643
Jessishiking shares some facts about GTA 6
Facebook post by Jessishiking, which reads,
"I can FINALLY share that I play Cygnus, the museum curator, the first-ever nonbinary character in the Grand Theft Auto franchise! Absolutely wild to find out THIS was the super-secret game I spent weeks and 17 NDAs filming 3 years ago. Some fun facts:
- GTA was one of the most inclusive & caring sets I’ve ever been on. I shot this back in my they/them days, and everyone on production ensured I was comfortable and gendered correctly.
- At the time I wasn’t allowed to know what I was shooting - I didn’t get confirmation until TODAY that it was, indeed, GTA VI.
- This was shot exclusively through motion-capture, meaning I had to wear a unitard made of dots every day 😂
- To mitigate anti-trans violence, I was assured that players would not be able to inflict violence against my character.
- There was an entire day dedicated to scanning my face, which involved hours of exercises where I contorted it into different expressions. For whatever reason I wasn’t able to move a certain muscle, and I thought I had wrecked the scan, but the director was so excited.iThat right there is exactly why we’ll never use Al," he said. “A computer could never come up with the face you just made.” Remember, in a world consumed with Generative Al, the largest video game in history chose human labor to preserve the integrity of the game.
- Despite being paid well for my time on set, I’ll never see a residual check for my work. (This is part of SAG’s contract with game developers.) While I’m thrilled to be a part of this project, as a union leader (for SAG’s sister union) I would be remiss not to acknowledge we have a long way to go to ensure arts workers are fairly compensated for our labor.
- SO many trans people besides me are featured in GTA
Vl as other roles, designers, writers, etc…take a note, theatre and TV! We are employable & profitable!!! - UK-based workers at Rockstar Games are currently voting on whether to unionize, and I sincerely hope their efforts are successful. Every arts worker should have a stable job with benefits and fair working conditions protected by a union. Solidarity to union workers everywhere who make the art that keeps the world running ❤️"
Comments
I have a minor issue here. You can beat up and shoot gays, blacks, Jews, the elderly, the homeless, women, and all other minorities. Any of those characters could also be trans. You may also beat up and shoot other characters that were all motion-captured and modeled after actual people. They could reasonably have the same expectation, and I’m sure that a part of everyone’s contract stipulates whether the character can or can’t be hurt, based on the actor/model’s preferences and their part in the game. What irks me is not only bringing highly polarized current political issues into a game game based on crime and violence, and also taking a side on it that prohibits player actions. It’s asking for more than equal treatment, it is asking for preferential treatment.
I understand that this is a touchy subject, and I hate that it is, and think we should be able to discuss these things without being permanently branded misogynistic transphobic pedophiles. Because that psychotic level outrage is exactly the reason some people take an issue with the trans community- the fact that any critique is basically haram and is met with the same reaction as spray painting a portrait of Mohammad on a mosque.
This game is not about trans or trans rights, never been up until now, and it still isn’t. Regardless of what your opinions are on that whole discussion, removing any amount of agency in a videogame about breaking rules, laws, and taboos that disallows or forces the player to conform with a political or personal conviction, rubs a lot of people the wrong way. Surely that’s understandable. And having an issue with it doesn’t make them transphobic.
I think this is an issue, and my closest family include one trans person and one happily married gay person, and we’re all involved politically in human rights policy. And I fucking hate that I have to write out all these god damned disclaimers every time I want to say something on the topic because I already know what the reactions will be.
Tbh, if someone’s reaction to “you cannot kill this particular character in the story even though they are non-binary” is anything other than “ok”, they’re probably a transphobe. There’s plenty of other character you can’t kill either. Changing your game because you might upset some bigots otherwise seems pretty pointless to me. I really don’t care about their feelings.
You can leave this out imo. “I’ve got black friends” type shit. Doesn’t add anything meaningful to the convo.
Because this is not a randomly generated NPC and instead it uses the likeness of a real person. This might be corporate virtue signaling, but it is also about real life violence. Against a real person. Not about imaginary violence (for the sake of satire) against imaginary randomly generated people that never existed?
