Skip to content

Comment on Can proposing a fix to code with llm generated context prevent an issue from being fixed

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments

Comments

  • As much as I resent LLMs for seemingly taking away my career, a fix is a fix, and I find rejecting your fix just because you used a LLM at one point to be futile.

    0
    • Ehhh, technical debt is a thing and just because something fixes an issue doesn’t mean it’s code you want to have to maintain in perpetuity.

      9
    • I should say the GitHub does say no llm based pull request.

      I do suspect that contributer probably inserted llm code simply because they didn’t want to type out repetitive code.

      I wanted to be proactive about finding a solution to my bricked save and sharing the solution.

      I do have the mindset that capitalism is the problem not llms and llms are a tool

      0
      • Depending on the repo, they might be more annoyed about completely automated pull requests. As long as you write the pull request manually, are clear that you are a human, but you used AI, you may have some luck.

        4
        • Yeah, if you can explain the fix there’s no reason to reject it. If there’s 7k lines changed it’s going to get rejected. If it’s a clean 50 that fixes an issue it should be accepted. Doing PRs properly takes time and LLMs try to change more than needed

          4

Sign in to comment. Sign in