53
Cordless power tools
I don’t have very much experience on cordless tools apart from using DeWalt at home and Makita at work, both at a DIY level capacity. The 18V era is as capable as I will ever need. While trying to expand the range of tools at home though, the influx of house brands (Worksite at my local store) at very low prices became enticing. These items often advertise battery compatibility with big brands and seem sturdy enough. Wonder what everybody is using and how did you make the decision?
Comments
Other than a drill cordless tools make little sense for DIY. Just prepare your work station an do the work there. If you’re not stealing catalytic converters or working on sites with no electricity you really don’t need to carry your tools around and it’s safer to unplug them when not in use.
I started out with Dewalt after buying my house but have since shifted to Bauer from Harbor Freight for new tool purchases since the batteries are like 1/3 the price. Ive tried some Chinese Dewalt batteries from Amazon and they gave up the ghost after about 6 months of light use. I just cant justify spending $200 on a single brand-name battery so im still rocking all the 2AH “included with the kit” batteries for my Dewalt tools.
My sister also gifted me a Mikwaukee electric ratchet which works great and has great battery life. If I were to start over I’d probably go with Milwaukee instead of Dewalt since they have by far the biggest selection of cordless tools. After that would be Bauer but theyre fairly limited and are mostly automotive related stuff outside of basic drills and impact drivers.
Makita are unique in that they design using standard parts and they publish schematics freely, which minimises long term cost of ownership if you’re handy
I have a small cordless metabo screwdriver / drill, and that’s it. Everything else is still with cord.
The decision was just because of the better mobility of the small one. I don’t want a cordless “fleet”.
If you really want to go down a rabbit hole, check out the torque test channel on YouTube.
They have expanded into quite a few different tool types, although originally they only tested the torque of impact drivers. (Hence the name)
I think it was around 2008, when 18v was pretty new, I got a dewalt drill and bit driver. The pair were on sale at the hardware store. Used lightly for work and home, and mostly lived in truck. 5 years later I bought more 18v dewalt because they still worked great. That first bit driver is in rough shape now, but still runs. Batteries hang in quite well. Have an adaptor and use dewalt batteries to power a GPS base station.
Whatever brand you pick, always shop sales, especially for batteries.
All the major brands have deals like “buy a tool, get a free battery” or “buy 1 battery, get another free” or “buy 1 battery, get a tool free”.
Personally, I like Milwaukee M12 system for home. It’s cheaper than the 18v stuff while still getting Milwaukee quality, plus the chargers work with both, so any tool i need that’s m18 only will use the same charger. Dewalt also has a very capable 12v line of tools.
The full m12 hamner-drill & impact driver kit cost the same as the m18 hammer-drill kit.
For the random home brads do a bit of reasearch. Personally I would avoid “Worksite” due the lack of online presence at major retailer. Their own website lists a whole ton of tools (no prices), but they’re non-existant anywhere else besides a amazon store page that only has few tire inflators and batteries. You can’t price compare to anything. (And I’m pretty confident there is AI in the marketing images, at least the web banner for sure)
The claim that it works with “big-brand” batteires, is very likely bullshit. I didn’t see any indication of that on their website, and the battery on the amazon store says “for worksite tools only”. It does look very similar to dewalt, so maybe it does work and they just don’t talk about it?
Anyway, ignoreing the battery thing, my biggest question is who do you go to if the things stops working? 1 month your local store might take care of it, but what about in 3 months or 3 years? Worksite’s website has no warrenty info and the only contact info is for china. Most of the name brands you can walk into the store you bought it from and they’ll get you squared away. Even Harbor Frieght has a clear, and easy to deal with warranty.
As I’m sure you’ve gathered from all the replies, it doesn’t really matter. Some brands’ designs for one tool might be a little better than average, a different brand might have a different better tool, but in the big picture they’re all pretty comparative.
I fix tools as part of my job and most of the bigger names are about the same inside.
I buy Makita for personal use simply because they are an independent company. Most places I’ve worked use Milwaukee.
One side note, Craftsman is just a brand name, it has never been one company. It’s always been sourced from mid/low tier suppliers.
If it’s for home use, any of the Name Brands are good.
Also,If it’s for home use,do you even need a battery? They are bulky, they wear out,
charger goes missing, the power connections go obsolete, they arent charged up on the day you need to use them.
Also,wired is safer if you have other people,kids or pets around,as you can just plug them out if you are looking at something else and need to let the tool sit for a while.
