It feels weird to me that the game where you can grab a random woman on the street, throw her on the ground and beat her to death would prevent you from attacking a trans person to “mitigate anti-trans violence.”
Like, either violence in videogames is problematic and leads to negative outcomes or it doesn’t, right? I can see either individual take, i.e. “beating random people to death is bad and shouldn’t be part of our core gameplay loop,” or “videogame violence isn’t real violence and doesn’t lead anyone to be more violent in real life, so of course it’s allowed.” But this weird middle ground of “violence is fine unless it’s against trans people” feels wild to me.
Have I lost the plot here? Is the societal position now that women being assaulted isn’t a big enough deal to stop people from doing it in a videogame but trans people being assaulted is? That seems backwards af to me. But maybe I’m just old and out of touch. Idk.
Well it’s not like you can check the medical history or inspect the bodies of those random people you brutalize or kill to check if they’re cis or trans anyway.
GTA has always had some characters be unkillable, framing this as a special thing they did for this one character and nobody else is a misunderstanding of how the game works. ‘We’re making it so that right wing chuds can’t create hundreds of gifs of beating your character to death to send to you’ is probably something that most trans video game actresses are wanting in their contracts around now.
There is a difference between key story characters and random side npcs tho. Historically a story critical char is unkillable. Any random npc is killable.
This is firmly in the arbitrary choice to make a poltical or moral motivated change to the status quo. Wether or not thats ok is an arguement and i can honestly see both sides to it.
Not allowing it helps but at the same time it does feel almost under mining the entire point of the gang violence murder simulator…
Sure, and if it was framed that way I would get it. Plenty of key NPCs are unkillable, and if it was just about that one actor being worried about their image being used that way I could get behind that I think.
But the language used here was that the decision was made “to mitigate trans violence,” which begs the question a bit on “can video games cause violence.”
The GTA series has long been the poster child of the “no they cannot” side, so it feels weird to prevent you from killing a trans person if the reason was in fact born out of wanting to prevent trans violence.
I think the thing here is that while a game that allows you to generally cause violence or go on a rampage might not directly cause someone to generally become more violent… as was previously mentioned, a million GIFs of someone going up and specifically targeting a trans person to kill them over and over might increase real-life hatred for trans people, or normalize taking out violence specifically on trans people over other groups.
It’s the same reason you just won’t see kids roaming the streets in GTA V off on their way to school for example. You don’t want it to be that easy for someone to glorify mass murder of children, or a school shooting, because aside from the optics, we know that a lot of school shooters are often slowly groomed into the people they end up being when they commit the shootings through online culture, and I think we can all agree online culture is often influenced by video games, especially one of this scale.
Essentially, I think there’s not much evidence to support that generally violent video games tend to make people more violent towards everyone, but there is evidence to support that the ability to create media of specific, targeted groups having violence done towards them is usually something that spreads and normalizes rhetoric and actions like hate crimes far more effectively than when it’s not possible.
Ironically, the often brought up point about sex workers in GTA being killable is one I think illustrates this point very well. Many people already have low opinions of sex workers, and being able to specifically target and kill them in GTA V likely helped contribute to many young people learning the lesson that it’s more justified to do, or that it’s more morally justified to not care about actions done to sex workers, because of their portrayal as being on a lower run of the societal ladder, all while people repeatedly joke about intentionally targeting and killing them.
Obviously they’re not going to think “if I went into the streets and shot a sex worker tomorrow, it’d be justified”, but I think it can indeed contribute to a different perception of them.
Well I didn’t play the game yet, I don’t know how it works out, but is it better to have a video online of a NPC which is getting shot, knifed or whatever constantly, even if the NPC doesn’t die?
I haven’t played it either because I don’t have a PS5, but in previous games IIRC your attacks sort of just phase through unkillable characters and they either run away or aggro against you.
Well, assurance that a vulnerable demographic won’t get targeted could be a variety of things but I don’t think it’s R* choosing a specific group to be free from hate crimes while turning a blind eye to other vulnerable populations. Previously, they’ve made conscious decisions about who gets hurt or not in plot related scenarios but allow freedom when it’s just wonton acts of violence (like murdering sex workers and such).
Personally I think it might just be that you can’t target named NPCs anyway, and this particular character isn’t going to be targeted in the plot for the “mitigated trans violence” reason. But that’s my guess, I’m not playing it for another few years probably. Lol
I think it’s more to prevent right wing groups using the game to push their viewpoints. If it was possible there’d be clips all over the internet of people torturing this person and using that to push their message. It’s an inflammatory time in politics, and not allowing your game to be used in that way makes sense to me.
That being said fuck Rockstar and their union-busting management.
I hear that argument, and I don’t think it’s baseless, but it seems weak to me.
It’s not like there aren’t going to be day 1 mods allowing you to bypass those restrictions and make that content anyway, so I’m not sure it actually stops that problem.
And I’m not sure that anyone is actually “pushing messaging” with edgelord videos of GTA gameplay. I’m sure you’ll get edgy 16yos posting that kind of content, but I think the idea that there will be Nazis coming out of the woodwork playing GTA6 just to make propaganda might be a bit of an overblown concern.
