Comment on Exclusive with a guy after several great dates but I'm feeling so conflicted after he told me he had a year-long affair with an engaged woman earlier this year; I would really appreciate any help
You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments
Comments
“Hall passes” is silly nonsense indicative of a failed marriage and failed values.
Polyamory has been a thing since forever. Try not to judge others just for holding to different (not lower) standards of morality.
Many things have been around forever, including cheating. The length of existence doesn’t justify the behaviour. I think I have the right to judge others based on my experiences, my marriage, my age, and having lived in 6 countries in 3 continents. Everyone has the right to judge everyone else and they actively do so. I disagree that polyamory is a workable framework for marriage, and that’s why the number of genuine polyamory marriages that exist in the world are probably 0.00001% of all marriages.
It’s alrind 5% in the usa and rising. Historically that number has been as high as 30% in some parts of the world.
The number rises and falls though history, most in relationship to religious invasions, war, or external pressures on places with high percentages.
It basically doesn’t work because religion doesn’t allow it to.
Otherwise it would hang around a quarter of relationships. A minority for sure, but not a overly small one.
[deleted]
Thank you, I agree! Does this mean what they did was explicit cheating, and my uneasiness about his enabling of said cheating is valid, regardless of one’s evaluation of “hall pass”? Especially since they blurred the lines with timing anyway. In other words, should I still try to trust him and work at this or how likely is it that I get hurt by future cheating? It’s unsettling not knowing the answer, fearing losing out on something good yet fearing being constantly afraid in the relationship
Understand that there are many different views of what is and isn’t ethical, and blindly accepting another person’s viewpoint when you have no idea of their overall moral framework is a recipe for disaster.
Honestly I can’t advise you as I’m not American. I’m 40 and I’ve been married 10 years, and if someone ever told me they had a Hall pass to sleep with others, I would just laugh. Maybe this is a new American thing or something young people are doing, I can’t keep up. But I honestly don’t see what sort of stratospheric levels of selfish individualism would lead a couple to think that’s ok and can work.
I think the race to bang as many people as possible and the treatment of sex as laudable conquest, and the development of dating apps turning everything into consumerism - has skewed people’s values and judgment irreparably. I thank god I started dating my wife just before the era of dating apps emerged.
In your situation, I think it depends on both of your ages. People change a lot as they get older and more mature and when they’re in long term relationships. It’s a risk that needs to be weighed with everything else, and honestly every relationship involves that kind of risk. You’ve presented us this one facet of his personality, but he could be a great person otherwise and this is just a silly mistake of a young kid. Only you can know
Sign in to comment. Sign in