Skip to content

Comment on Who's (ironically or unironically) your favorite Mary Sue/Gary Stu character of all time and why?

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments

Comments

  • Harry Blackstone Copperfield Dresden, of The Dresden Files book series.

    My man can’t lose. He gets his ass beat off him on the regular, don’t get me wrong, but he’s always got a way out. The series has 20+ books in it, you come to expect it after a while, but it never gets less fun.

    spoiler text

    Legitimately the only character I know of that can be shot dead and drowned at the end of one book, wake up in the literal afterlife at the beginning of the next book, and my immediate assumption is “Yeah he’ll probably walk that off”

    1
    • Harry is - like Neo mentioned higher in the thread - one of those points where he suffers enough setbacks and hostility from other characters that he slips beneath the Sue threshold. He’s definitely rocking some serious power, especially as of the latest book(s), but he’s taken some serious losses too.

      In no particular order:

      Spoilers up until the latest book:
      • Couldn’t stop Susan from being infected by the Red Court, or her death in the events of Changes.
      • Couldn’t stop the Red Court without subjecting himself to Mab’s authority.
      • Couldn’t stop either of the loves of his life from dying right before him, in spite of all his power.
      • Ended his relationship with Luccio on a painful note for both of them.
      • Lost Morgan.
      • Couldn’t prevent Molly from being claimed by the Winter Court.
      • Got kicked out by the White Council and is treated as a serious threat by them, including by former close friends.
      • Couldn’t stop Ethniu without Chicago getting wrecked, potentially destroying the Masquerade.

      Remember, a Sue isn’t just successful in their story. It’s that they instantly solve any problem without struggle and are adored by those around them. Dresden is, at this point, a seriously scarred individual thanks to all the losses he took.

      2
      • Yeah that’s a fair point I suppose. I can’t sit here with a straight face and argue that he solves anything “without struggle”. I’ve just always felt like he had a serious case of protagonist syndrome, is all. I still love it though, it’s straight up my favorite book series.

        0

Sign in to comment. Sign in