Alien life, although likely to exist somewhere out there (Its quite literally mathematically impossible for it NOT to) in some form, even if microscopic.
But it has never and will never pop by for a visit. Its never been here. And has no reason to ever come here.
A civilisation that is technologically capable of making the trip is, by default, also technologically advanced enough to not need anything from some hostile primates on a malfunctioning planet.
Aren’t we kinda capable of going to another solar system? Multiple generations of travel perhaps, and at an extreme cost. But with technology we have today it could potentially be possible.
So, does that mean they would have to be vastly more advanced than us?
Although it probably is a fairly narrow band of development. That said we have no idea the speed of development another species would be capable of compared to us.
Using a laser beam to push a solar sail dragging a mini probe behind it (which is the closest thing as are even relatively close to) is a far far far cry from having the self-sustaining life-support technology to last the centuries it would take to get there.
The only way a “human” will ever experience a different solar system or galaxy is if we do reach singularity, and decide to copy conscience to programing and send it into space. This tech will eventually exist. Maybe, and way down the line. Space distance is beyond the contemplation of understanding. The thing we launched in 1978 is 1 light DAY from earth. The single closest star is Proxima Centauri and it is 4.25 light years away.
A computer program version of some future scientist could go into sleep mode for the duration of the flight and wake up in orbit in 71,000 years. (At voyager speed. Will likely be faster once that tech is around.)
no, thats sci-fi. we would be travelling near relativistic speeds if we want to do that, but we are subject to things like time dilation. this was always a trope in sub-ftl travel(travelling close to speed of light, but the time effects is so wierd. you arnt actually doing the whole 10s of thousands of years in our perspective, but to the passengers, it takes less time.
also we dont have FTL, thats pure scifi(its almost always involved bypassing the speed of light as to not violate that universal constant, usually its interdiminesional travel. trek has several methods, warp which is just spatial manipulation to move the vessel across space, transwarp/voth/vortex, which is interdimensional travel to by pass the speed of light, most others are using teleportation which is not truel ftl movement, but its considered ftl.
but still curious to study, probably using deep space probes. in trek, the vulcans wouldve never even cared or noticed if cochrane never developed the first warp vessel. eventhough they visited earth in the past, they dont dint do first contact until much later. also the potential of inteference in natural development of a species.
I’ve been thinking about this a lot the last few years. I was huge into electronics and gadgets and such 10-15 years ago. Things were fun and exciting. Now there isn’t any real fun or experimentation or uniqueness in electronics. Phones are just a black slab with minor differences in features. Every new gadget has to be set up with your phone and then requires a monthly subscription.
It was always a money making venture, but every new iteration seems to cost more and do less. It’s depressing.
That’s just not true. There where anti mask protests and similarily stupid things in a lot of places. Here they went on the street wearing cow bells for some reason. The ‘how dare you inconvenience me to wear a mask just to potentially save a life’ thing happened in most european countries.
This one I still question. I’ve had so many people help me in life. Buy me gifts, tyres, games, get me jobs, apartments, take me to work, cheer me up, stick their necks out for me, etc. Some of those people we’re hardcore killers. So I’m not sure what to think.
I used to think US police were probably good guys making the right call most of the time. When something fishy hit the news I tended to think “they must have had a reason.”
That put a crack in it for me, but it was 2020 that really spun me the rest of the way around. And not just George Floyd himself. It was how police conducted themselves during the protests - every day I saw clips of cops escalating or being brutal to protesters. And several more high profile cases of police brutality happened during the same time. I admit I can’t remember a lot of the names now but I remember them - the kid with the sandwich shot in the back as he tried to enter his home, the guy with the phone in his hand shot in his friend’s garage, the old woman who had her arm dislocated and was then mocked while the cops replayed the video and bragged about it. And others… And always it was that the cops were shown to be liars by video evidence.
I ended 2020 with the view that I believe nothing cops say about any situation without video evidence to back them up. I will never again assume they “must have had a reason” or assume they are making a good faith effort to be truthful. It’s been far too consistent that every time there is a controversy, a video makes liars out of them.
Existence of a god, especially a monotheistic one.
None of the stories we have of them adequately explain anything. Beings that are supposed to be omniscient get things wrong. They are immoral, bigoted, narcissistic, genocidal, and egotistical.
I’ve rolled around a lot on this one myself. At the moment i see the true material existence of a monotheistic god as irrelevant to any discussion about such a god. What someone (or some book) says about a monotheistic god is an admission of their own ideals. Should there be a creator of the universe in any form to claim comprehension of the will of such being is an admission of ignorance. Therefore, any discussion about god is really a discussion about social ideals.
I have found this lens quite helpful when navigating socializing and connecting with people who do have strong religious beliefs. If i understand the rules of their religion i can step into their world for a conversation without compromising my own intellectual integrity or belittling their attachment to an immaterial belief structure.
I used to think progress in tech will solve societies problems, now I think it concentrates too much power in the hands of some of the worst people in society and needs to be federally regulated at some level with safeguards and checks.
This is the same for me, I wanted to believe that technology would be used to help the average individual in the USA but with what’s happening with data centers is clearly broken. Without proper regulations and redistribution of gains, many people will suffer terribly over the next couple years if we don’t get on top of it over the next year.
Depends on the tech I think. Old school p2p tech (e.g. Gnutella) was more decentralized. ActivityPub is more decentralized than Reddit. This kind of tech is more of a “public good,” so there’s less money in it and capitalism de-prioritizes it. I suppose cryptocurrency could be a counter-example though; decentralized tech that none-the-less got heavily centralized. The Internet itself too.
I’m mostly talking about massive centralized closed source tech like Uber, Facebook, Instagram, windows, Reddit, Google Suite and much more, because most of these platforms cannot run without a big investment to scale up with data centers only the wealthy can bankroll them and fully control them, they have and will always be used to benefit the rich at the expense of the working class. I recommend people migrate to open source and offline or decentralized or self hosted tech if they want something that doesn’t data mine their life for profit or force them into constantly inflating lifetime subscriptions or just simply get abandoned with time.
Important reminder to everyone that Gaza is still under an illegal embargo than the UN called a crime against humanity back in 2020. Still no international observers allowed in. And they’ve just dropped some more bombs on Gaza earlier this week, killing a bunch of civilians, including a hospital bombed on November 13th where they killed 6
and the sheer amount of propaganda(post-oct7 2023) they tried to forced through social media, MSMs, especially on reddit. if they dint tried so hard to do that, i think people would be blisfully ignorant. also they timed the attack in time for the election season to help trump win.
that has to do with MSMs never reporting israel in a bad light, its always Hamas did this to israel, or that. and then you realized most of the msm’s politicians are practically captured by israel via epstein honeypots.
I used to be a conservative Christian. I was vehemently opposed to things like gay marriage and abortion.
Then I actually moved to a larger city and met gay people and, well, that became the crux of my deconstruction. Turns out people are people, no matter where or how they’re born, or what they choose to be or identify as.
My views on abortion have changed, to the point where I very much do not believe in fetal personhood, though I still think late-term abortions should be shied away from if they can be avoided. Regardless, it makes no sense to remove a woman’s right to choose how her body is used. It’s hers. If she doesn’t want to put her body through childbirth, or doesn’t want to take on the immense burden of raising a child, she shouldn’t have to. But, at the same time, dudes should be aware of what they can inflict upon a woman just because ‘it doesn’t feel as good’ with a condom on. Wrap it before you tap it, boys.
Maybe not a complete 180, but I used to completely believe in the whole “move fast and break things” mentality. If I think something can be better, I should change it.
But I’ve come around to believing more in Chesterton’s Fence - I need to understand why something is the way it is before I decide to move fast and break things. If I don’t, I have no chance of my solution being better than the current one
I was born and raised in the deep south (U.S.) surrounded by conservatives. I retired in the south with 98% conservative colleagues. I spent 50 years turning the other cheek to conservatives, being patient, using the Socratic method, being a good son, a good grandson, a good brother, good friend and good neighbor to conservatives. Then Trump came along.
I now see how absolutely short-sighted and naive I was thinking the arrogant, unintelligent, bigoted, hateful, grinning monsters all around me could ever possibly become kind humans. Conservatives are exactly as evil as they appear. It’s not an illusion and they will never change.
Conservatives are biologically unable to experience empathy. This core understanding of conservatives explains so much about them. Their relationships are shallow because deep connections require empathy. It explains why bigotry and cruelty comes so easily to them. It explains how they can literally brag about killing a puppy and receive positive feedback from fellow conservatives.
I will never trust a conservative again as long as I live. I cannot unsee how genuinely cruel and evil they are and I can no longer be misled to believe they can change. It took a lifetime, but I understand what they are now and I am appropriately horrified by them.
This has been me, too, and it’s literally my entire family. Aaaaaall of them. Siblings, parents, cousins, nephews, nieces, aunts, uncles. My own children are the only exception. I’ve lost all respect for every last one of my family members, which is pretty lonely, but not something I can ever undo, since it’s so damn warranted.
As quiet as we all are in public about this, just know you are not mourning the loss of your family and friends alone. There are many millions of us experiencing this profound grief and upset. You are not alone in this, despite how isolating and lonely it can feel sometimes.
He didn’t say “genetically”, nor did he advocate for euthanizing them. “Medically” would be a better term than “biologically”, but I think he’s right. Conservatism is a brain defect.
The flu vaccine (pre Covid). Always been pro vax in general, just never saw the need since I never had symptomatic flu. My immune system is good enough, right?
Well, it was like a switch flipped in my brain. One day, I suddenly realized getting the shot isn’t about me. If I don’t vaccinate, I get the flu, and I don’t have symptoms.
That makes me a carrier. I’m a disease vector. Somewhere throughout my day, I’m going to pass it on to some immunocompromised person, and I will be the reason someone’s grandma doesn’t make it for the holidays.
“Just the flu” still kills hundreds of thousands of people every year.
I am a pharmacist and have vaccinated thousands of people. I am always impressed when someone listens to the reasons why a flu shot is an important civic duty and decides to get one when they haven’t previously.
The Spanish Flu of 1918 killed between 1-5% of the world population. For perspective, COVID-19 killed about 0.1%. Consider a pandemic that was 10 to 50x (!!!) the effects of COVID and specifically killed young people from the ages of 20-40.
Yeah, I always thought the flu shot was just for the old and/or immune-compromised. I am 100% pro-vaccine but just never got that one. We have basically every year since corona now.
Wait, does the flu vaccine actually work like that? I didn’t kmow it did anything to dampen transmission. I’ve never gotten it because I have such intense needle phobia it didn’t seem worth it, but if this is true, then it has more benefits than I realized and that kinda changed the calculus a little
Yes, vaccination primarily reduces odds of infection. No infection = no transmission. Secondarily, vaccination reduces the symptoms of an active infection if you get one anyways.