Do you see the difference? this is by far not the first LGBTQ character that has been protected this way, and it’s not the first character being protected because they are played by real actors. Who can face real life harassment and violence.
I know fascism has no media literacy. But the purpose of GTA is not absolutist freedom to do anything and break all laws and rules. If you even put an ounce of brain power when playing a GTA game, it becomes obvious this is satire against the US’s culture. GTA has been violently left wing for a long while. It is trying to puncture holes into the political right wing narratives via reductio ad absurdum. If you play GTA and pay attention to the plot and the dialogue, you can’t come away thinking that the game is pro guns, and supports violence and abuse against the weak. Because it has always found ways to ridicule and spit on the face of said opinions.
Instead it mocks the glorification of sex and violence. It laughs openly against the idiocy of racism and bigotry. It makes caricatures of political conservative characters to put them in embarrassing situations. At the times when the game is talking about the struggles of oppressed people, or minorities, or the real suffering caused by the pressures of capitalism, the game gets serious and dark.
It’s just the average conservative goes “hurr durr, guns, boobs and drugs funny”, and never sees past the surface veneer.
Anyway, fuck Rockstar. May they corporation crash and burn in hell and all suits go along with it.
Yeah, the first terrible thought that came to my mind is that this game will come to PC, and someone will mod it so you can kill her character because she’s trans. Because people are fucked up that way.
The alternative was that she’s included as part of the inevitable murder spree players would go on because she’s just part of the game. Because that’s what GTA is, murdering people not because of how they look, but because they exist.
Wow you made a point I never considered in my push against this. How can we know if passing trans characters are trans…? So where is the line and what’s the damn point beyond just corpo virtue signaling?
It’s nice getting paid , cheers.
nice
This might be a dumb question…
Why the fuck do I care if someone is non-binary?
And while I’m im at it ,why the fuck do non-binary folks insist on telling everyone they are non-binary.
It’s like the joke about how you tell someone who is vegan/cross-fit/other niche thing - “they’ll tell you”
I don’t give a fuck if you’re gay, lesbian or one of the other many types of people out there.
Couldn’t give a flying fuck.
What I give a shit about is how you treat other people. If you’re a cunt, you’re a cunt and I don’t want to know you. It’s got nothing to do with what genitals you find attractive, who you want to fuck, what gender you are.
Be a decent fucking human and I’ll treat you with respect. If not, you can fuck right off.
I think I should remind everyone that Rockstar operates on the UK which has lately been incredibly hostile towards trans rights, the fact they still maintain such diversity is nothing but positive
Well yeah it’s not a national policy that all citizens have to agree with the government, they are better than a fascist dictatorship which is basically the alternative. So really we have to put up with the idiots, it doesn’t mean everyone agrees with them.
And it’s not like they’ve gone after inclusive employment programs like in the US. They just been baseline shitty people.
oh boy people are not gonna take this well are they
“We are profitable” as a statement of self valuation is… dystopian
Like the US president constantly saying ‘we made lots of money’ as far as I can tell the US population is not included in the ‘we’. Seriously one step before cyberpunk, but before the awesome technology.
I believe it may be her job as a union leader to say these things…and we all have jobs.
But you’re not wrong, it is dystopian to have to say that.
How much you wanna bet CHUDs will work to mod the game to hurt the character?
Telling people they can’t do something is the best way to get them to do something.
[removed by a moderator]
GTA has made it impossible to kill story NPCs plenty of times. I hated that testosterone riddled musclehead in GTA4 and could never figure out a way. This is fine. It’s nothing new.
They also tend to allow you to kill story npcs AFTER the story is done.
Okay if the museum curator is probably a special NPC anyway, I can understand not being able to kill them… But you can still kill all the random peds, right? Or is it literally going to be shoots “oh, that one is trans, they’re invulnerable”? Because that would be jarring.
There has never been an instance in any GTA game previously where you are ever given the opportunity to kill any named story related characters unless and until any given mission specifically involves you doing so. So any named character can be assumed to be safe until the plot says otherwise.
