Skip to content

Comment on What should we call communities on here?

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments

Comments

  • People say communities or coms, those work fine.

    I’m not sure subreddit flows off the tongue like you think it does.

    16
    • Downvote away, but I prefer sublemmy, subpie or just “sub.”

      Why? Because “sub” actually is a really good / simple descriptor of the fact that a group is a smaller extension of a larger software instance.

      I had no problem at all with the word “community” until I eventually realised that it’s naturally a poor fit for subgroups here, which are really more like subscriber lists. Partly because people here commonly sign up for content coming out of that subgroup, but rarely seem to invest all that much in to making it what would really be called a “community.”

      Back in the days of webforums, I found a lot of them to be very much like true online communities, because it was the same people rubbing elbows over and over again. But a big part of that is because forums operate by topic-focus, whereas modern social media tends to operate by stream-focus. Forums encourage people to be talking about the same topic for days, whereas streaming social media turns it in to endless browsing of dozens of topics each day, and we rarely linger in one for more than a bit.

      All that’s why I prefer “sub,” as in we’re subscribed to that list.

      /mini-lecture rant over!

      4
      • Lol, I really want to downvote this just because you asked people to, but I won’t.

        I see where you’re coming from, but Lemmy still feels like a community to me, and “sub” would have to be explained every time, while community doesn’t.

        I remember when nobody knew what “reddit” or “subreddit” meant, and those words only became normal when reddit became huge, which I’m not interested in Lemmy becoming anyway.

        I have explained Lemmy to curious friends as a forum a few times though.

        An important note is that I do block all of the spammers, so most of my interactions on here are with real people instead of endless, meaningless memes.

        6
        • @Kichae@piefed.ca· · edited

          “Community” would have to be much better justified, I think. As soon as a space grows beyond a certain size, it stops functioning as any kind of community and just becomes a crowd od chaos.

          Now, there aren’t many – if any – spaces this large here now, bit it’ll happen eventually.

          Personally, I like the term “group”. “Group Actor” is the name for the ActivityPub feature underpinning them, and “group” doesn’t come with any baggage around the size or style of interaction. It’s also viably platform agnosric, which is nice because not everyone is going to be accessing groups from Lemmy-based sites!

          0
          • … it’ll happen eventually.

            Do I understand you right? You’re saying that the word community is a bad label for literal communities because if Lemmy one day gets too popular, the communities won’t feel like communities?

            I think “groups” is fine also. How is the word community somehow platform-specific or have baggage? It seems definitional.

            If you’re using “group” “circle” or “quork” to describe people on Lemmy that talk to each other about certain topics, won’t that have the same baggage and platform specificity that any word will have, since that is the word you’re using to describe people on lemmy talking about specific shared topics?

            0
        • Lemmy still feels like a community to me

          That’s awesome! 👊
          I can’t quite say I feel the same way, but I do regularly interact with a couple fellow content creators here, so that does feel better than Reddit, for example.

          “sub” would have to be explained every time, while community doesn’t.

          For those without Reddit experience, I have to agree. Then again, if enough people commonly used the term, I don’t think it would be all that hard to pick up for noobies, just as in RL.

          I have explained Lemmy to curious friends as a forum a few times though.

          I mean… as long as they don’t have webforums experience, right? Because it’s a massively different experience from traditional forums.

          0
          • Yeah, for those unfamiliar, it’s easy to say “interactive forum” after “online community” and people get a sense of how lemmy works, which is enough.

            0
            • Counterpoint: for people who aren’t online a lot, Lemmy / PieFed is typically a complicated, bewildering place to get in to, not because it lacks social interaction, but because of the inevitable learning curve about the infrastructure, tankies, uniqueness of rules, mod situation, empty community situation, etc.

              1
              Continue this thread 6 more replies

Sign in to comment. Sign in