I bought into ryobi
My reasons were
They’re cheap. No, they’re often not the most heavy-duty of tools, but they’ve been more than adequate for my needs as a somewhat advanced DIY homeowner type. If I was really putting my tools through their pages on a job site day in and day out and relying on them to make a living I probably would’ve invested a bit more in them.
Piggybacking off of that, I discovered Direct Tools Outlet, where you can get their returns/refurbished/factory-blemished stuff for cheap. They also handle rigid and one or two other brands, and I’m sure most of the other brands have their own similar outlet thing, but I don’t see them talked about as much as DTO.
They have a pretty huge selection of tools available, I’m pretty confident that they make every power tool I may ever need, and it’s nice that they all run on the same battery. They make a lot of stuff I don’t see myself ever needing too, but you never know.
They’ve really stuck by their battery platform, if you have their old blue NiCad batteries and tools, they still work just fine with the newer bright green lithium stuff. You can still even buy a new charger for the NiCad batteries if you somehow still have some of those kicking around in working order. Some other brand have changed up their batteries once or twice over the years, so you’re kind of fucked if your older tools or batteries shit the bed and you kind of need to start over with brand new stuff. And I don’t really see that changing anytime soon because it feels like they’ve made the battery a pretty big part of their brand identity. They’ve added a couple other parallel lines like the 40v outdoor stuff and their little USB rechargeable tools (and I do have a couple of the USB tools as well, and I think they’re great) but I’m not seeing any signs that they’re going to drastically change or drop their main tool/battery line anytime soon.
I like the bright green. Nothing else in the sorts of places I’m working is that color, so if I set my drill down in a pile of junk I can always spot it right away.
I’ve been happy with the 40v stuff. They also have a 300W inverter that takes those batteries, and they’ve got a few power stations that use 4 6Ah batteries to give 1800W. I haven’t seen any reviews of the power stations (versus all the product reviews of something like a jackery), but having removable, multi-function cells is a pretty neat idea that I hope has legs.
I personally stick with Makita, they seem like great tools and hold their value surprisingly well if you plan on selling them at some point.
https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/2b2e330d-4d1c-481e-999e-5c6799081be6.jpeg
Ryobi is without a doubt Hufflepuff
Missing the 5th house, Ridgid.
Lifetime warranty crew!!
And Black&Decker
Maybe i made a mistake but I ended up with Kobalt.
If I had not gotten into rigid when I worked at Home Depot I likely would have gone with kobalt.
[deleted]
By whatever brand is available, fits your budget and has a wide enough selection of tools for your needs. It makes no difference for the vast majority of users. This is not as important decision as it might feel like. It only starts to matter if you’re a professional and you’re relying on them every day. Makita is arguably the best overall but the price reflects that as well.
I’m a carpenter. I use Dewalt, because the first tool I got after moving out of my parent’s house, was a dewalt drill, and I don’t want a bunch of different batteries laying around.
Truth is, it doesn’t matter which brand you use. In the end it’s mostly religion. If you don’t plan on building a house, most discount tools will work just fine for those 2 times per year you need to drill a hole, og saw a plank with a circular saw. If you’re only going to use an impact drill a few times per year, the cheap one for $20 is likely going to last you a lifetime. Don’t get caught up in branding, it’s all mostly the same, unless you’re a professional who uses the tools every single minute of every single day.
If you’re going to use it that infrequently, you’d have to make a good case for getting a battery-powered tool–there’s two more things that can go wrong or get lost.
For occasional use, I get a lot of value out of corded tools and portable power station. I can use the power station for camping, too.
You’re a genius!
https://lemmy.zip/pictrs/image/1bdbdb81-769a-417c-9c80-5855a4af9bb7.gif
I don’t like dewalt, every company seems to buy dewalt and I’ve never liked them. They feel cheap and I’ve seen many dewalt tools break.
I like rigid because they’re made by the same company as Milwaukee and ryobi, are generally cheaper, its homedepot brand so easy to get anywhere, easy to return if they break(I’ve never broken a rigid tool).
Torque Test Channel on youtube if you want some data. They have teated some cheaper brands as well.
In my experience,
Milwaukee has the best battery system, their tools are very good, but they are proud of their red shit and reflect it in the price. Invest if you dare, but I would not send Milwaukee as a first choice to a casual user who isn’t using them at least weekly.
DeWalt is pretty middling on tool and battery quality but theyre fine. Been through a lot of them broken at work. Has the largest support of aftermarket knockoff options though. I like dewalt for hand tools more than power tools.