It’s basically a numbers game. With a vaccine the flu can’t spread through your body because you have immunity. Meaning your body can fight of the flu so you don’t get sick/have symptoms (or at least all of that is greatly diminished). Since the flu can’t spread in your body, there is less flu in you for you to spread to others.
So more people vaccinated means less viral load in the community which means less people spreading and therefore getting the flu.
I guess that does kinda make sense, less viral load in the commumity = better. I always thought that, because it might only protect against 80% of the flu strains out there (or however good we guess for the season), that herd immunity can’t be achieved and there was no point
I definitely never heard of it presented as a measure to protect people around me
This is mine too. Pre covid, my thought process was “I’m young and healthy and have had the flu twice in the last 15 years, I’d rather save the shots for someone who needs them, not me! I’ll just keep working my retail job and going to school even if I’m a little achey and sniffly, I can tough it out!”
Now I get them both every year. I still kinda feel like I’m taking a shot away from someone who needs it more, but I’m just trying to do my part!
You never get symptomatic flu? Can you please get to yourself to the nearest research hospital and get started on the genetic immunity or whatever it is you have. You may be the key for saving millions of lives and untold suffering.
A large portion of the population have immune systems that keep them from having symptoms of common diseases, or symptoms so mild don’t notice. That’s part of why transmission rates aren’t 100%.
There have been 254,485 notifications of laboratory confirmed influenza reported to the NNDSS in the year to 9 November 2026.
With a population of 27 million, that’s one in 100.
The reason it’s 1 in 100 in this country, and 1 in 8 worldwide, is because of our great healthcare system and protective social determinants of health, like nutrition and daily hygiene.
Since this is Lemmy, I assumed most people commenting would be from rich countries like Australia, so an Australian statistic would have better applicability to this population than a global statistic.
I used to think Tankies were misguided but harmless. Now I understand, if they got their way, they’d be dangerous.
I got into a fairly in depth conversation with one of them where they explained that they believed that the suspension of freedom, suppression of speech and expression, and sustained authoritarianism were necessary to achieve the socialist utopia. Except worse, they believe that these bad things should be in place until the entire world was socialist. If even one country wasn’t socialist, that would be the justification for suppression on the rest of the entire world. So essentially they’re defending worldwide authoritarianism and suppression of everyone in perpetuity.
I’d point you to this conversation so you could be your own judge, but true to their suppression methods, they exercised their own authoritarianism, deleted all my posts on the subject leaving only their own, because they said I was speaking against socialism and that can’t be allowed fulfilling the exact authoritarianism and suppression I was citing as a problem with their philosophy.
but you don’t understand, if only we murder and kill everyone until they are socialist then we’d finally never have to murder and kill again! unlike those evil capitalists who just go around murdering babies and grandmas, we are so much better than them! we only murder babies and grandmas who aren’t socialist!
They are not great at selling their position to the uninitiated. They demand you read their books and learn their definitions before you are permitted to exist. Asking questions gets you banned in many of their communities. I guess there’s a good reason their instances are often defederated from the bigger instances.
If only you agreed with my particular political opinions, I wouldn’t have to call you a liberal. Which is basically a Nazi. Which means you are evil. Which just proves my point
raises hand I have a definitional question for you.
Xi Jinping is president of China. One of the pillars of Chinese foreign policy is non-interference. China explicitly does not seek to impose its system on the rest of the world.
*raises hand * I have a definitional question for you.
Yes, you in the back that looks misinformed or willfully ignorant.
Xi Jinping is president of China.
He is. Well done, ten points to Slytherin!
One of the pillars of Chinese foreign policy is non-interference. China explicitly does not seek to impose its system on the rest of the world.
For part of the curriculum it is important to read the official statements and beliefs a nation has, but you can’t stop there. You have to look at how a nation behaves, not just want they say. I’m assigning you additional reading on the following topics:
- Canadian Sikh activist Hardeep Singh Nijjar’s assassination in British Columbia.Edit: error on my part including this. Leaving it here to show my error, but striking through it.
China’s “nine-dash line” and how it treats is neighbor’s sovereignty
Belt and Road initiative with specific reading on the port in Sri Lanka and resource extraction in a number of African countries.
Unauthorized Chinese police stations setup in foreign nations without the permission to do so from those nations.
Chinese fishing fleet ranging around the world and into territorial waters of Chile and even Gambia
Senkaku islands
Tibet and the seizing of the Panchen Lama
Is Xi Jinping a tankie?
Of course not. He’s the rightful leader of the nation of the Peoples Republic of China. His actions are with full awareness of geopolitical implications and in the interests of his state. I have no doubt he understands that written national ideals at the geopolitical level are guidelines, not promises. He is doing what he believes best for his people and his nation to secure them a future of plenty and stability.
Canadian Sikh activist Hardeep Singh Nijjar’s assassination in British Columbia
… You mean the guy suspected of having been killed by India, and decidedly not China? You realize that Punjab was partitioned between India and Pakistan, correct?
I know this isn’t the point, but if I was going to go out of my way to over-elaborate a simple yes or no question, and I openly offered up something this obviously wrong, I’d probably just delete my post out of embarrassment. Because Holly shit, lmao
… You mean the guy suspected of having been killed by India, and decidedly not China?
You’re absolutely right, on this one point I had mixed up the aggressor. Thank you for the correction. I have updated my prior post to reflect my error.
I’d probably just delete my post out of embarrassment.
I have no doubt you would. We’ve already established that deleting posts and suppression is the problem. Personally, I admit my mistakes and try to learn from it. So I’m leaving it up with a correction because I’m not afraid to admit when I make am mistake.
but if I was going to go out of my way to over-elaborate a simple yes or no question,
Ah gotcha, so I can remove my ‘misinformed’ assumption leaving the ‘willfully ignorant’ firmly in place. Should I also point out that your entire response was to point out my error (which I do appreciate, thank you) but not a single response to rest of my post contradicting your leading question?
Of course not. He’s the rightful leader of the nation of the Peoples Republic of China. His actions are with full awareness of geopolitical implications and in the interests of his state. I have no doubt he understands that written national ideals at the geopolitical level are guidelines, not promises. He is doing what he believes best for his people and his nation to secure them a future of plenty and stability.
I truly hate myself for having held this view at one time but I used to think (being a stupid young man) that boys in highschool having sex with their hot teachers was awesome. I used to unironically say “where were all these hot and horny teachers when I was in school?”
Then I realized what exactly it meant as abuse of power and betrayal of trust. It’s literally child rape.
Younger all of us was a dumbass. I was 24 when a hot blond teacher in Florida got arrested. It was a fun topic on the radio show I interned, lots of guys saying the same thing…where were those teachers when I was younger???
The moment I realized I was the same age as the teacher, my brain broke, 14 year olds are gross.
(They are less gross if you’re within a couple years…probably?).
I found myself accidentally agreeing with pedos on 4chan when I was younger. They were talking about teen girls being prime hotness because whatever reasons. As a teen myself, I also found them peak attraction. 25+ was old and gross. It all made sense.
Now that I’m older, I’m seeing girls that age around me now and they’re basically children. Like even 18 year olds are basically jumbo kids.
Universal healthcare and confederate history in the South.
When the Obamacare talks started I thought it was a terrible idea because all I’d heard was how has the government was and didn’t know how bad healthcare and insurance were. Now I think universal healthcare is a great idea, but I still think we’re dumb for trying for it at the federal level. California is as wealthy and populous as Canada and it makes a lot more sense for them to go their own way and have like minded states follow than to try and convince states like Florida it’s a good idea.
Confederacy in the south is weird. I was raised learning about the biased southern version, calling it the war of northern aggression, going to battle re-enactments and daughters of the confederacy get togethers. It wasn’t until I looked into the real history on my own that I discovered how terrible the South was, that they fired the first shot and most importantly that the whole celebration of the souths history started late in the 1900s as a rascist response to try and white wash history.
It baffles me that people will say “we can’t let the government do that; they’re terrible!” then hire terrible, lowest-bid companies to do a thing, have them fail, and then shrug and say “well, nothing we can do about it”.
Have the government do it. Hold them accountable. Make sure that your elected officials know you will pull support if they don’t hold themselves accountable.
The thing is that universal healthcare and such benefit from scale and more bargaining power. Companies will have more people trying to deny and charge hire rates the more states they have to negotiate with. Make it one: the US federal government. That’s not to say that certain things wouldn’t be administered at the state/county/municipal level, but the negotiations for price and such all happen at the top.
Yeah, logically universal healthcare is way more efficient than the insanity we have now. But it also isn’t happening when a large part of the country is strongly against it. And who can blame them when they are from places like Florida or Mississippi where their only experience with government is it being incredibly ineffective and corrupt. I don’t know how you improve the country as a whole without fixing that problem.
Trans athletes in student sports - now I believe there should be no student sports. It’s a waste of educational resources to have a team run by the school system. I went to the football stadium in Allen, TX and I realized how messed up schools have become
I went to more than one high school in which the science classrooms were using worn-out microscopes and textbooks old enough that the teacher occasionally told us to correct bits in ink for the next user, while the football team always got the shiniest newest toys to bang their thick skulls together with.
Abolish institutionalized sports; I’m thinking, in favour of self-organized sports. Just remove the fucking money from it in education - remove the money funnel from education anyway - and watch people care less about composition and more about everyone being active and smiling.
Now it’s so specialized and out of control that the sports I did watch (Olympics and winter sports), have just become rich kid and genetic outliers’ talent shows.
Personal story: Ages ago I was in marching band in TX, so we had to visit multiple other schools to play against them.
Some of those stadiums, even 20ish years ago, were ridiculous. So much money that could have gone to much better programs, or even a publicly available stadium that aren’t locked to a specific school district. I left band before graduating.
no school sports - this is the most radical take I’ve ever seen on lemmy.
and i like it. I and I like sports. FWIW the town my brother in has no school sports… the sports are run by an independent volunteer org. Nobody gets paid. but i’m not sure it’s a good ‘model’ because their sports program is mediocre and their teams are average at best.
he’s actually trying to move his family to another town with better sports because he expects his kids to go to college on sports scholarship like him and his wife both did. and there is no way that will happen if his kids are bad sports teams.
i do think sports have educational value, teaching teamwork and discipline and health. i learned more from cross country and marching band versus everything else combined. but i definitely agree about the ridiculous funding disparity, though, no extracurricular should be getting more funding than core classes
my hot take is that sports and bathrooms shouldn’t be gendered. i understand the “seperate but equal” clause doesn’t include gender, but it should, given the better funding and accomodation boys sports get over all but the best girls teams. siloing off genders has catastrophic cultural consequences- “locker room talk” shouldn’t and wouldn’t exist otherwise, plus the whole trans rights thing that shouldn’t and wouldn’t be an issue
The use of language. My mom was a proofreader for a handful of local editorials, so the “correctness” of language was pushed very hard on to me from very little. As a result, I pushed for “correct” language onto others very hard as well. And this isnt about English, but my birth language, which has lots of conjugation rules, gendering details, grammar quirks and special cases; so people do tend to deviate from proper grammar a lot in informal settings (and sometimes in formal as well). I became a “language nazi” of sorts, and noticed quickly how people spoke fearfully in front of me to avoid making mistakes and getting corrected. This was something I (regretfully) took pride of.