The pedestrians out in the world are fair game, but they’re randomly generated and none of them have names or, if you get right down to it, unique faces.
My guess is that the character would never appear in an area where weapons or punching is allowed. So either cutscenes only or only indoors
I don’t know how to express my opinion without sounding like an absolute chud, but imma try. So let me preface that I’ve always been a supporter of trans rights. Let me also say that I’m not the target audience for this entire genre. I don’t really care for the “be as horrible as you want” simulator, but I’m familiar enough to know that historically that’s exactly what it has always been. Be as horrible as you want, and don’t feel bad because everyone in the game is horrible too.
For literally any other video game, I’d be yelling at my screen “fuck yeah” at every line of the original post. But this is gta, so the actor’s character being immortal left me confused. It’s a wonderful gesture, especially knowing that there’s assholes out there who will target this character specifically because of being trans. But this is gta.
Shooting up nightclubs and running over pedestrians hasn’t really appealed to me since I was a teenager many years ago. But if that’s something I did want to do (and gta is famous for letting you), then I’m not asking for pronouns first, and if anyone is left standing when I’m done I’d keep trying and it would be weird if it didn’t work.
“So you want to kill trans people” is what I expect to see in the replies, and the more I explain the easier it is to paint me as the asshole. “The fact that the character/actor is trans is utterly irrelevant to the point!” but that’s pretty much the same line a chud would say, knowingly lying while seething that they can’t kill the game’s one trans person.
Maybe it’s fine. Maybe all the import characters are immortal specifically so that players don’t accidentally miss out on content. That makes sense and would invalidate all objections. But it’s presented as "I’m immortal because I’m trans*. Cool superpower, damn I wish it was like that in real life.
To be fair, I think they ban you from shooting up nightclubs now too. The game has “gun free zones” at all major clubs to prevent you from doing mass shootings there, from what I’ve heard.
I don’t know all the details, but given that the the character in question is a museum curator, I wonder if they’re an NPC that only ever appears in scripted segments or cutscenes. It’s not that they are invincible in the open world while every other NPC is vulnerable, they probably don’t appear in the open world at all.
That’s just my speculation. I don’t think Rockstar would pull a Fallout 4 and make key NPCs “go down” if you try to kill them. So I think in practice this wouldn’t be an issue to the average GTA player.
That also makes total sense, and I probably should have thought of that.
No shame in that. Watch my speculation be horribly wrong and it actually works like the Cuccos in Ocarina. :D
That would be even better actually
I’m sure this is right just by the fact the character is named. I have yet to encounter Sygnus or explore enough to see if there random spawning trans/gays whatever. I would expect a bunch as South Florida has a decently large gay community, and rockstar is really going for realism here.
There is a comment just below yours that calls them “demon” and can’t wait to mod the ability to “burn them alive”. There is a specific part of psyche you don’t want to encourage even in a crime simulator.
It’s 2026 and we’re still not sure if DOOM should be banned…
Sounds like I made two mistakes: I underestimated the average chud’s cruelty, and overestimated their ability to form coherent arguments.
OK so I played a 5 hours with my mate last night who bought it and invited me over. Most of that was just driving around and fucking about so we only saw 9% of the campaign.
I’m not a GTA fan but I’m not a hater just not a regular player. I had fun with the game.
The bit of the story we did play the characters felt like they had life to them and not just a collection of surface level stereotypes.
I don’t get why people like Mandy, she was just so presumptuous, rude, and gives off sociopathic energy. If I met anyone like that I real life I’d be backing off slowly as to not get my tyres slashed or my pet poisoned. Maybe she has some redeeming qualities later on that we didn’t get to see?
I like the game mechanics of the cops circulating a description of you in the area so you have to change your vehicle, clothes, outfit to not be spotted and the fact that they don’t highlight where the cops are so you have to keep an eye out for them.
Of course the second the world opened up we located the military base and tried to break in there to steal a jet, that was a lot of fun.