Ryobi has some of the better tool selections out there- my dad still has 30+ year old Ryobi stuff kicking around from the NiCad battery days that works fine on new lithium ion batteries. Their li-ion batteries are super mid though, my dad has killed quite a few batteries that weren’t that old but just refuse to charge, even after “jump starting” them with another batt.
Makita, hilti, and others I have not had hands on experience with.
Most of the store brand stuff from Walmart, harbor freight, corner hardware stores, etc I usually avoid just because the tool selection is pretty limited and they don’t always have a real track record. I don’t want to invest in a tool, charger, and multiple batteries to have like 4 tools (drill, impact driver, a single circular saw and sometimes a vacuum lol) actually available.
Some good advice I’ve heard is to stick with the same brand of power tools as you do for yardwork tools (assuming you’re using battery powered stuff for yardwork). The batteries are interchangeable, you don’t have to keep track of a bunch of different chargers, and new stuff often comes with more batteries.
I use the same brand for my drills and saws as I do my lawnmower, weed wacker, and leaf blower. It’s glorious.
My mower is gas but having an electric trimmer and blower that use the same batteries as the rest of my tools is amazing.
I have been impressed with Hercules from Harbor Freight as a DIYer. I use their 20V tools.
Yeah, HF really stepped up their game over the years. I can’t speak about cordless, but recently I bought three corded tools and am impressed. Really solid and powerful. ‘Will need to replace my beloved DeWalt cordless driver soon and will seriously consider HF offerings.
Fun fact: 20V tools are actually 18 volt ones. 18 volt battery is about 20 volts when fully charged. It’s purely marketing to use the max voltage because it sounds higher than the nominal voltage of 18V but it’s the same thing.
I haven’t used mine super heavily but so far so good, they don’t feel cheap at all
We have 2 ranges.
Milwaukee for work. - started the range many years ago and really once you have a few items it’s easier to stick with them. Main items are all 10 years old now and still have some life left. Friend has all dewalt and they seem pretty solid too. (Saws/drills/sanders/multitool)
Ryobi for around the house/garden. It’s enough for small to medium-high task. Cheaper price point and decent garden/cleaning selection. I did have a problem with one garden tool, after a year, Ryobi were very accommodating in sorting it. I also use a few third party batteries with these product, which takes price point down quite a bit.
I did pick up a Hyundai cordless lawnmower, last year. Reason bigger battery and self propelled at a cheaper price to Ryobi. They messed up the sale sent a lesser product and blamed me, had to threaten with court action to get the product I paid for. Looked to be a beast on paper but has had a few faults, and is fussy with some grass types. Given Hyundais past cust service I’ll take it as a loss.
What third party batteries do you use for your Ryobi tools? I’m looking to add a spare but want to make sure a 3rd party brand is trustworthy.
I bought mine via eBay. I have had a few over the years, I’m sure there are internet recommendations of providers but I just popped on eBay and checked reviews. Usually a different seller each time.
I have a few sizes from the 2.5 to the 5H. The 5 has a lot more juice but is an uneven weight at one end for my hedge trimmer. I favour the 3.5/4 in general. The only tool that’s fussy is the small chainsaw. It only likes a 2.5.
Mine look like the pic below but it’s irrelevant really, I suppose reviews will be the best guide. I see no difference in performance against the genuine batteries. Infact I only have one genuine left now the 2.5. I’ve had no weird noises, no power drops…some are nearing 5/6 yr old, all the light indicators still work etc. I have about 6, I did have a few more but gave them away with the lawnmower.
image
I started the journey on team Makita, but their sawzall was very lackluster and I broke two cordless drills through heavy use so I switched to team Milwaukee just to test the waters and I never left.
Basically, some brands do certain tools better than the rest, and if said tool will be one of your main workhorses, I’d say that’s a pretty relevant factor. I still prefer team red’s sawzall over any other brand I’ve tried, even Hilti. Milwaukee also has a lot of specialized plumbing tools that other brands just don’t make.
I went with Makita way back because at that time they were the only one with a cordless router. I wanted it for working on the boat out on the mooring. Generally I’ve been super happy with them, haven’t had anything die yet. That being said I don’t use them every day, but I did use them for both work and home. I looooove the corded laminate trimmer of theirs.
I read a reddit post way back on this subject, and the person commenting was a professional in a very high end specialized shop. They said for 90% of the work they just used Ryobi tools and only for the last 10% that had to look perfect they used the super pro expensive tools. If they saw a sale on the Ryobi stuff they would stock up because they would just beat on them. Cheaper than doing that with the pro tools.