Until one day, a friend of mine which specialized in languages said to me: “Language isn’t prescriptive; it’s descriptive”. And it took a while, a plethora of questions, and infinite patience from her, but I eventually came around and understood what she was saying: language is what we use to convey ideas from one to the other. We stick to a given language and grammar (structure) because that’s the common agreement for the language speakers, in the expectations that it makes for easier communication. BUT, if a sentence can transmit correctly a thought, even when not using a word in the dictionary or not applying grammar rules, then it’s fine as long as me (or whomever is the interlocutor) understands what they’re trying to say. Furthermore, even when using proper grammar with “existing words”, communication can be confusing and requires clarification. If you can make up a word in the spot that better conveys what you’re trying to say, then I’m all for it! (And probably will start using it myself). If you learned to speak a certain way and call stuff a different name from what I learned, or if you add extra letters to the word because that’s what you were taught by your family (something very usual) then that’s cool and I’ll respect it.
TLDR: Language has no rules. It is what we make of it.
Emphasis on ‘correctly transmitting a thought’. Many who choose to completely ignore spelling and grammar do not manage to convey their thoughts. If I have to read or listen to something more than a couple times to try to figure out what was said, I skip on to the next item. That person failed to communicate.
True, though this is one of those ideas at the ends of the bell curve. You have authors who brilliantly break the rules and then you have the degeneracy of the language to the point where communication is touch-and-go at best. Having some flexible ground rules is to everyone’s benefit.
Reading Stephen King broke me of this as a teen 40-years ago.
“Hey! That’s not proper English! You can’t use punctuation like that! Did he just make that word up?!”
I had always made A’s in English and was stunned that this popular author often flouted the rules. But, as you said, he conveyed his descriptions brilliantly.
Thanks for sharing, my dad was a language purist as well, and it took me to marrying a local girl that used a lot of slang to break the habit. Even though sometimes, I cannot stop myself, I’ve become a much easier person to be around with.
I know you said English isn’t your native language, but I’m choosing to believe the grammar and punctuation mistakes in your post are just there to troll people who are still “language Nazis”. :-P
However, I was led to believe that some languages are prescriptive. For example, French has Académie Française. I was told (no idea how true it is) that it’s actually “in charge” of the language, so they get to decide what is “right”. The wiki page seems to indicate that they decide what goes in the French dictionary. That being said, I have no idea what authority they actually have outside of that. I doubt they’re issuing fines for using loanwords.
As a French speaker, the Académie Française is a bunch of old people completely disconnected from reality. They are usually considered irrelevant by the vast majority of French speakers, and a relic of the past where French had to be imposed to all French territory, including areas where other languages (Breton, Occitan, Catalan, Alsacien, etc.) were spoken.
The Académie thinks you should say “joueur-animateur en direct” instead of “streamer” or I guess “stremur” which literally no one does, so if an Académie prescribes a language but no one follows the rules, does it make a language?
Yes, that’s precisely my point. The language is a living being, and any authority pretending to rule over it is just smoke; word will be spoken, meanings will be given. Literally like the word “literally”, which now has a double meaning due to common (mis?)use.
Although, I’ve never been a fan of police, I used to believe that there were plenty of “good” police, and that changed during the George Floyd protests when I started thinking and reading about police more. I mean, there probably are “decent” police officers, but they appear to be an extremely small minority, and the systems they uphold are still evil. By and large, they are just another gang.
I’m still trying re-form my opinions on AI/ML/automation as well. I used to be very pro AI, and focused on ML in grad school. I thought extreme automation would be great for humanity and free us up to do things we enjoy. This current AI boom is focusing AI on the things people enjoy doing. It’s starting to look like AI may be able to find solutions to hard problems (e.g. the recent math problems solved by OpenAI), but it seems like the value of the result is much less than what would’ve been learned along the way if done by a human. I.e. if a human solved it, it would’ve likely surfaced new problems to solve, or new methodologies that could’ve been used to solve other problems. But, from what I’ve gathered, the proofs the AI made are unlike anything a human would come up with, and the problems are solved in more of a “brute force” manner that offers little further insights. So, the journey may be more important than the destination, or however that saying goes.
I used to be somewhere in the neighborhood of anarchist/social democrat, the way most people on lemmy who aren’t MLs are. I was just as “anti-tankie” as anyone.
While trying to really define what I believed, I stumbled across Progress and Poverty by Henry George, and it really clicked for me. It made the case that no one should have a specific right of ownership over land and natural resources, so they should be considered publicly owned and used to fund the state. Without getting into the details of the idea itself, I was convinced that it could work, as a compromise that would fix the worst parts of capitalism and essentially get the best parts of both. That, if it were enacted in a few small countries and able to compete on a level playing field, it would prove itself successful and serve as a model for everyone to follow. But this raised the question of, if that’s true, why hasn’t it happened already?
This question caused me to take an interest in a bunch of random small countries around the world that had experimented with asserting state control over their natural resources, and using them to fund social spending for the benefit of the people. And what did I find? Let’s look at a case study.
Mohammad Mossadegh of Iran was the prime example for me, because he wasn’t a Marxist at all, he had no ties whatsoever to the USSR, and did everything right. He attempted to assert control over Iran’s oil, which had been stolen outright by the British on a massive scale, in order to use it to uplift the people, who were incredibly poor and destitute. He believed in and upheld democratic ideals, and that exactly how the CIA was able to freely operate in Iran and oust him in favor of a literal monarchy.
Mossadegh refused to censor the press, when the CIA controlled 90% of the newspapers in the country, which constantly printed negative stories about him. He refused to suppress demonstrations, when the CIA was hiring them to march, both against him, and for him while wrecking shit and turning people against him. Finally, a US diplomat fed him a false story about the embassy receiving death threats from his supporters, and he was so moved, and so concerned about remaining friendly with the US, that he put out a radio message instructing his supporters to stand down. The next day, the CIA attacked his residence and there was no one to come to his aid.
It took me a long time to really wrestle with the full implications of that case study, and the similar stories that I found all around the world. But what I eventually realized is that the reason so many socialist states are authoritarian is not because they just want to be, it’s survivorship bias. And while the US is able to act as a global hegemon, the kind of system that I idealized, the kind of system Mossadegh was trying to build, will never be allowed to compete fairly. In fact, it is precisely because it might work to fix the worst parts of capitalism that it cannot be permitted, because a lot of powerful people get very, very rich off of those parts. It’s not about the food, it’s about keeping those ants in line.
I would much rather live in the world where the Marxist-Leninists were wrong. I would love it if countries around the world could try out all sorts of different systems, without fear of outside interference, so that different systems could compete and rise or fall on their own merits. If, when I looked into history I had found something different, I’d probably still agree with the criticisms I did before. But, unfortunately, that’s just not the world we live in. When you actually study history, what you’ll find in nearly every case is that the US tried to meddle in their affairs, to the detriment of the average person, and they were successful whenever they were not suppressed by force.
And that’s how I became a “tankie.”
From The Jakarta Method:
This was another very difficult question I had to ask my interview subjects, especially the leftists from Southeast Asia and Latin America. When we would get to discussing the old debates between peaceful and armed revolution; between hardline Marxism and democratic socialism, I would ask:
“Who was right?”
In Guatemala, was it Árbenz or Che who had the right approach? Or in Indonesia, when Mao warned Aidit that the PKI should arm themselves, and they did not? In Chile, was it the young revolutionaries in the MIR who were right in those college debates, or the more disciplined, moderate Chilean Communist Party?
Most of the people I spoke with who were politically involved back then believed fervently in a nonviolent approach, in gradual, peaceful, democratic change. They often had no love for the systems set up by people like Mao. But they knew that their side had lost the debate, because so many of their friends were dead. They often admitted, without hesitation or pleasure, that the hardliners had been right. Aidit’s unarmed party didn’t survive. Allende’s democratic socialism was not allowed, regardless of the détente between the Soviets and Washington.
Looking at it this way, the major losers of the twentieth century were those who believed too sincerely in the existence a liberal international order, those who trusted too much in democracy, or too much in what the United States said it supported, rather than what it really supported—what the rich countries said, rather than what they did. That group was annihilated.
Capital commands a mind boggling capacity for violence, and any attempt to change power structures need to take that into account. A peaceful revolution is impossible because literally millions of thugs will be paid to stop it.
I dont understand how the US doing stupid evil shit makes you go from Georgism to tankie? Its the same argument american cuban expats use to fear monger about communism (except in their case they cite cases of the USSR doing stupid evil shit). To me economics and politics are correlated, but not that strongly. You can have Georgism without hegemony. You could have evil socialist hegemons (look at some of the nationalistic Israeli kibbutzim).
Yeah, you have to assume your new society will be under constant attack. The problem with tankies is not that they are willing to fight back. The problem is they are fighting for systems already as corrupt, or worse, than “western capitalist” systems.
By what standard do you say socialist countries are “already as corrupt, or worse, than western capitalist systems?” The various socialist countries have managed to stand outside the paradigm of capital-dominated societies into human-run societies, and this has resulted in dramatic differences in who receives the primary benefits of social production. The first thing communists typically do upon successfully establishing state power is land reform, away from landlords, and into public and cooperative hands. Social programs soon follow, and production becomes something with a definite plan, typically in the range of five year segments.
Tankies have to grapple with running a new form of society while also protecting the gains of revolution from the international imperialist dictatorship of the collective west, spearheaded by the US. This has resulted in the buildup of high-security forces and structures, the strong states that inevitably come up from revolution. This isn’t something against the people, it’s a strategic necessity for protecting the long-term goals of coherent, planned construction of socialism.
The problem with the Western system is not just corruption, it’s that it’s built on a structure of neocolonialism that dominates the entire world. We are opposed to that social relation. You can compare, say, the US vs Iran and say that the US system is more progressive, but opposing the Iran War should not imply that we like Iran, or that we want to make US society more like Iranian society. But, while the Iran War seems to be unpopular enough to be an exception, in other cases this kind of line is often used against us, and against anyone who genuinely opposes the imperial project. Those who opposed the war in Afghanistan, for example, were branded as terrorist sympathizers, regardless of how they actually felt about Al Qaida or their actual reasons for opposing the war.