And the world was just gorgeous to look at especially the bay area during the day and the city from the main airport at night.
Seems to me like WAY too many people are invested in this game as like a huge cultural moment and just not appreciating it for what it is: a video game to escape into.
If you managed to get through 9% of the campaign in 5 hours. Then the campaign is magnitudes shorter than I’d anticipate of the world’s largest media production
because it is rdr3 miami edition, which is fine because games evolve
but fans wanted gta4 next gen
This is the next generation now, well maybe two, time flies afterall. I played GTA 3 as an adult, still an adult (stupid time one direction but not the point here) but have no ps5 so will wait semi patiently. Least I hope, could attempt a purchase if I succumb to my basic urgres. Tthat being a ps purchase but probably not the best time to invest since I only have a 4 and own a decent PC, always kept up with PC hardware thought been nearly two years since my last build but don’t want to do that currently for damn sure. Eh at my age it’ll be out after the hype died down and be all cool time to check it out.
GTA 5 was fun, silly good vibe, everything I’ve heard about 6 is similar. Can’t wait but try and keep my wallet in my pocket till I can afford it without telling my gf how much I spent. Single? Well I’d probably have a ps5 but rather have the gf around. Plus had to buy a dishwasher? Ugh expensive as shit. Could have paid for that purchase for sure.
Wait unless I wasn’t understanding next gen, if you’re talking 30fps just look at gta5 release. Prefer better fps but consoles were always behind compared to PC, they always push their hardware if possible (some conditions apply)
nothing on a console can ever be next gen
it can be well done, it can be fun, but hardware is years behind at all times
25 fps says it all vs pc games running 240 sometimes and thats just one aspect
Yall really need to step back and self examine how mad you are you cant murder trans people.
Separate fiction from reality, otherwise, what are you doing playing GTA? This is just the “killer games” debate again. I don’t really care when it’s an important story character that’s made unkillable for obvious game design reasons, that might be the case here but idk, because accidentally killing important story chars would mean you have to reload a save.
minor GTA VI spoiler
GTA VI has made furries illegal and cops shooting a furry, as a furry I’m completely fine with that because it’s satire and not real. It would be very weird if they made every minority unkillable to “protect” them. Btw, I don’t want to equate trans people to furries, this is just the only thing I know about the game, also shout-out to all the cool trans furries out there.
It’s not about trans people specifically, it’s about the game developer forcing their morality on your gaming experience. I want to be able to indiscriminately massacre everyone. Why am I restricted from doing so?
Making a story-critical character is neither morality forcing nor new for GTA.
So, you won’t play the game because you can’t murder most of the story characters, even minor ones? You know, like every other GTA game?
This is a named character. Unless there is a mission requiring you to do so, you would not be able to kill them. Were you offended that you could not kill Peach in GTA 5/online?
Couldnt you kill them after the story was done like in older GTA games? I dont recall how GTA did it.
Is there a line? Would you want to kill children? Put people in a Nazi style gas chamber? If so, why is the line there? If there is no line, why?
Yes, I would like to be able to. Not that I would like to do that necessarily. But artificially taking away the ability to do things that the player historically has been able to do? That’s a no no.
Now, GTA never had children anywhere. Nor gas chambers, none that I can recall.
What I want to know is, if I was able to go shoot up a night club in GTA4, why is this suddenly a problem in GTA6?
The first two fallout games had softlocks in quests because they straight up patched out children in non-us releases. The later fallout games require mods to kill children.
On the other hand and just in genera, maybe I just want to decide for myself if I’m gonna murderhobo my way through a game or not. Sure it might make some parts of the game unaccessible but I probably get to those on a different playthrough.
People need to step back and realize that the game is no longer openworld.
I am not advocating violence towards any group of people at all. But your imaginary war is dumb.
I think her un-killable status is laughable, and she is hardly the first non-binary character in the GTA franchise.
Do we now consider Trevor, just a recent example, binary? Is nonbinary becoming simply ternary?
