999/728):
The operational guidance that spells out the media-specific restrictions is PSI 37/2010 – Prisoners’ Access to the Media, which prohibits prisoners from:
Making statements likely to cause unnecessary distress to victims
Making gratuitous reference to victims
Bypassing the rules by having a third party (e.g., a family member) publish their comments
Edit: added second half regarding third party bypassing.
Its really convenient that you skipped over the rest of Rule 34, considering that it completely disproves what youre trying to claim.
This is the full text, emphasis mine:
Literally every single one of those patently does not apply. Obviously this is not a national security issue. Hes already in prison for the crime, so B and G are definitely out. C, D, E, and H are completely unrelated. The only one the maybe, and I use the word maybe very loosely, could possibly apply is F. But the thing is that he already was found guilty and convicted, and is currently in prison for the crime. Reasonably the majority of people take that under greater consideration than the word of a guy saying they lied.
Most importantly, “the communication might distress someone if it was leaked to the press”, or even “the communication might be leaked to the press at all” are notably not listed whatsoever in the grounds to restrict a prisoners communications.
Given there is not really any grounds for it in the first place, thats gonna make it really hard to clear the bar established by point (iii), that the restriction be proportionate to the goal. “Prisoner isnt allowed to talk to his wife anymore” would be pretty disproportionate to preventing the possibility of her communicating a message for him from prison. Plus to fully prevent that you would have to not allow him to see anyone at all, let alone his wife, for the purpose of not distressing people who can just turn off YouTube. Hes not mailing letters to them to harass them personally
Idk about the other shit you quoted, but given how severely you misrepresented the first source Im not even going to bother to look
That’s the prisoner, not the spouse of a prisoner. Additionally if this statement is from before the conviction or sentencing then the wording of the law makes it not apply, as it would not be contemporary speech.
Sign in to comment. Sign in