Every empire is expansionist, hence colonial. Not just the Western ones. China is colonizing Africa and parts of Asia. Russia has colonized the entirety of Siberia. Even Iran would like to expand if it could. Waging a war against an empire can be OK, even if it is fought by another empire. Fighting Nazis in WW2 was OK. Kuwait intervention was OK. Intervention in the Yugoslavian civil war was OK. Helping Ukraine against Ruzzia is OK. Mostly because they didn’t provide the USA (and “the West”) with imperial benefits, at least not that was plannable. And the people of the European and Pacific theatres , Kuwait, former Yugoslavia, and Ukraine got (or would get) a better life out of the interventions. As opposed to Iraq and Afghanistan. The problem with those wars were that they were fought for the wrong reasons, mostly greed. It smelled from the start, given that 9/11 was obviously a Saudi plot to destabilize the West, which has been a tremendous success since. Had the USA occupied Saudi Arabia, removed the royal family, put the oil fields under UN control, and made serious efforts, not just half-assed ones, to mend the rift between Islam and the West, e.g. by ensuring that Mecca and the pilgrimage remains unaffected, that would have been a war I would have supported. Had Al Gore’s presidency not been stolen, there was a chance that the USA had gone this way, instead of the money grabbing Afghan and Iraqi wars that the MIC convinced Dubya to do.
Point is, oppose or support wars based on their premise and goals, not by who is fighting them. I am yet to see a war fought by Ruzzia that was for the good of anyone but the Ruzzian elite. China hasn’t fought wars recently, but their expansion in the Third World is as cruel as the 19th century Western colonialism was.
China hasn’t fought wars recently, but their expansion in the Third World is as cruel as the 19th century Western colonialism was.
This is completely and utterly delusional. Outrageously false. You’re clearly ignorant of the practices of Western colonialism during that era, which included literal chattle slavery. Look up conditions in the Congo, for example, where workers were frequently punished by mutilation just for failing to meet a quota. Which countries is China subjecting to anything remotely similar to those practices? You’re attempting to whitewash this past by pretending that everyone is just as cruel, when the reality is completely different. Even modern day Western neocolonialism is nowhere remotely close to the absolute horror of 19th century colonialism.
The reality is that China offers development loans, which it has on occasion forgiven, and which, unlike Western loans, aren’t conditional on agreeing to anti-worker domestic policies. It does not hold monopolies on the means of production, as is the case in many neocolonies of the West. When the old system of direct control and administration was replaced with the current system, generally, the natural resources that had been stolen through overt force remained in Western hands. This is why, even compared to Western neocolonialism, China is much better for the underdeveloped world.
But forget about China, if you’re going to whitewash the actual history of slavery and colonialism like this then I’m not interested in discussing anything further with you. Nothing comparable in scale and cruelty exists in the modern day (with the possible exception of Israel, being a holdout from “old-school” colonialism).
Socialism isn’t authoritarian when done right. It should follow what works for the majority, like Nordic models and other places have done well for the people and the measures show it. Good systems use science and research to lead policy for healthy people. It’s not dualistic but demands proof, and real truth withstands scrutiny. The bad examples became authoritarian and benefited the wealthy rather than the majority, but there are good examples to follow and not repeat the same bad histories. The good ones upgraded their education systems to teach critical thinking and other good things for a healthy society. They’re not perfect but try to improve and great policies to start with.
The Nordic countries are allowed to do what they do because the cost benefit calculation was that it was easier to secure their loyalty by allowing them some progressive policies (likewise, this is why the US historically invested in a handful of regions like Germany, Taiwan, and South Korea). But there are many countries in the global south that have tried to follow the Nordic model, the trouble is, they’re not allowed to because the cost-benefit analysis is different. When they try, the CIA overthrows them and installs a dictator who will enact exploitative policies and keep the cheap goods flowing. When they take steps to stop that from happening, Western leftists denounce them as “authoritarian.”
Science and research are followed in AES (actually existing socialism) countries. Look at the response to COVID, for example. While in the US, people where crowding into stores to panic buy toilet paper, Vietnam was delivering free groceries directly to the doorsteps of people under lockdown.
What are the examples of “bad” socialism “benefiting the wealthy rather than the majority?” Socialist states, including Vietnam, Cuba, China, etc have implemented policies that have improved people lives by any objective metric, literacy, life expectancy, doctors and teachers per capita, etc. Granted, they sometimes have little choice but to allow some economic concessions, as a condition to participate in the global market. China’s reforms in the 80’s lead to 800 million people being lifted out of extreme poverty, for example. When a country doesn’t make such concessions and gets sanctioned or blockaded, things tend to go very poorly for them, which also gets held up as a “failure of socialism.” Damned if you do, damned if you don’t.
If you actually evaluate AES countries, based on reasonable expectations or on what they had before, they are not failures at all. The problem is that people don’t understand the challenges and threats that they have to navigate, and so they have unreasonable, impossible expectations of them. Again, I wish we lived in a world where it was possible to simply copy-paste social democratic policies into the global south, but it isn’t. History has proven quite clearly that that isn’t the world we live in. Y’all just never bother to actually study the histories of global south countries, so you don’t understand the severity of the threats they face.
That you should always try to give people the benefit of the doubt. I grew up that turning the other cheek and taking the high road was righteous. It was freeing to realize that even though it might not be 100% someone’s fault; sometimes a racist is a racist, even if they’ve never had the opportunity to broaden their horizon. The alcoholic is choosing not to get help, even if they have a good reason to want to drink. That asshole is an asshole, even if their father beat them as a child.
I hadn’t realized what an emotional burden I’d taken on trying to excuse the bad behavior of others until I came to the realization I needed to stop.
Alcoholism isn’t an addiction: truly it is a disease. It starts as a mental issue that then turns physiological.
Then your body stops producing GABA inhibitors.
You see, with smoking, some people quit cold turkey. And that’s fine. But with alcoholism, quitting cold turkey could mean death: Amy Winehouse is an example. It is the culmitive hangover that sends your body into shock.
So to properly detox, it takes about three days of medical attention. They monitor your blood pressure, basically.
But even after release, you require about three more weeks of monitoring. This is the “pink elephant” phase.
My sister stayed with me for the first week, and while I knew she was familiar and I wouldn’t dare say it: I honestly didn’t recognize her. Literally. I had logic to know that I should know her; she was on my couch.
But I honestly just didn’t recognize her.
Now, that was me coming out of my worst point: a fifth and touch on another fifth, chased by 6-8 beers a day.
Thankfully from ASA, I got a chance to clean up. Obamacared!
But while sober, I didn’t have any support once the physiological side was done.
So the mentality that caused the dependence came back.
And this is why groups like AA and NA pair you with a mentor.
The truth is the mentee is also helping the mentor.
So, with another example, I smoke cigarettes. I smoke about a pack a day, if left to my own devices.
I went on a date last week, and she kept me so entertained that in five hours, I only smoked one cigarette. She was a social smoker and bummed one.
I with vocal hesitation gave her one. I really like this woman. I don’t want her to take back up smoking. Greater than my drinking, smoking is the biggest regret of my life.
But she kept me entertained and engaged that I wasn’t wanting whiskey, beer, or cigarettes.
I was happy. I had physiological nags, for sure, but she was removing the actual root cause of my behavior.
I know I have basically written an essay, but my point is that sometimes, in heavily specific arenas, you should give people the benefit of the doubt.
Get them engaged and feel love, and watch those worries just wash away.
And we are going to have dinner on Monday. Wish me luck. She might be my cure, and not leftover thanksgiving tips.
It’s definitely something you have to be careful with. My ex basically used to it to financially and emotionally manipulate me.
I think it’s still healthy to an extent. My current conclusion is understand why someone behaves in a way doesn’t excuse it, just informs the actions you should potentially take.
This ties into a lot of the Boomer-hate out there.
Now, I don’t go out of my way to defend people who treat others poorly - I’ve been hurt by the generations before me as much as any Millennial has been. However, realizing just how shitty the parents of Boomers were to them really opened my eyes. My mother’s far from perfect, but her father was strict in a disturbing way. The control that fathers in the 1950/1960s had over their kids (in the US at least) seems to be glossed over nowadays, but in those times Dad was THE authority… and my grandfather personified that attitude.
Questioning what parents said meant “getting the belt” or other corporal punishments. I used to wonder how my mom went so long without examining the ideas she grew up with (for example, the tradition of married women taking their husbands’ names.) But now I can see that, for her generation, asking such questions was pretty much as invitation to a beating. Baby Boomers’ childhoods were soaked in indoctrination and obedience to authority.
It’s no small wonder that when Baby Boomers came of age, they turned around and followed the model they had growing up, except with them “in charge.”
Anyway, long story short: even our grandparents got fucked over long ago, we can all simultaneously be both victims and perpetrators, We Didn’t Start the Fire, yadda yadda.
After the October 7 attack I was very pro isreal. Of course it’s totally unacceptable for a neighbor to enter one’s territory and kill hundreds of innocent civilians. You can’t commit such an act of terrorism without consequences. However I have seen that the Israeli invasion has been all but moral and the use of the word genocide feels more and more justified. It has gone way over board and I have staunchly become anti isreal. The war was supposed to be a war on Hamas but the innocent civilians in Gaza have had to bear with unbelievable suffering which I no longer believe justifies the war.
as someone who went through the same, it was mostly lack of attention. i had a vague idea that israel and palestine hated each other, and it was easy to understand from a perspective of israel taking palestinian land, but when you don’t think about it too much it’s easy to both sides it or feel like the supposedly western, supposedly democratic one has a point. i think a lot of people in the west had that vague, unrefined view when oct 7 happened, and it’s easy to stand with someone who just suffered a terror attack.
but it just kept being a focus in media, and the more you look into it, the clearer israel’s crimes against humanity become. and the crazy part is that the vague perspective of israel taking the land for themselves is absolutely correct, but when you see it for the real atrocity it is, rather than an abstract curiosity, it’s impossible to side with the occupiers if you’re not a bigot.
I can only add that, as much as I despise what occurred to Israel that day, it achieved their objectives in a way nothing else probably could have. It’s difficult to morally reconcile, but the evil they committed against Israel exposed a greater evil Israel was committing against them.
This is exactly how I see it as well, it brought the worlds attention to their situation and exposed Israel’s human rights violations and other atrocities to the forefront where as earlier it was easy to think of it as some local border dispute, now it’s apparent that Israel is a apartheid country that is trying to slowly genocide a group of people and will never agree to any peaceful solution. I hope that Americans get their shit together and force the next group of politicians that come to power to stop funding this amoral crime against humanity through their tax dollars
I was in the same boat (outside of being already critical regarding israels illegal settlements in the west bank). Main reason was that growing up in Austria, criticizing anything jewish was practically a taboo, and the only ones doing it publicly were the far right, which delegitimized all of it in public discussion. (Edit: This effect was surely even stronger in Germany. It’s actually an great development that german politics are wizening up, even if it’s a slow process)
It took their atrocities to make me realize how much effort Israels Zionists are putting into trying to tie Judaism/Ethnic Jews/Zionism together, so that blaming Israel can be countered by accusing anyone to be an antisemite. (I also have to say that for how good Israel is at Psyops, they really botched this one on the world stage.) I also realized that the conflict became a lot more one sided over the years; in the 80s and 90s there still was a push for a 2-state solution, and attacks in both directions were a common occurrence. Nowadays Israelis getting hurt is often the direct result of repressive action from Israels side.