Way to upheave those stereotypes!
edit: for the record, I have a niece who is a transwoman, two of my friends are gay men, and when I moved to this city, my roommates were a lesbian couple and a gay man.
Why aren’t people up in arms about how you can kill the nearly nude dude in Morrowind who is the primary quest starter? I mean, he looks pretty damn gay.
Acknowledgement only fuels the bullshit from all angles. Fuck it and be happy.
Vivic is literally a hermaphrodite who has transcended gender. Thats kinda part of who vivic is. They are… a odd case…
I am talking about the big bear you meet in Balmora. But yeah, Vivec is like hexadecimal.
We live in an unserious world.
Culture war nonsense about actions in a video game > actual material suffering of real people
In a game that allows you to shoot anyone, making a trans character not shootable is quite odd. If they are protected from violence why are minorities and children not? I think that’s a dumb PC choice that does not achieve anything.
I should not have to add a disclosure, but I say this as someone who is support of trans rights, as well as uplifting any person discriminated against.
I don’t think GTA normally allows players to kill story-significant characters in any context.
I have not played the game, so I know nothing about this character in particular. But if they are being mocapped and face scanned, they’re not just some background NPC.
And in that sense, egalitarianism in violence aside, it’s more reassuring to know that bigots don’t have the option of brutalizing a specific trans character with the likeness of a specific trans person. Targeted violence towards a real person is probably the bigger concern. Bigots can still murder a random woman on the street in GTA and headcanon that she’s trans if they want to get their rocks off.
The headcanon would then also have to include that she was passing, and those are the ones they fantasize about fucking, not the ones they fantasize about killing.
Usually (at least in GTA 5) you could kill the NPC after the mission is done as they become a regular NPC with a few benefits in the world.
But after killing them you got a SMS talking mad and sending you the hospital bill.
I can more agree with the specific-likeness argument. Well put.
GTA is filled with characters that cannot be killed. That includes children, this why children are almost never portrayed in any GTA game, and when they are it is cut scenes only. Violence against certain characters are automatic game overs as well, punishing the player with a save reload. They can be both minority and non minority characters under this kind of protection if they’re part of the plot.
Everyone is entitled to their opinion. But you are basing yours in completely erroneous information or a distorted perception of reality. If you truly are an ally to trans folk, be careful with this argument. It is extremely similar to conservative “anti-woke” talking points.
Is the “completely erroneous information” limited to the fact that other non-killable characters exist? Because that does not go against my point about the line.
Only siths deal in absolutes. One can be an ally and question corporate narratives dawg.
“Only sith deal in absolutes” is itself an absolute. It’s meant to underscore the hypocrisy of the council. You’re basically calling yourself a hypocrite without realizing it by quoting it.
Here’s a dump question. If killing a special character is automatic game over…then there is a way to play the game. Can you win. What is the objective. Is it like the sims or animal crossing.
Huh?
Huh?
Yeah you can’t kill kids in GTA but you can kill sex workers, Latinos, black people etc.
Then feel free to correct them
Even a broken clock is right twice a day. This is performative rainbow capitalism from a company only interested in their bottom line. Right wingers are pissed at this for the wrong reason, but token diversity is not something that should be encouraged.
Well.
It doesn’t. The existence of a counterexample nullifies the hypothesis.
They are. One minority, like sexual workers, not being protected is not evidence of “no minority” being protected. Children, pregnant women, people with disabilities and other minorities have been protected in GTA in the past. Last game had a bisexual main character.
A documented dog whistle from right wing political rhetoric as code for anything they dislike and whenever they can’t exploit someone else.
Which GTAV character was bi?
Trevor.
The first person npc citizen I purposely killed in gta 6 was a older white woman who looked like Roseanne who called me a libtard. I shot both her knees out with a pistol the blew her head off with the shotgun.
Killing a plot relevant character has actual story relevance and mechanical implications. The game over makes sense mechanically. A side char does not. Your own argument is based on shaky ground as well.
Side chars almost universally have not had any form of protection in gta unless there was driect stated reasons for the game over/punishment.
