Comment on How to cope with awareness of suffering being necessary for life (at least on our planet)?
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above
Comments
Life does increase entropy in a system overall but does so as a byproduct of decreasing it locally in the form of highly organized cells. Our immediate struggle against it is what causes the suffering under discussion!
I mean I wouldn’t say we are struggling against entropy I’d say we are facilitating it. But yeah that is pretty pedantic. Maybe I ought to watch less David Mitchell lol.
Life takes in low-entropy energy like sunlight and simple chemical bonds and gives off high-entropy waste like heat and co2. It’s these activities of organizing and processing that is the struggle to live. So yes we facilitate entropy but it’s an effect of persisting, every living being carries code to replicate, organize and survive. Without that effort there is no struggle and no suffering.
The Buddhists call this organizational drive taṇhā!
Oh curious! Which Buddhists focus on that? I’ve only closely studied Chan Zen.
Do you think something that has no desires can suffer?
Without understanding qualia it is basically impossible to confidently speak about the intentions of non-humans. I’ve filmed some microbes that sure looked like they suffered. But I can’t with certainty say they had the intention to survive or if I just iterpret certain movements as pain.
taṇhā is the core of the second noble truth so is shared across all the Buddhist sects. My own studies are largely under Theravada which uses Pali. Mahayana and Vajrayana branches would call it the Sanskrit tṛṣṇā. The Chinese terms are unfamiliar to me I just looked it up and it seems like 愛 (ài) or 渴愛 (kě’ài) are closest.
suffering under Buddhism (dukkha in Pali) doesn’t require the same pain/distress connotations that we assign in the west. It’s more a sense of unsatisfactory-ness. The paramecium moves towards and eats another microbe to satisfy the innate unease of conditioned existence. To live is to suffer in this fashion. Every creature is born hungry in its own way.
Ah I just hadn’t read much from OG Buddha or any Theravada literature in so long I forgot the term! Thanks for the refresher. Chan is very focused on what we consider real and what enlightenment is and talks less about suffering than you might expect.
I don’t necessarily belive subjects exist and I think experience doesn’t require suffering. But all these terms are so wibbly wobbly that it is a real pain to talk about.
I can in some sense see all motivation as suffering, but then suffering loses it’s power to distinguish between life an non-life. Well, at least if we apply it to microbes it becomes harder to distinguish living motivation from mechanical motivation.
Sign in to comment. Sign in