Oct 7 might very well have been an false flag op in retrospective. It gave Bibi the chance to annex all of Gaza, Genocide be damned. It’s similar to Putins staged apartment complex attack.
Bibi received warnings from multiple sources that an attack was planned and yet weren’t troops moved away from the venue where it occurred in days before?
One lesson here is that psyops only work in a nominal range of material conditions.
You can keep comfortable people from paying too much attention to a distant problem, but once daily life becomes too difficult, people’s pattern recognition starts seeing through it fast.
Also people are extremely sensitive to rates of change. The elites panicked and/or got impatient, thought they had it in the bag, and now the general public is more activated and cohesive than they have probably ever been.
US media has spun such a one sided narrative for decades that I never looked close enough to to catch on that it was whitewashing genocide. October 7th and the Israeli reaction was comparable to the US genocide of Native Americans both through the dehumanization and pbvious propaganda that I started paying more attention. The more details came out, including the apartheid state structure, the less I felt that there will ever be a peaceful two state solution when Israel is an expansionist culture that cannot accept or acknowledge the right to exist of the Palestinians whose land they stole, much less the soverignty of their neighbors.
When I first learned that people were transitioning their gender, I was very much “live and let live,” but took exception at having to call people their preferred pronoun. It seemed like a rigged game to me, like they wanted you to guess at what their gender is, and if you got it wrong, you’re a bigot.
Then my wife was like “what harm does it do to call them what they prefer?”
And I thought about all the hurtful names people teased me with at school, and how I wished they would’ve just called me by my name.
So I said “OK,” and that was that. It hasn’t been as hard as I thought to recognize what people wish to be called. Unless you’re dealing with a “they/them,” then they gotta tell you. Or if you’re dealing with a butch lesbian that dresses boy-ish. On those occasions, I just try not to use any pronouns or talk to them extensively for fear of messing up.
like they wanted you to guess at what their gender is, and if you got it wrong, you’re a bigot.
FWIW, for anyone else who has these sorts of thoughts, most people trans/nonbinary people I’ve met don’t tend to get particularly hung up on it if you guess wrong.
They live in the same world you do, they own mirrors, they know how they look, and in a lot of cases they probably spend a whole lot more time agonizing over how they look than anyone else because they’re worrying about whether or not they can pass.
Just take your best guess and if they or someone else corrects you, just apologize and try to do better. You’re probably gonna fuck up, you have a lifetime of indoctrination in the gender binary to unlearn. It happens. I have a friend who’s been dating a nonbinary person for years and occasionally still messes up and uses the wrong pronouns, it happens. The femboy wearing a skirt probably isn’t gonna be offended no matter what pronouns you use for them. The butch lesbian with a buzz cut has probably already been mistaken for a guy 7 times today, it’s nothing new. Trans and non-binary people have probably spent most of their life using pronouns they don’t like, and sure they’d prefer you use the right ones, but it’s nothing new to them.
If you’re unsure when you meet someone and they don’t broach the subject off the bat, go ahead and spell out your own pronouns so they can feel safe to do the same.
Or just stick to they/them. It’s a little awkward sometimes, it takes some getting used to, but the only people I’ve ever seen get offended by it are bigots who I don’t mind offending anyway.
Sure, there’s some subset of the community that gets really huffy about it, and those people are just garden variety assholes who happen to be trans/nonbinary. They’re basically the same as the cis Karen type who for some reason gets a stick up her ass about not wanting to be called “ma’am,” or the guy who insists on correcting you that it’s “Doctor such-and-such” if you dare to refer to him as “mister.” It doesn’t mean you should go ahead and ignore their preference, but don’t put too much stock in their opinions either.
Don’t have fear. As long as you try and are respectful, it’s fine. Even though awareness about this is much better than maybe 20 years ago, a lot of people are still not used to it and are missing the necessary personal experience. Of course they might have difficulties adjusting. But as long as they are polite and try to improve, trans people can be expected to deal with it. Those who immediately call you a bigot are entitled assholes, imo.
It’s a fair common ground: you respect the identity of the trans person, and the trans person forgives you innocent mistakes.
I’ve felt like this. You already call people the name they asked you to call them, it’s like 3 extra brain cells work to just call them what they ask, way too much effort to mess with them or cause animosity.
While transitioning I’m sure they understand there will be genuine mixups.
My kids started saying “it’s not that deep” and seems to really fit here.
I just don’t use pronouns if I’m not sure, because I’ve never seen anger on the level of someone whom I’ve inadvertently misgendered, and it doesn’t seem to cross people’s minds that maybe I’m not a mind reader.
Gender neutral language is just best overall in this scenario.
Assuming this means avoiding gendered pronouns, I agree.
In a vacuum, theoretically, our language would simply be easier without gendered pronouns. But it would be idealistic for me to therefore assert everyone should just always use neutral pronouns and be alright with that. I know some people who intentionally signal their gender feel invalidated by neutral language, so it would be insensitive and pointless for me to disrespect their preference.
In all the societies I’m in, my approach is to default to neutral unless/until someone specifies preferred pronouns or clearly indicates their gender. I haven’t had anyone, progressive nor reactionary, object to this behavior.
Yeah I really try to be inclusive but I’m with you here, that shit is whack. You’re not a fucking bionicle. We’re all trying our best to be nice to you and your new identity, but if you ask me to call you a fairy, I’m going to laugh in your face. I’ll feel bad about it later, probably, but I will do a spit-take in the moment.
I took a very long sort of a pilgrimage to test my faith and find myself. I found out I believed in myself a hell of a lot more than a god that either doesn’t exist, doesn’t care, or can’t help.
I would share more, but this was an extremely personal and very painful moment for me. I don’t feel comfortable telling the entire story to anyone but my close friends.
Congratulations. You have had one of the healthiest epiphanies you will ever have. I relate very much, although I am probably twice your age. I wish I had that realization 30 years ago.
If you ever have a strong urge to drink again, if it’s legal where you are, a light dose of THC might satisfy you instead. It’s not for everyone, but that’s worked very well for me.
Again, congratulations. Getting away from alcohol is a move so healthy, you should be proud of yourself for it.
I used to be a dyed-in-the-wool optimist. Now, I’m an avowed cynic, and most people don’t realize it because I’m generally a cheerful person and that serves to mask it somewhat.
My entire adult life has corresponded to the regressive post-9/11 loss of economic and civil liberty that has drastically impacted the poor and working class in America.
Thing is, I truly believed in Obama. I went to a rally where Michelle spoke in September 2008. In late October, Obama dropped by for a rally, and there were so many of us that the organizers had to cut the line off and we had to sit on a nearby hill and just listen. I was 100%, absolutely certain that real, lasting change was coming.
But nope. Our two wars became seven. (That we know of.) Occupy was brutally crushed by the NYPD with Obama’s tacit approval. Police became militarized, even after Ferguson. Torture continued and the War on Terror continued unabated, despite Obama having a mandate to end it. No one from Wall Street that crashed our economy for profit went to prison, even though a foreclosure crisis followed. Life began to become unaffordable and the minimum wage stayed at $7 an hour. Despite having the votes to universalize health care, Obama made it more expensive instead. The cherry on top was that Obama gave us Tom Homan.
All of these problems have continued and worsened in the decade since 2016, despite both parties having total power for years at a time.
Now, no matter who we elect at the federal (and mostly state) level, I know things are never getting better.
My only power is local. Thankfully, my city is doing good things, so there’s that, but if I had the money to do so I’d leave this country completely and reside abroad instead.
Comments
Used to be a Mulder. Now I’m a Scully.
Alien life, although likely to exist somewhere out there (Its quite literally mathematically impossible for it NOT to) in some form, even if microscopic.
But it has never and will never pop by for a visit. Its never been here. And has no reason to ever come here.
A civilisation that is technologically capable of making the trip is, by default, also technologically advanced enough to not need anything from some hostile primates on a malfunctioning planet.
Aren’t we kinda capable of going to another solar system? Multiple generations of travel perhaps, and at an extreme cost. But with technology we have today it could potentially be possible.
So, does that mean they would have to be vastly more advanced than us?
Although it probably is a fairly narrow band of development. That said we have no idea the speed of development another species would be capable of compared to us.
We are no where near being capable of that.
Using a laser beam to push a solar sail dragging a mini probe behind it (which is the closest thing as are even relatively close to) is a far far far cry from having the self-sustaining life-support technology to last the centuries it would take to get there.
The only way a “human” will ever experience a different solar system or galaxy is if we do reach singularity, and decide to copy conscience to programing and send it into space. This tech will eventually exist. Maybe, and way down the line. Space distance is beyond the contemplation of understanding. The thing we launched in 1978 is 1 light DAY from earth. The single closest star is Proxima Centauri and it is 4.25 light years away.
A computer program version of some future scientist could go into sleep mode for the duration of the flight and wake up in orbit in 71,000 years. (At voyager speed. Will likely be faster once that tech is around.)
Not to mention every bit of mass matters and getting up to speed is ludicrous. See Project Orion
no, thats sci-fi. we would be travelling near relativistic speeds if we want to do that, but we are subject to things like time dilation. this was always a trope in sub-ftl travel(travelling close to speed of light, but the time effects is so wierd. you arnt actually doing the whole 10s of thousands of years in our perspective, but to the passengers, it takes less time.
also we dont have FTL, thats pure scifi(its almost always involved bypassing the speed of light as to not violate that universal constant, usually its interdiminesional travel. trek has several methods, warp which is just spatial manipulation to move the vessel across space, transwarp/voth/vortex, which is interdimensional travel to by pass the speed of light, most others are using teleportation which is not truel ftl movement, but its considered ftl.
but still curious to study, probably using deep space probes. in trek, the vulcans wouldve never even cared or noticed if cochrane never developed the first warp vessel. eventhough they visited earth in the past, they dont dint do first contact until much later. also the potential of inteference in natural development of a species.
This feels basic now but I used to be very ‘pro tech’ and would have latest-ish phones, getting smart gadgets, etc.
Now I consider those features to be negatives and refuse to buy things with internet, if possible.
https://discuss.tchncs.de/pictrs/image/7e3cdd79-c840-4ddc-a805-d878d452bcf4.png
Nowadays I would keep the gun in a separate room, to prevent the printer of taking it.
This is going on my board at work.
one more time you disconnect from the wifi… choose 45LC or +P 9m copper polymer
I’ve been thinking about this a lot the last few years. I was huge into electronics and gadgets and such 10-15 years ago. Things were fun and exciting. Now there isn’t any real fun or experimentation or uniqueness in electronics. Phones are just a black slab with minor differences in features. Every new gadget has to be set up with your phone and then requires a monthly subscription.