Dear lord, just learn how to read. Or at least play the game franchise that you so much claim to have such a strong opinion about.
This not the first LGBT character that’s been protected in GTA. The fact that the average internet conservative misses that GTA’s overt violence is satyre against the US’s culture and has been woke for decades at this point makes me laugh.
Mandatory fuck Rockstar and I hope that the union succeeds and every single executive that has ever proposed or approved a layoff get their dicks chopped and fall ass first into razor wire.
Honestly, I take no issue with this character being immortal…I do however take issue with the Jessishiking with the self valuation statement though. Like, ma’am you are not just a product, you are a whole person that has more value than just money making potential! I am noticing a lot of chuds in the comments saying a lot of words that essentially give me the vibe of, “They really want to kill a trans character (as they are afraid to do it in real life), but they want it to seem like they’re arguing from a game world freedom perspective. Players should be free to kill any NPC (particularly this character).” Ugh, how cursed.
The reason GTA VI is woke is because woke is illegal on Florida 😂
So lame that they are blocking certain NPCs such as protesters and protected minorities.
I still remember the original GTA (yeah i’m old) where you could literally mow down a group of Hare Krishnas who were parading on the sidewalk.
Good times!
Not good times.
GOURANGA!!
Wow this brings me back.
Viva GTA2 London 1969 😎
Are they? I was speeding over a bridge and there was traffic jam that I hit at high speed. Turns out protesters had blocked the bridge. I was annoyed so came back finish the job and one of the protesters said something like Oh my god they killed (some name I forget)…
Are the protestors an invisible wall that gates a gameplay area until mission progress unlocks it? That would explain their immortality.
No, they are npc’s that I mowed into and killed a bunch. That’s my point, they were quite mortal.
GOURANGA!
How long until the mods where you can kill thr character?
Ugh, this character is going to be a focal point for culture war bullshit. Someone will publish a mod, the mod will get taken down, and everyone including people who are indifferent about the character’s immortality will get pissed off.
It feels weird to me that the game where you can grab a random woman on the street, throw her on the ground and beat her to death would prevent you from attacking a trans person to “mitigate anti-trans violence.”
Like, either violence in videogames is problematic and leads to negative outcomes or it doesn’t, right? I can see either individual take, i.e. “beating random people to death is bad and shouldn’t be part of our core gameplay loop,” or “videogame violence isn’t real violence and doesn’t lead anyone to be more violent in real life, so of course it’s allowed.” But this weird middle ground of “violence is fine unless it’s against trans people” feels wild to me.
Have I lost the plot here? Is the societal position now that women being assaulted isn’t a big enough deal to stop people from doing it in a videogame but trans people being assaulted is? That seems backwards af to me. But maybe I’m just old and out of touch. Idk.
Well it’s not like you can check the medical history or inspect the bodies of those random people you brutalize or kill to check if they’re cis or trans anyway.
GTA has always had some characters be unkillable, framing this as a special thing they did for this one character and nobody else is a misunderstanding of how the game works. ‘We’re making it so that right wing chuds can’t create hundreds of gifs of beating your character to death to send to you’ is probably something that most trans video game actresses are wanting in their contracts around now.
There is a difference between key story characters and random side npcs tho. Historically a story critical char is unkillable. Any random npc is killable.
This is firmly in the arbitrary choice to make a poltical or moral motivated change to the status quo. Wether or not thats ok is an arguement and i can honestly see both sides to it.
Not allowing it helps but at the same time it does feel almost under mining the entire point of the gang violence murder simulator…
Sure, and if it was framed that way I would get it. Plenty of key NPCs are unkillable, and if it was just about that one actor being worried about their image being used that way I could get behind that I think.
But the language used here was that the decision was made “to mitigate trans violence,” which begs the question a bit on “can video games cause violence.”
The GTA series has long been the poster child of the “no they cannot” side, so it feels weird to prevent you from killing a trans person if the reason was in fact born out of wanting to prevent trans violence.
I think you’re reading too much into it and that sentence is about making images of violence against trans people.
