Skip to content

Comment on What to do about racism in speculative media?

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments

Comments

  • Ethnic identity is formed in opposition to majority culture

    Say whaaaaat? That’s a wild take. Ethnic identity is formed by being part of a culture, not by being in opposition to another. Putting up Diwali decorations instead of Christmas ornaments doesn’t inherently mean you oppose Christmas. Just means you celebrate Diwali. Not everything is a competition.

    3
    • Yes, that was poorly phrased. I think the intensity of your identification with ethnicity is definitely influenced by the majority view’s take on it. Think of all the white people who might have a passing familiarity with their heritage, but not really consider themselves to have much culture otherwise, compared to how strongly European Muslims cling to a Muslim identity in a hostile environment to American Muslims who (and I know the Islamophobia is still bad) can wear it a little more lightly.

      Anyway, I think there’s a tension between celebrating ethnic identity and the melting pot, and I’m not sure how it would shake out in a Utopia. For instance, if people really did celebrate their ethnic identity but at the same time married and raised children easily outside of their ethnic identiy, what culture would the children of a Korean-German-Indian-Persian identify with? I think what it would turn into is people DIYing an ethnic identity for themselves based on their heritage, the same way people pick and choose which ancestors they identify with when they do geneology.

      And to be fair to Star Trek, I think we see Star Fleet, which might be more heavily a racial mix than the Earth from which it draws its ranks, so I think part of my problem with the show is I assume Earth is mixing as much as Star Fleet is, which is probably not the case.

      2
      • I feel like a lot of the pressures involving racial mixing in Star Trek kind of stop when there are other planets to settle. The internal migrations on Earth tend to go away when moving off world is a better key to success.

        You also get the expanding idea of kin now that there are several other sentient species. Brock Peters plays Admiral Cartwright in Star Trek VI while saying a lot of racist shit against Klingons. I expect all the human racists got together to be racist against other species.

        1

Sign in to comment. Sign in