It was always a money making venture, but every new iteration seems to cost more and do less. It’s depressing.
I have a theme for total launcher that makes My phone a PADD with LCARS.
People are inherently good.
Then COVID happened.
I reassure you, only in the USA covid raised such hysterical reactions.
That’s just not true. There where anti mask protests and similarily stupid things in a lot of places. Here they went on the street wearing cow bells for some reason. The ‘how dare you inconvenience me to wear a mask just to potentially save a life’ thing happened in most european countries.
We made Covid infected people drink cow urine, insanity was a worldwide phenomenon.
dont you mean HORSE/cow ivermectin consumption, meant for farm animals.
I was talking about India.
This one I still question. I’ve had so many people help me in life. Buy me gifts, tyres, games, get me jobs, apartments, take me to work, cheer me up, stick their necks out for me, etc. Some of those people we’re hardcore killers. So I’m not sure what to think.
I used to think US police were probably good guys making the right call most of the time. When something fishy hit the news I tended to think “they must have had a reason.”
Then there was the killing of Walter Scott.
That put a crack in it for me, but it was 2020 that really spun me the rest of the way around. And not just George Floyd himself. It was how police conducted themselves during the protests - every day I saw clips of cops escalating or being brutal to protesters. And several more high profile cases of police brutality happened during the same time. I admit I can’t remember a lot of the names now but I remember them - the kid with the sandwich shot in the back as he tried to enter his home, the guy with the phone in his hand shot in his friend’s garage, the old woman who had her arm dislocated and was then mocked while the cops replayed the video and bragged about it. And others… And always it was that the cops were shown to be liars by video evidence.
I ended 2020 with the view that I believe nothing cops say about any situation without video evidence to back them up. I will never again assume they “must have had a reason” or assume they are making a good faith effort to be truthful. It’s been far too consistent that every time there is a controversy, a video makes liars out of them.
Existence of a god, especially a monotheistic one.
None of the stories we have of them adequately explain anything. Beings that are supposed to be omniscient get things wrong. They are immoral, bigoted, narcissistic, genocidal, and egotistical.
I’ve rolled around a lot on this one myself. At the moment i see the true material existence of a monotheistic god as irrelevant to any discussion about such a god. What someone (or some book) says about a monotheistic god is an admission of their own ideals. Should there be a creator of the universe in any form to claim comprehension of the will of such being is an admission of ignorance. Therefore, any discussion about god is really a discussion about social ideals.
I have found this lens quite helpful when navigating socializing and connecting with people who do have strong religious beliefs. If i understand the rules of their religion i can step into their world for a conversation without compromising my own intellectual integrity or belittling their attachment to an immaterial belief structure.
evangelical christinization trying to explain away other religions and their gods, especially in shows and movies.
I used to think progress in tech will solve societies problems, now I think it concentrates too much power in the hands of some of the worst people in society and needs to be federally regulated at some level with safeguards and checks.
This is the same for me, I wanted to believe that technology would be used to help the average individual in the USA but with what’s happening with data centers is clearly broken. Without proper regulations and redistribution of gains, many people will suffer terribly over the next couple years if we don’t get on top of it over the next year.
Depends on the tech I think. Old school p2p tech (e.g. Gnutella) was more decentralized. ActivityPub is more decentralized than Reddit. This kind of tech is more of a “public good,” so there’s less money in it and capitalism de-prioritizes it. I suppose cryptocurrency could be a counter-example though; decentralized tech that none-the-less got heavily centralized. The Internet itself too.
I’m mostly talking about massive centralized closed source tech like Uber, Facebook, Instagram, windows, Reddit, Google Suite and much more, because most of these platforms cannot run without a big investment to scale up with data centers only the wealthy can bankroll them and fully control them, they have and will always be used to benefit the rich at the expense of the working class. I recommend people migrate to open source and offline or decentralized or self hosted tech if they want something that doesn’t data mine their life for profit or force them into constantly inflating lifetime subscriptions or just simply get abandoned with time.
Israel.
I used to support Israel, until I heard about them executing children in Gaza.
Important reminder to everyone that Gaza is still under an illegal embargo than the UN called a crime against humanity back in 2020. Still no international observers allowed in. And they’ve just dropped some more bombs on Gaza earlier this week, killing a bunch of civilians, including a hospital bombed on November 13th where they killed 6
And keep in mind that according to Israel’s own defence ministry, they were limiting the calories entering Gaza for many years to “keep Gaza’s economy on the brink of collapse”, while simultaneously openly funding Hamas
Same, to be fair I was more or less ignorant until Oct 7, then about Oct 8th I realized just how fucking awful israel is
and the sheer amount of propaganda(post-oct7 2023) they tried to forced through social media, MSMs, especially on reddit. if they dint tried so hard to do that, i think people would be blisfully ignorant. also they timed the attack in time for the election season to help trump win.
100%. I’m glad they did try so hard though because it allowed me, and many others to lift the veil
that has to do with MSMs never reporting israel in a bad light, its always Hamas did this to israel, or that. and then you realized most of the msm’s politicians are practically captured by israel via epstein honeypots.
I used to be a conservative Christian. I was vehemently opposed to things like gay marriage and abortion.
Then I actually moved to a larger city and met gay people and, well, that became the crux of my deconstruction. Turns out people are people, no matter where or how they’re born, or what they choose to be or identify as.
My views on abortion have changed, to the point where I very much do not believe in fetal personhood, though I still think late-term abortions should be shied away from if they can be avoided. Regardless, it makes no sense to remove a woman’s right to choose how her body is used. It’s hers. If she doesn’t want to put her body through childbirth, or doesn’t want to take on the immense burden of raising a child, she shouldn’t have to. But, at the same time, dudes should be aware of what they can inflict upon a woman just because ‘it doesn’t feel as good’ with a condom on. Wrap it before you tap it, boys.
Sometimes biological preference is biology and not preference, though. Something to continue ruminating on.
I thought the preceeding words in the sentece made that clear.
Maybe not a complete 180, but I used to completely believe in the whole “move fast and break things” mentality. If I think something can be better, I should change it.
But I’ve come around to believing more in Chesterton’s Fence - I need to understand why something is the way it is before I decide to move fast and break things. If I don’t, I have no chance of my solution being better than the current one
I was born and raised in the deep south (U.S.) surrounded by conservatives. I retired in the south with 98% conservative colleagues. I spent 50 years turning the other cheek to conservatives, being patient, using the Socratic method, being a good son, a good grandson, a good brother, good friend and good neighbor to conservatives. Then Trump came along.
I now see how absolutely short-sighted and naive I was thinking the arrogant, unintelligent, bigoted, hateful, grinning monsters all around me could ever possibly become kind humans. Conservatives are exactly as evil as they appear. It’s not an illusion and they will never change.
Conservatives are biologically unable to experience empathy. This core understanding of conservatives explains so much about them. Their relationships are shallow because deep connections require empathy. It explains why bigotry and cruelty comes so easily to them. It explains how they can literally brag about killing a puppy and receive positive feedback from fellow conservatives.
I will never trust a conservative again as long as I live. I cannot unsee how genuinely cruel and evil they are and I can no longer be misled to believe they can change. It took a lifetime, but I understand what they are now and I am appropriately horrified by them.
This has been me, too, and it’s literally my entire family. Aaaaaall of them. Siblings, parents, cousins, nephews, nieces, aunts, uncles. My own children are the only exception. I’ve lost all respect for every last one of my family members, which is pretty lonely, but not something I can ever undo, since it’s so damn warranted.
As quiet as we all are in public about this, just know you are not mourning the loss of your family and friends alone. There are many millions of us experiencing this profound grief and upset. You are not alone in this, despite how isolating and lonely it can feel sometimes.
Careful mate. Dangerously close to eugenics.
He didn’t say “genetically”, nor did he advocate for euthanizing them. “Medically” would be a better term than “biologically”, but I think he’s right. Conservatism is a brain defect.
The flu vaccine (pre Covid). Always been pro vax in general, just never saw the need since I never had symptomatic flu. My immune system is good enough, right?
Well, it was like a switch flipped in my brain. One day, I suddenly realized getting the shot isn’t about me. If I don’t vaccinate, I get the flu, and I don’t have symptoms.
That makes me a carrier. I’m a disease vector. Somewhere throughout my day, I’m going to pass it on to some immunocompromised person, and I will be the reason someone’s grandma doesn’t make it for the holidays.
“Just the flu” still kills hundreds of thousands of people every year.
I am a pharmacist and have vaccinated thousands of people. I am always impressed when someone listens to the reasons why a flu shot is an important civic duty and decides to get one when they haven’t previously.
The Spanish Flu of 1918 killed between 1-5% of the world population. For perspective, COVID-19 killed about 0.1%. Consider a pandemic that was 10 to 50x (!!!) the effects of COVID and specifically killed young people from the ages of 20-40.
Get your flu shot.
Yeah, I always thought the flu shot was just for the old and/or immune-compromised. I am 100% pro-vaccine but just never got that one. We have basically every year since corona now.
Wait, does the flu vaccine actually work like that? I didn’t kmow it did anything to dampen transmission. I’ve never gotten it because I have such intense needle phobia it didn’t seem worth it, but if this is true, then it has more benefits than I realized and that kinda changed the calculus a little
Yes, vaccination primarily reduces odds of infection. No infection = no transmission. Secondarily, vaccination reduces the symptoms of an active infection if you get one anyways.
It’s basically a numbers game. With a vaccine the flu can’t spread through your body because you have immunity. Meaning your body can fight of the flu so you don’t get sick/have symptoms (or at least all of that is greatly diminished). Since the flu can’t spread in your body, there is less flu in you for you to spread to others.
So more people vaccinated means less viral load in the community which means less people spreading and therefore getting the flu.
I guess that does kinda make sense, less viral load in the commumity = better. I always thought that, because it might only protect against 80% of the flu strains out there (or however good we guess for the season), that herd immunity can’t be achieved and there was no point
I definitely never heard of it presented as a measure to protect people around me
This is mine too. Pre covid, my thought process was “I’m young and healthy and have had the flu twice in the last 15 years, I’d rather save the shots for someone who needs them, not me! I’ll just keep working my retail job and going to school even if I’m a little achey and sniffly, I can tough it out!”
Now I get them both every year. I still kinda feel like I’m taking a shot away from someone who needs it more, but I’m just trying to do my part!
You never get symptomatic flu? Can you please get to yourself to the nearest research hospital and get started on the genetic immunity or whatever it is you have. You may be the key for saving millions of lives and untold suffering.
A large portion of the population have immune systems that keep them from having symptoms of common diseases, or symptoms so mild don’t notice. That’s part of why transmission rates aren’t 100%.
Only 1 in 200 people get the flu each year. Lots of people never catch the flu in their life. Flu is pretty rare compared to the common cold.
