Skip to content

Comment on Have someone changed your mind about something significant? What was it?

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments

Comments

  • Being race-blind and treating everyone the same is woefully inadequate and harmful.

    I’m quite removed for humanity, so my natural inclination is to see all of humanity as a species separate from myself, with very little distinction between demographics. I much disliked discussions about race because I was well informed about the biological reality of the species: pockets of meaningful genetic distinction exist, but none correlate with the social construct of “race”. Most are regional adaptations, on the scale of small tribes and islands, and have nothing to do with skin color. There is more genetic diversity within the continent of Africa than outside of it; trying to lump people together because of visible traits is a demonstration of stupidity.

    (Also, sidenote cold take: genetic diversity is good. For all the talk of pure blood and alpha wolves that ethnic nationalists love yapping about: “pure blood” is how you get pugs, not wolves… ‘Race “science”’ isn’t just wrong on theoretical and epidemiological bases, but is internally self-defeating even when assumed axiomatically correct… But I digress.)

    I was challenged on the basis that —conceding that race was purely a social construct— not accounting for race means that it’s fundamentally impossible to correct for the inequities that construct creates. My strict ‘equality’ was actually doing unintended harm by perpetuating a state of things that was influenced by racism.

    That taught me the important distinction between equity and equality, and convinced me to “see race” (for what it is) more justly. Just because something is a “social construct” doesn’t mean it’s not real: it’s manifestly real, emerging from human interaction. “Race” is of statistical significance; not because race is true as a concept, but because we make it true. And I can’t ignore it if I want to contribute to fixing it.

    7
    • Tell me more about you being ‘removed’ from humanity. I’d think that’s a neurodiverse thing to say but I’m keen on learning who else refers to oneself like that.

      0
    • Preach

      2

Sign in to comment. Sign in