I think the thing here is that while a game that allows you to generally cause violence or go on a rampage might not directly cause someone to generally become more violent… as was previously mentioned, a million GIFs of someone going up and specifically targeting a trans person to kill them over and over might increase real-life hatred for trans people, or normalize taking out violence specifically on trans people over other groups.
It’s the same reason you just won’t see kids roaming the streets in GTA V off on their way to school for example. You don’t want it to be that easy for someone to glorify mass murder of children, or a school shooting, because aside from the optics, we know that a lot of school shooters are often slowly groomed into the people they end up being when they commit the shootings through online culture, and I think we can all agree online culture is often influenced by video games, especially one of this scale.
Essentially, I think there’s not much evidence to support that generally violent video games tend to make people more violent towards everyone, but there is evidence to support that the ability to create media of specific, targeted groups having violence done towards them is usually something that spreads and normalizes rhetoric and actions like hate crimes far more effectively than when it’s not possible.
Ironically, the often brought up point about sex workers in GTA being killable is one I think illustrates this point very well. Many people already have low opinions of sex workers, and being able to specifically target and kill them in GTA V likely helped contribute to many young people learning the lesson that it’s more justified to do, or that it’s more morally justified to not care about actions done to sex workers, because of their portrayal as being on a lower run of the societal ladder, all while people repeatedly joke about intentionally targeting and killing them.
Obviously they’re not going to think “if I went into the streets and shot a sex worker tomorrow, it’d be justified”, but I think it can indeed contribute to a different perception of them.
It’s a trans person speaking to their audience. Stop looking for conspiracy
Well I didn’t play the game yet, I don’t know how it works out, but is it better to have a video online of a NPC which is getting shot, knifed or whatever constantly, even if the NPC doesn’t die?
I haven’t played it either because I don’t have a PS5, but in previous games IIRC your attacks sort of just phase through unkillable characters and they either run away or aggro against you.
I’m pretty sure there were characters who existed solely for cutscenes meaning you literally couldn’t interact with them in game.
[deleted]
Well, assurance that a vulnerable demographic won’t get targeted could be a variety of things but I don’t think it’s R* choosing a specific group to be free from hate crimes while turning a blind eye to other vulnerable populations. Previously, they’ve made conscious decisions about who gets hurt or not in plot related scenarios but allow freedom when it’s just wonton acts of violence (like murdering sex workers and such).
Personally I think it might just be that you can’t target named NPCs anyway, and this particular character isn’t going to be targeted in the plot for the “mitigated trans violence” reason. But that’s my guess, I’m not playing it for another few years probably. Lol
https://lemmy.zip/pictrs/image/af649b48-281c-4f4c-bd46-93154bef3e84.avif (It’s wanton)
Lol thanks, my phone tends to screw me up when spelling things but I’m not even going to fix it now, hehe.
I think it’s more to prevent right wing groups using the game to push their viewpoints. If it was possible there’d be clips all over the internet of people torturing this person and using that to push their message. It’s an inflammatory time in politics, and not allowing your game to be used in that way makes sense to me.
That being said fuck Rockstar and their union-busting management.
I hear that argument, and I don’t think it’s baseless, but it seems weak to me.
It’s not like there aren’t going to be day 1 mods allowing you to bypass those restrictions and make that content anyway, so I’m not sure it actually stops that problem.
And I’m not sure that anyone is actually “pushing messaging” with edgelord videos of GTA gameplay. I’m sure you’ll get edgy 16yos posting that kind of content, but I think the idea that there will be Nazis coming out of the woodwork playing GTA6 just to make propaganda might be a bit of an overblown concern.
I respect that, I think it being a console exclusive might show down the mods by maybe a day. Not much I agree.
I would have to disagree that Nazis wouldn’t be open to using Gta 6 to push propaganda. I think they’re mostly edgy children that are looking for attention, lacking media literacy or maybe actual literacy, so gravitating to the biggest thing out there is not out of the question. All you really need is one clip to go viral and suddenly it’s a media feast. I’m sure that’ll still happen as you said, but I don’t think the effort is misplaced.