I’m not sure how this hasn’t been mentioned already, but Ridgid is the only brand that offers a “lifetime” warranty on batteries.
That’s important because the tools may last for decades but the batteries certainly won’t and are often the most expensive part.
I put lifetime in quotes because there are two caveats:
That being said, I’ve replaced half a dozen batteries under the warranty program and it’s been quick and painless (I’ve seen people who’ve had issues, so ymmv).
If you need a tool that’s not in Ridgid’s lineup you can always get a battery adapter without having to commit to a whole new battery ecosystem.
Ridgid also has a decent selection of outdoor tools too, weedeater, hedge trimmer, chainsaw, auger, etc. If yard maintainance is something important to you.
I’ve got Milwaukee cordless stuff, a mix between the 12v and 18v tools.
What originally got me onto Milwaukee was their M12 stubby impact wrench, it’s a nice little tool with a good amount of power behind it (quite useful for working on the bike and car). I’d been wanting a new drill and impact driver too to replace my old Makita (from their 12v nicd system) so the little impact swung the choice.
The 18v stuff came later when I wanted a proper angle grinder and a 3/4" impact (for working on some heavier machinery).
Haha it’s always the angle grinder. I’ve got the same M18 grinder and love that thing. The paddle switch and safety is pretty nifty, and it weighs less than my Ryobi beater.
I also have an M18 drill I’ve used to hell and back, and a reciprocating saw that might one day see use
Agree on 18 volt being a solid foundation. 20 volt packs are just 18 volt packs with some additional marketing.
I was on team orange back in 2010 in the early lithium days. Their batteries had no balancing at that time, which made me jump to team blue when the batteries became useless a year in. I’ve been on team blue ever since but…
I bought some team green 40 volt yard tools back in 2016 and have been hooked. Their string trimmer, edger, and poll trimmer have served me well. Although I have a team blue corded chainsaw, I bought a team green battery unit too.
If I was starting over I would probably just choose the brand that offers products in the segment(s) you care about. I’ve accumulated an 18 volt 1/4 impact, 1/2 drill, circular saw, sawzall, and angle grinder. The last three were pretty unique on the cordless market when I bought them and they’ve been very useful. Most of the mainstream brands will be more than performant enough for diy stuff.
Team orange? Rigid? Black and decker?
Rigid.
tl;dr I’m changing teams and needed to vent about it a bit.
I currently use Team Green for smaller powered hand tools, but my most recent purchase with them has unfortunately soured the relationship. Of the 3 tools in the combo, two of them lived absurdly short lives. The drill had some clutch issue that it fail when in high speed (it would not engage, allowing for a drill bit to be stationary while the drill made a lot very promising sounds), and the oscillating tool became a very lackluster flashlight after a few months, though it was very lightly used. The first wood blade (the only one I used) is in good condition. I’ve had one of their higher end impact drivers for quite awhile and it has been everything I’ve wanted it to be. Oh, and their sawzall is such poor quality that the blunt end of the blade managed to both knock off the guard, and when I continued using it because “shrug, guards pop off from the vibration all the time, I didn’t consider any further possibilities on why the guard would remove itself” friction cut its way through the housing and rather thin metal protective layer.
But since that particular purchase was so tragically awful, I’m considering changing teams. Red team is something I’d consider, but they are incredibly expensive to get started in. Yellow is alright, but I use them professionally and would rather not conflate ownership if ever the need pops up.
I think I may end up on team cyan, I just haven’t really looked into them in a long while and have no idea where they stand anymore, or the general accessibility of the brand.
Worst part about the ryobi sawzall was the tasks it has started to fail itself on. I was cutting through the less than one by sections of a few pallets. They were not in great shape and the diablo blade made short work of them. It seems like a rather large design flaw.
That stinks to hear. Team orange and team green are actually on the same team. On the 40v side of things, team green is the only house brand on offer, so they’re a pretty solid product. Both team green and team orange are available on the 18v side of things, with team green positioned as a lower tier.
Maybe this is something to put in the back of all our heads: there are multiple leagues each team competes in. Just because the same team is in a second lead does not mean that it will do well in that league.
Part of the reason I want to go cyan is because of this chart. They aren’t a part of the rest of the congealed corporate mess that nearly all the rest are. They are an island, along with Hilti among the mess.
https://lemmy.blahaj.zone/pictrs/image/d6802108-2386-416a-8343-522d995f1f4c.webp
Sign in to comment. Sign in