I respect that, I think it being a console exclusive might show down the mods by maybe a day. Not much I agree.
I would have to disagree that Nazis wouldn’t be open to using Gta 6 to push propaganda. I think they’re mostly edgy children that are looking for attention, lacking media literacy or maybe actual literacy, so gravitating to the biggest thing out there is not out of the question. All you really need is one clip to go viral and suddenly it’s a media feast. I’m sure that’ll still happen as you said, but I don’t think the effort is misplaced.
You should be allowed to do whatever you want tbh. I don’t think there’s anything morally wrong with being able to attack anyone you want in a videogame. It would be disturbing if you deliberately go only after them all the time. Enforcing some kind of morality from a game series that used to let you have sex with prostitutes as well as kill said prostitutes, rabbis, gay club attendees, and cops just seems like grandstanding.
We live in a very different world today. When gta5 was released, images of a character killing a prostitute were limited to people actually playing the game at home, and maybe a handful of YouTube videos that you would have to seek out to view.
Today, any nut job could stream themselves going on a trans-focused rampaged in the game and have their short form and live streaming content monetised and pushed to thousands of people by big tech algorithms. It’s also not crazy to suggest that there is an audience of very hateful broken people for this sort of content.
While I do find it interesting what Rockstar has decided is and isn’t possible in their game world, I can at least recognise the larger cultural and societal contexts that informed some of their decisions.
I agree with your take (and, amusingly, I also agree with the top comment under yours disagreeing with you, which is rare, but means it’s a good discussion).
You can look at it flipped. There are random killable characters and plot-critical unkillable characters. If you’re an actor who feels vulnerable, you can make a choice to play one of the unkillable ones. I don’t know the plot but I assume that the museum curator being played by a trans actor is not central to it.
I think, in this case, it’s more that this is recognizably a real person that exists outside of the character and while they’re not too bothered by bad publicity, they don’t want the game to be used to personally harras one of their actors.
Of course all violence is bad, but they have chosen to allow it for a game like this. The thing they are trying to prevent right there is someone explicitly targeting the trans person and expressing violence on them, because this explicitly shows transphobic trends.
You are right however about the women, but I guess they have chosen not to care for them :/
Comments
It feels weird to me that the game where you can grab a random woman on the street, throw her on the ground and beat her to death would prevent you from attacking a trans person to “mitigate anti-trans violence.”
Like, either violence in videogames is problematic and leads to negative outcomes or it doesn’t, right? I can see either individual take, i.e. “beating random people to death is bad and shouldn’t be part of our core gameplay loop,” or “videogame violence isn’t real violence and doesn’t lead anyone to be more violent in real life, so of course it’s allowed.” But this weird middle ground of “violence is fine unless it’s against trans people” feels wild to me.
Have I lost the plot here? Is the societal position now that women being assaulted isn’t a big enough deal to stop people from doing it in a videogame but trans people being assaulted is? That seems backwards af to me. But maybe I’m just old and out of touch. Idk.
Well it’s not like you can check the medical history or inspect the bodies of those random people you brutalize or kill to check if they’re cis or trans anyway.
GTA has always had some characters be unkillable, framing this as a special thing they did for this one character and nobody else is a misunderstanding of how the game works. ‘We’re making it so that right wing chuds can’t create hundreds of gifs of beating your character to death to send to you’ is probably something that most trans video game actresses are wanting in their contracts around now.
There is a difference between key story characters and random side npcs tho. Historically a story critical char is unkillable. Any random npc is killable.
This is firmly in the arbitrary choice to make a poltical or moral motivated change to the status quo. Wether or not thats ok is an arguement and i can honestly see both sides to it.
Not allowing it helps but at the same time it does feel almost under mining the entire point of the gang violence murder simulator…
Sure, and if it was framed that way I would get it. Plenty of key NPCs are unkillable, and if it was just about that one actor being worried about their image being used that way I could get behind that I think.
But the language used here was that the decision was made “to mitigate trans violence,” which begs the question a bit on “can video games cause violence.”
The GTA series has long been the poster child of the “no they cannot” side, so it feels weird to prevent you from killing a trans person if the reason was in fact born out of wanting to prevent trans violence.
I think you’re reading too much into it and that sentence is about making images of violence against trans people.
I think the thing here is that while a game that allows you to generally cause violence or go on a rampage might not directly cause someone to generally become more violent… as was previously mentioned, a million GIFs of someone going up and specifically targeting a trans person to kill them over and over might increase real-life hatred for trans people, or normalize taking out violence specifically on trans people over other groups.
It’s the same reason you just won’t see kids roaming the streets in GTA V off on their way to school for example. You don’t want it to be that easy for someone to glorify mass murder of children, or a school shooting, because aside from the optics, we know that a lot of school shooters are often slowly groomed into the people they end up being when they commit the shootings through online culture, and I think we can all agree online culture is often influenced by video games, especially one of this scale.