1 in 200? No. Funny how the ones who don’t provide sources are the ones who spread nonsense.
1 Billion people a year get it. That is roughly 1 in 8.
Of these 3-5 million get severe illness, and out of that you get roughly 300-600k deaths.
Oh, you know what? I misread the statistics site and read NSW’s rate as the entire country’s. It’s actually around one in 100
https://immunisationcoalition.org.au/influenza-statistics/
With a population of 27 million, that’s one in 100.
The reason it’s 1 in 100 in this country, and 1 in 8 worldwide, is because of our great healthcare system and protective social determinants of health, like nutrition and daily hygiene.
Since this is Lemmy, I assumed most people commenting would be from rich countries like Australia, so an Australian statistic would have better applicability to this population than a global statistic.
I used to think Tankies were misguided but harmless. Now I understand, if they got their way, they’d be dangerous.
I got into a fairly in depth conversation with one of them where they explained that they believed that the suspension of freedom, suppression of speech and expression, and sustained authoritarianism were necessary to achieve the socialist utopia. Except worse, they believe that these bad things should be in place until the entire world was socialist. If even one country wasn’t socialist, that would be the justification for suppression on the rest of the entire world. So essentially they’re defending worldwide authoritarianism and suppression of everyone in perpetuity.
I’d point you to this conversation so you could be your own judge, but true to their suppression methods, they exercised their own authoritarianism, deleted all my posts on the subject leaving only their own, because they said I was speaking against socialism and that can’t be allowed fulfilling the exact authoritarianism and suppression I was citing as a problem with their philosophy.
but you don’t understand, if only we murder and kill everyone until they are socialist then we’d finally never have to murder and kill again! unlike those evil capitalists who just go around murdering babies and grandmas, we are so much better than them! we only murder babies and grandmas who aren’t socialist!
tankies don’t like socialists, they call them liberals. they would slaughter socialists, too.
They seem to call Republicans liberals as well.
They are not great at selling their position to the uninitiated. They demand you read their books and learn their definitions before you are permitted to exist. Asking questions gets you banned in many of their communities. I guess there’s a good reason their instances are often defederated from the bigger instances.
If only you agreed with my particular political opinions, I wouldn’t have to call you a liberal. Which is basically a Nazi. Which means you are evil. Which just proves my point
raises hand I have a definitional question for you.
Xi Jinping is president of China. One of the pillars of Chinese foreign policy is non-interference. China explicitly does not seek to impose its system on the rest of the world.
Is Xi Jinping a tankie?
Yes, you in the back that looks misinformed or willfully ignorant.
He is. Well done, ten points to Slytherin!
For part of the curriculum it is important to read the official statements and beliefs a nation has, but you can’t stop there. You have to look at how a nation behaves, not just want they say. I’m assigning you additional reading on the following topics:
- Canadian Sikh activist Hardeep Singh Nijjar’s assassination in British Columbia.Edit: error on my part including this. Leaving it here to show my error, but striking through it.Of course not. He’s the rightful leader of the nation of the Peoples Republic of China. His actions are with full awareness of geopolitical implications and in the interests of his state. I have no doubt he understands that written national ideals at the geopolitical level are guidelines, not promises. He is doing what he believes best for his people and his nation to secure them a future of plenty and stability.
… You mean the guy suspected of having been killed by India, and decidedly not China? You realize that Punjab was partitioned between India and Pakistan, correct?
I know this isn’t the point, but if I was going to go out of my way to over-elaborate a simple yes or no question, and I openly offered up something this obviously wrong, I’d probably just delete my post out of embarrassment. Because Holly shit, lmao
You’re absolutely right, on this one point I had mixed up the aggressor. Thank you for the correction. I have updated my prior post to reflect my error.
I have no doubt you would. We’ve already established that deleting posts and suppression is the problem. Personally, I admit my mistakes and try to learn from it. So I’m leaving it up with a correction because I’m not afraid to admit when I make am mistake.
Ah gotcha, so I can remove my ‘misinformed’ assumption leaving the ‘willfully ignorant’ firmly in place. Should I also point out that your entire response was to point out my error (which I do appreciate, thank you) but not a single response to rest of my post contradicting your leading question?
So was Josph Stalin a Tankie?
First tankie I met was a Czech gay man who supported Russia and wanted to go to Iran. My brain was so confused
I truly hate myself for having held this view at one time but I used to think (being a stupid young man) that boys in highschool having sex with their hot teachers was awesome. I used to unironically say “where were all these hot and horny teachers when I was in school?”
Then I realized what exactly it meant as abuse of power and betrayal of trust. It’s literally child rape.
I fucking hate younger me for that.
Younger all of us was a dumbass. I was 24 when a hot blond teacher in Florida got arrested. It was a fun topic on the radio show I interned, lots of guys saying the same thing…where were those teachers when I was younger???
The moment I realized I was the same age as the teacher, my brain broke, 14 year olds are gross.
(They are less gross if you’re within a couple years…probably?).
I found myself accidentally agreeing with pedos on 4chan when I was younger. They were talking about teen girls being prime hotness because whatever reasons. As a teen myself, I also found them peak attraction. 25+ was old and gross. It all made sense.
Now that I’m older, I’m seeing girls that age around me now and they’re basically children. Like even 18 year olds are basically jumbo kids.
Oh man trust me…it never stops. I remember how old the Golden Girls looked to little kid me…vs now.
Last time I was at a college baseball game, I wondered why they had middle school aged cheerleader’s…the light is getting dark and the end is near
ISAIP did an episode how dennis bragged about bedding a teaching when he was 14, dee convinced him he was raped at that age.
Universal healthcare and confederate history in the South.
When the Obamacare talks started I thought it was a terrible idea because all I’d heard was how has the government was and didn’t know how bad healthcare and insurance were. Now I think universal healthcare is a great idea, but I still think we’re dumb for trying for it at the federal level. California is as wealthy and populous as Canada and it makes a lot more sense for them to go their own way and have like minded states follow than to try and convince states like Florida it’s a good idea.
Confederacy in the south is weird. I was raised learning about the biased southern version, calling it the war of northern aggression, going to battle re-enactments and daughters of the confederacy get togethers. It wasn’t until I looked into the real history on my own that I discovered how terrible the South was, that they fired the first shot and most importantly that the whole celebration of the souths history started late in the 1900s as a rascist response to try and white wash history.
It baffles me that people will say “we can’t let the government do that; they’re terrible!” then hire terrible, lowest-bid companies to do a thing, have them fail, and then shrug and say “well, nothing we can do about it”.
Have the government do it. Hold them accountable. Make sure that your elected officials know you will pull support if they don’t hold themselves accountable.
The thing is that universal healthcare and such benefit from scale and more bargaining power. Companies will have more people trying to deny and charge hire rates the more states they have to negotiate with. Make it one: the US federal government. That’s not to say that certain things wouldn’t be administered at the state/county/municipal level, but the negotiations for price and such all happen at the top.
Yeah, logically universal healthcare is way more efficient than the insanity we have now. But it also isn’t happening when a large part of the country is strongly against it. And who can blame them when they are from places like Florida or Mississippi where their only experience with government is it being incredibly ineffective and corrupt. I don’t know how you improve the country as a whole without fixing that problem.
I was never so pro-States rights until I watched the American reality TV show. Fuck the fed.
I want taxation and most institutions going through the state first.
Trans athletes in student sports - now I believe there should be no student sports. It’s a waste of educational resources to have a team run by the school system. I went to the football stadium in Allen, TX and I realized how messed up schools have become
Sports are actually good overall, but the overly strong focus and wasted money spent on them is absolutely ridiculous.
I LOLOLED
Its funny how people come to radically different conclusions on one topic:
Conservatives: Omg gEnDeRs! What would we do if a boy and a girl touched, jaysus would rain hellfire on us
LGBT+ Allies: Trans Women are Women
Egalitarians: Gender shouldnt matter
This guy: ABOLISH SPORTS
But still lowkey an interesting take +1
When you find out how much of the education budget goes to the sportsball team instead of the educating it’s not such a radical take.
I went to more than one high school in which the science classrooms were using worn-out microscopes and textbooks old enough that the teacher occasionally told us to correct bits in ink for the next user, while the football team always got the shiniest newest toys to bang their thick skulls together with.
Abolish institutionalized sports; I’m thinking, in favour of self-organized sports. Just remove the fucking money from it in education - remove the money funnel from education anyway - and watch people care less about composition and more about everyone being active and smiling.
people in the usa would rather give up their guns and their right to vote than their sports.
[deleted]
Now it’s so specialized and out of control that the sports I did watch (Olympics and winter sports), have just become rich kid and genetic outliers’ talent shows.
Personal story: Ages ago I was in marching band in TX, so we had to visit multiple other schools to play against them.
Some of those stadiums, even 20ish years ago, were ridiculous. So much money that could have gone to much better programs, or even a publicly available stadium that aren’t locked to a specific school district. I left band before graduating.
no school sports - this is the most radical take I’ve ever seen on lemmy.
and i like it. I and I like sports. FWIW the town my brother in has no school sports… the sports are run by an independent volunteer org. Nobody gets paid. but i’m not sure it’s a good ‘model’ because their sports program is mediocre and their teams are average at best.
he’s actually trying to move his family to another town with better sports because he expects his kids to go to college on sports scholarship like him and his wife both did. and there is no way that will happen if his kids are bad sports teams.
i do think sports have educational value, teaching teamwork and discipline and health. i learned more from cross country and marching band versus everything else combined. but i definitely agree about the ridiculous funding disparity, though, no extracurricular should be getting more funding than core classes
my hot take is that sports and bathrooms shouldn’t be gendered. i understand the “seperate but equal” clause doesn’t include gender, but it should, given the better funding and accomodation boys sports get over all but the best girls teams. siloing off genders has catastrophic cultural consequences- “locker room talk” shouldn’t and wouldn’t exist otherwise, plus the whole trans rights thing that shouldn’t and wouldn’t be an issue
The use of language. My mom was a proofreader for a handful of local editorials, so the “correctness” of language was pushed very hard on to me from very little. As a result, I pushed for “correct” language onto others very hard as well. And this isnt about English, but my birth language, which has lots of conjugation rules, gendering details, grammar quirks and special cases; so people do tend to deviate from proper grammar a lot in informal settings (and sometimes in formal as well). I became a “language nazi” of sorts, and noticed quickly how people spoke fearfully in front of me to avoid making mistakes and getting corrected. This was something I (regretfully) took pride of.
