Skip to content

Comment on How can a fancy autocomplete / stochastic parrot solve the Riemann Hypothesis?

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments

Comments

  • Regardless of if it generated a legitimate proof for the Riemann Hypothesis or not, whatever was spat out is less than useless for everyone except maybe Anthropic Shareholders (due to the hype and their name being in the news).

    Mathematical proofs are not for their answer, they are for the logical breakthroughs and novel insights that solving a problem like this elicit. The useful extensions to the total collective of human knowledge, that can be reused and applied to other fields to further human development and advancement.

    The “proof” that was generated by the LLM is exactly as useful as a napkin with the words “The Riemann Hypothesis is True” written on it. An LLM generated 1.4gb Lean project, and it’s accompanying 250,000 page paper, is so useless to the field of Mathematics that it’s completely insulting to actual insightful work being done. Like the draft paper for an honest human written solution to the Generalised Riemann Hypothesis “The Music Of The Primes” written by Alessandro Maria Masullo who has been working on the paper for over a decade(!) and was less than a year to publication, but had to release it early due to the LLM publicity stunt that is Levent Alpöge/Anthropics “proof”.

    15
    • Mathematical proofs are in part for their answer. This is true for the Riemann Hypothesis more than any other conjecture, because it is SO big and important that an answer to it immediately solves hundreds of other questions.

      In a lot of cases a single theorem is not worth that much, but that’s very much not this case.

      And the Riemann Hypothesis is extremely easy to state in Lean, so it’s quite unlikely that a small infidelity has crept into the statement of the theorem, which is the big worry with a huge AI proof - in other words we can be really very confident about the truth of the Riemann Hypothesis now.

      0
    • Like the draft paper for an honest human written solution to the Generalised Riemann Hypothesis “The Music Of The Primes” written by Alessandro Maria Masullo who has been working on the paper for over a decade(!) and was less than a year to publication, but had to release it early due to the LLM publicity stunt that is Levent Alpöge/Anthropics “proof”.

      Lol! I bet the solution to the Generalised Riemann Hypothesis was in the LLM weights due to this.

      3
      • It’s definitely possible, there are a disturbing number of times where genuine pre-production work has been leaked by an AI company having access to data they shouldn’t.

        Though in this instance I don’t believe so as, before the draft was published to the internet, the “The Music Of The Primes” paper had only been shared with one other person, the author’s old Standford Professor/Mentor Brian Conrad. And from the initial surface evaluation of both I’ve heard, it seems the approach the Riemann Hypothesis with completely different methods.

        3

Sign in to comment. Sign in