Essentially, I think there’s not much evidence to support that generally violent video games tend to make people more violent towards everyone, but there is evidence to support that the ability to create media of specific, targeted groups having violence done towards them is usually something that spreads and normalizes rhetoric and actions like hate crimes far more effectively than when it’s not possible.
Ironically, the often brought up point about sex workers in GTA being killable is one I think illustrates this point very well. Many people already have low opinions of sex workers, and being able to specifically target and kill them in GTA V likely helped contribute to many young people learning the lesson that it’s more justified to do, or that it’s more morally justified to not care about actions done to sex workers, because of their portrayal as being on a lower run of the societal ladder, all while people repeatedly joke about intentionally targeting and killing them.
Obviously they’re not going to think “if I went into the streets and shot a sex worker tomorrow, it’d be justified”, but I think it can indeed contribute to a different perception of them.
It’s a trans person speaking to their audience. Stop looking for conspiracy
Well I didn’t play the game yet, I don’t know how it works out, but is it better to have a video online of a NPC which is getting shot, knifed or whatever constantly, even if the NPC doesn’t die?
I haven’t played it either because I don’t have a PS5, but in previous games IIRC your attacks sort of just phase through unkillable characters and they either run away or aggro against you.
I’m pretty sure there were characters who existed solely for cutscenes meaning you literally couldn’t interact with them in game.
[deleted]
Well, assurance that a vulnerable demographic won’t get targeted could be a variety of things but I don’t think it’s R* choosing a specific group to be free from hate crimes while turning a blind eye to other vulnerable populations. Previously, they’ve made conscious decisions about who gets hurt or not in plot related scenarios but allow freedom when it’s just wonton acts of violence (like murdering sex workers and such).
Personally I think it might just be that you can’t target named NPCs anyway, and this particular character isn’t going to be targeted in the plot for the “mitigated trans violence” reason. But that’s my guess, I’m not playing it for another few years probably. Lol
https://lemmy.zip/pictrs/image/af649b48-281c-4f4c-bd46-93154bef3e84.avif (It’s wanton)
Lol thanks, my phone tends to screw me up when spelling things but I’m not even going to fix it now, hehe.
I think it’s more to prevent right wing groups using the game to push their viewpoints. If it was possible there’d be clips all over the internet of people torturing this person and using that to push their message. It’s an inflammatory time in politics, and not allowing your game to be used in that way makes sense to me.
That being said fuck Rockstar and their union-busting management.
I hear that argument, and I don’t think it’s baseless, but it seems weak to me.
It’s not like there aren’t going to be day 1 mods allowing you to bypass those restrictions and make that content anyway, so I’m not sure it actually stops that problem.
And I’m not sure that anyone is actually “pushing messaging” with edgelord videos of GTA gameplay. I’m sure you’ll get edgy 16yos posting that kind of content, but I think the idea that there will be Nazis coming out of the woodwork playing GTA6 just to make propaganda might be a bit of an overblown concern.
I respect that, I think it being a console exclusive might show down the mods by maybe a day. Not much I agree.
I would have to disagree that Nazis wouldn’t be open to using Gta 6 to push propaganda. I think they’re mostly edgy children that are looking for attention, lacking media literacy or maybe actual literacy, so gravitating to the biggest thing out there is not out of the question. All you really need is one clip to go viral and suddenly it’s a media feast. I’m sure that’ll still happen as you said, but I don’t think the effort is misplaced.
You should be allowed to do whatever you want tbh. I don’t think there’s anything morally wrong with being able to attack anyone you want in a videogame. It would be disturbing if you deliberately go only after them all the time. Enforcing some kind of morality from a game series that used to let you have sex with prostitutes as well as kill said prostitutes, rabbis, gay club attendees, and cops just seems like grandstanding.
We live in a very different world today. When gta5 was released, images of a character killing a prostitute were limited to people actually playing the game at home, and maybe a handful of YouTube videos that you would have to seek out to view.
Today, any nut job could stream themselves going on a trans-focused rampaged in the game and have their short form and live streaming content monetised and pushed to thousands of people by big tech algorithms. It’s also not crazy to suggest that there is an audience of very hateful broken people for this sort of content.
While I do find it interesting what Rockstar has decided is and isn’t possible in their game world, I can at least recognise the larger cultural and societal contexts that informed some of their decisions.
I agree with your take (and, amusingly, I also agree with the top comment under yours disagreeing with you, which is rare, but means it’s a good discussion).
You can look at it flipped. There are random killable characters and plot-critical unkillable characters. If you’re an actor who feels vulnerable, you can make a choice to play one of the unkillable ones. I don’t know the plot but I assume that the museum curator being played by a trans actor is not central to it.
I think, in this case, it’s more that this is recognizably a real person that exists outside of the character and while they’re not too bothered by bad publicity, they don’t want the game to be used to personally harras one of their actors.
Of course all violence is bad, but they have chosen to allow it for a game like this. The thing they are trying to prevent right there is someone explicitly targeting the trans person and expressing violence on them, because this explicitly shows transphobic trends.
You are right however about the women, but I guess they have chosen not to care for them :/
Sign in to comment. Sign in