You should be allowed to do whatever you want tbh. I don’t think there’s anything morally wrong with being able to attack anyone you want in a videogame. It would be disturbing if you deliberately go only after them all the time. Enforcing some kind of morality from a game series that used to let you have sex with prostitutes as well as kill said prostitutes, rabbis, gay club attendees, and cops just seems like grandstanding.
We live in a very different world today. When gta5 was released, images of a character killing a prostitute were limited to people actually playing the game at home, and maybe a handful of YouTube videos that you would have to seek out to view.
Today, any nut job could stream themselves going on a trans-focused rampaged in the game and have their short form and live streaming content monetised and pushed to thousands of people by big tech algorithms. It’s also not crazy to suggest that there is an audience of very hateful broken people for this sort of content.
While I do find it interesting what Rockstar has decided is and isn’t possible in their game world, I can at least recognise the larger cultural and societal contexts that informed some of their decisions.
GTA has changed over the years. GTA 1 was a game about 'going mad and killing people. It was fun but, for what it was, not a patch on Carmageddon which came out the same year.
The move towards realism has, necessarily, resulted in a change in the way the world reacts to your criminal shenanigans. So, now, GTA 6 is a game about consequences.
Good to know, I will go play celeste now. Screw 200 GB games with history of worker oppression.
The “mitigate trans violence” thing is such bullshit you can see through. This should be a game where you do literally anything no matter what but in hta 6 for some reason certain npcs are untouchable which kinda ruins the immersion. For example penguinz0 said he tried to attack a pizza delivery guy to take his scooter and the pizza he was delivering but he couldnt. I think “protecting” certain npcs will just create more controversy and is completely out of spirit of the game. Imagine if they did this with every volnurable group in game, you launch a fucking bazooka at the store and all the straight cis adult males and women die but everyone else is just involnurable.
They already do this with kids. You meet kids only in cut-scenes, and I guess that’s the same for this character.
Does that mean they protect kids and trans people more than, let’s say women or racial minorities? Sure, but a world only inhabitated by straight white men would seem strange, so you have to draw the line somewhere.
The correct spelling is ‘invulnerable’. I mention this purely as an FYI and not as critique or a way to reduce/ignore the points you’re trying to make.
Have a great day!
You’re a good person.
I have my moments. I definitely try to be.
Here’s where I’d like to be able to say:
Don’t we all.
But…
Vice City without the pizza side mission?
What has the world come to?!
This will, and probably already has had, the exact opposite effect. As, I’m assuming, the companies involved are perfectly aware, because that was their sole intention.
…
I’m sorry but #4 is an absolutely stupid thing to have in a GTA game.
People when they don’t get to kill trans people
I mean, y’all know GTA has always had people you couldn’t kill right? But now that it’s a trans character y’all are mad you can’t shoot them? The fuck’s that say about you.
Are you trying to say that my killing all the other random civilians and police (acab am i rite) in a game like GTA is just fine example of pretending things that could never happen in real life but if there’s a trans person getting the bullets, that’s somehow significantly worse? Are you saying, like the conservatives in the 80s and 90s, that games are causing murders?
It’s a stupid thing to have in a game like GTA and overemphasizes how weird and different trans people are and how fragile the whole concept is. I would like to think that the point is to normalize them.
No, I dislike when my people are snowflaked like if we’re weak and damsels in distress that need protection.
Have you looked around lately at all? We do need protection and we get precisely none. You’re not helping when you say you find the game lacking because you specifically can not shoot a trans person. Our trans friends are being murdered everywhere already. This is the game telling you ‘don’t murder trans people’. Don’t like the message, don’t buy the ‘don’t kill trans people’ game.
Really not a good look
In a game where you can kill anyone why are trans people exempt from that?
What makes them more important than any of the other people you can kill?
The message I got was “trans people are special don’t kill them”
Yeah I love all the other stuff except for this one.
Sign in to comment. Sign in