Until one day, a friend of mine which specialized in languages said to me: “Language isn’t prescriptive; it’s descriptive”. And it took a while, a plethora of questions, and infinite patience from her, but I eventually came around and understood what she was saying: language is what we use to convey ideas from one to the other. We stick to a given language and grammar (structure) because that’s the common agreement for the language speakers, in the expectations that it makes for easier communication. BUT, if a sentence can transmit correctly a thought, even when not using a word in the dictionary or not applying grammar rules, then it’s fine as long as me (or whomever is the interlocutor) understands what they’re trying to say. Furthermore, even when using proper grammar with “existing words”, communication can be confusing and requires clarification. If you can make up a word in the spot that better conveys what you’re trying to say, then I’m all for it! (And probably will start using it myself). If you learned to speak a certain way and call stuff a different name from what I learned, or if you add extra letters to the word because that’s what you were taught by your family (something very usual) then that’s cool and I’ll respect it.
TLDR: Language has no rules. It is what we make of it.
Emphasis on ‘correctly transmitting a thought’. Many who choose to completely ignore spelling and grammar do not manage to convey their thoughts. If I have to read or listen to something more than a couple times to try to figure out what was said, I skip on to the next item. That person failed to communicate.
True, though this is one of those ideas at the ends of the bell curve. You have authors who brilliantly break the rules and then you have the degeneracy of the language to the point where communication is touch-and-go at best. Having some flexible ground rules is to everyone’s benefit.
Reading Stephen King broke me of this as a teen 40-years ago.
“Hey! That’s not proper English! You can’t use punctuation like that! Did he just make that word up?!”
I had always made A’s in English and was stunned that this popular author often flouted the rules. But, as you said, he conveyed his descriptions brilliantly.
Thanks for sharing, my dad was a language purist as well, and it took me to marrying a local girl that used a lot of slang to break the habit. Even though sometimes, I cannot stop myself, I’ve become a much easier person to be around with.
I know you said English isn’t your native language, but I’m choosing to believe the grammar and punctuation mistakes in your post are just there to troll people who are still “language Nazis”. :-P
However, I was led to believe that some languages are prescriptive. For example, French has Académie Française. I was told (no idea how true it is) that it’s actually “in charge” of the language, so they get to decide what is “right”. The wiki page seems to indicate that they decide what goes in the French dictionary. That being said, I have no idea what authority they actually have outside of that. I doubt they’re issuing fines for using loanwords.
As a French speaker, the Académie Française is a bunch of old people completely disconnected from reality. They are usually considered irrelevant by the vast majority of French speakers, and a relic of the past where French had to be imposed to all French territory, including areas where other languages (Breton, Occitan, Catalan, Alsacien, etc.) were spoken.
The Académie thinks you should say “joueur-animateur en direct” instead of “streamer” or I guess “stremur” which literally no one does, so if an Académie prescribes a language but no one follows the rules, does it make a language?
Yes, that’s precisely my point. The language is a living being, and any authority pretending to rule over it is just smoke; word will be spoken, meanings will be given. Literally like the word “literally”, which now has a double meaning due to common (mis?)use.
Although, I’ve never been a fan of police, I used to believe that there were plenty of “good” police, and that changed during the George Floyd protests when I started thinking and reading about police more. I mean, there probably are “decent” police officers, but they appear to be an extremely small minority, and the systems they uphold are still evil. By and large, they are just another gang.
I’m still trying re-form my opinions on AI/ML/automation as well. I used to be very pro AI, and focused on ML in grad school. I thought extreme automation would be great for humanity and free us up to do things we enjoy. This current AI boom is focusing AI on the things people enjoy doing. It’s starting to look like AI may be able to find solutions to hard problems (e.g. the recent math problems solved by OpenAI), but it seems like the value of the result is much less than what would’ve been learned along the way if done by a human. I.e. if a human solved it, it would’ve likely surfaced new problems to solve, or new methodologies that could’ve been used to solve other problems. But, from what I’ve gathered, the proofs the AI made are unlike anything a human would come up with, and the problems are solved in more of a “brute force” manner that offers little further insights. So, the journey may be more important than the destination, or however that saying goes.
I used to be somewhere in the neighborhood of anarchist/social democrat, the way most people on lemmy who aren’t MLs are. I was just as “anti-tankie” as anyone.
While trying to really define what I believed, I stumbled across Progress and Poverty by Henry George, and it really clicked for me. It made the case that no one should have a specific right of ownership over land and natural resources, so they should be considered publicly owned and used to fund the state. Without getting into the details of the idea itself, I was convinced that it could work, as a compromise that would fix the worst parts of capitalism and essentially get the best parts of both. That, if it were enacted in a few small countries and able to compete on a level playing field, it would prove itself successful and serve as a model for everyone to follow. But this raised the question of, if that’s true, why hasn’t it happened already?
This question caused me to take an interest in a bunch of random small countries around the world that had experimented with asserting state control over their natural resources, and using them to fund social spending for the benefit of the people. And what did I find? Let’s look at a case study.
Mohammad Mossadegh of Iran was the prime example for me, because he wasn’t a Marxist at all, he had no ties whatsoever to the USSR, and did everything right. He attempted to assert control over Iran’s oil, which had been stolen outright by the British on a massive scale, in order to use it to uplift the people, who were incredibly poor and destitute. He believed in and upheld democratic ideals, and that exactly how the CIA was able to freely operate in Iran and oust him in favor of a literal monarchy.
Mossadegh refused to censor the press, when the CIA controlled 90% of the newspapers in the country, which constantly printed negative stories about him. He refused to suppress demonstrations, when the CIA was hiring them to march, both against him, and for him while wrecking shit and turning people against him. Finally, a US diplomat fed him a false story about the embassy receiving death threats from his supporters, and he was so moved, and so concerned about remaining friendly with the US, that he put out a radio message instructing his supporters to stand down. The next day, the CIA attacked his residence and there was no one to come to his aid.
It took me a long time to really wrestle with the full implications of that case study, and the similar stories that I found all around the world. But what I eventually realized is that the reason so many socialist states are authoritarian is not because they just want to be, it’s survivorship bias. And while the US is able to act as a global hegemon, the kind of system that I idealized, the kind of system Mossadegh was trying to build, will never be allowed to compete fairly. In fact, it is precisely because it might work to fix the worst parts of capitalism that it cannot be permitted, because a lot of powerful people get very, very rich off of those parts. It’s not about the food, it’s about keeping those ants in line.
I would much rather live in the world where the Marxist-Leninists were wrong. I would love it if countries around the world could try out all sorts of different systems, without fear of outside interference, so that different systems could compete and rise or fall on their own merits. If, when I looked into history I had found something different, I’d probably still agree with the criticisms I did before. But, unfortunately, that’s just not the world we live in. When you actually study history, what you’ll find in nearly every case is that the US tried to meddle in their affairs, to the detriment of the average person, and they were successful whenever they were not suppressed by force.
And that’s how I became a “tankie.”
From The Jakarta Method:
Capital commands a mind boggling capacity for violence, and any attempt to change power structures need to take that into account. A peaceful revolution is impossible because literally millions of thugs will be paid to stop it.
I dont understand how the US doing stupid evil shit makes you go from Georgism to tankie? Its the same argument american cuban expats use to fear monger about communism (except in their case they cite cases of the USSR doing stupid evil shit). To me economics and politics are correlated, but not that strongly. You can have Georgism without hegemony. You could have evil socialist hegemons (look at some of the nationalistic Israeli kibbutzim).
They very clearly explained their position, your lack of understanding is a comprehension problem.
Yeah, you have to assume your new society will be under constant attack. The problem with tankies is not that they are willing to fight back. The problem is they are fighting for systems already as corrupt, or worse, than “western capitalist” systems.
By what standard do you say socialist countries are “already as corrupt, or worse, than western capitalist systems?” The various socialist countries have managed to stand outside the paradigm of capital-dominated societies into human-run societies, and this has resulted in dramatic differences in who receives the primary benefits of social production. The first thing communists typically do upon successfully establishing state power is land reform, away from landlords, and into public and cooperative hands. Social programs soon follow, and production becomes something with a definite plan, typically in the range of five year segments.
Tankies have to grapple with running a new form of society while also protecting the gains of revolution from the international imperialist dictatorship of the collective west, spearheaded by the US. This has resulted in the buildup of high-security forces and structures, the strong states that inevitably come up from revolution. This isn’t something against the people, it’s a strategic necessity for protecting the long-term goals of coherent, planned construction of socialism.
The problem with the Western system is not just corruption, it’s that it’s built on a structure of neocolonialism that dominates the entire world. We are opposed to that social relation. You can compare, say, the US vs Iran and say that the US system is more progressive, but opposing the Iran War should not imply that we like Iran, or that we want to make US society more like Iranian society. But, while the Iran War seems to be unpopular enough to be an exception, in other cases this kind of line is often used against us, and against anyone who genuinely opposes the imperial project. Those who opposed the war in Afghanistan, for example, were branded as terrorist sympathizers, regardless of how they actually felt about Al Qaida or their actual reasons for opposing the war.
Every empire is expansionist, hence colonial. Not just the Western ones. China is colonizing Africa and parts of Asia. Russia has colonized the entirety of Siberia. Even Iran would like to expand if it could. Waging a war against an empire can be OK, even if it is fought by another empire. Fighting Nazis in WW2 was OK. Kuwait intervention was OK. Intervention in the Yugoslavian civil war was OK. Helping Ukraine against Ruzzia is OK. Mostly because they didn’t provide the USA (and “the West”) with imperial benefits, at least not that was plannable. And the people of the European and Pacific theatres , Kuwait, former Yugoslavia, and Ukraine got (or would get) a better life out of the interventions. As opposed to Iraq and Afghanistan. The problem with those wars were that they were fought for the wrong reasons, mostly greed. It smelled from the start, given that 9/11 was obviously a Saudi plot to destabilize the West, which has been a tremendous success since. Had the USA occupied Saudi Arabia, removed the royal family, put the oil fields under UN control, and made serious efforts, not just half-assed ones, to mend the rift between Islam and the West, e.g. by ensuring that Mecca and the pilgrimage remains unaffected, that would have been a war I would have supported. Had Al Gore’s presidency not been stolen, there was a chance that the USA had gone this way, instead of the money grabbing Afghan and Iraqi wars that the MIC convinced Dubya to do.
Point is, oppose or support wars based on their premise and goals, not by who is fighting them. I am yet to see a war fought by Ruzzia that was for the good of anyone but the Ruzzian elite. China hasn’t fought wars recently, but their expansion in the Third World is as cruel as the 19th century Western colonialism was.
This is completely and utterly delusional. Outrageously false. You’re clearly ignorant of the practices of Western colonialism during that era, which included literal chattle slavery. Look up conditions in the Congo, for example, where workers were frequently punished by mutilation just for failing to meet a quota. Which countries is China subjecting to anything remotely similar to those practices? You’re attempting to whitewash this past by pretending that everyone is just as cruel, when the reality is completely different. Even modern day Western neocolonialism is nowhere remotely close to the absolute horror of 19th century colonialism.
The reality is that China offers development loans, which it has on occasion forgiven, and which, unlike Western loans, aren’t conditional on agreeing to anti-worker domestic policies. It does not hold monopolies on the means of production, as is the case in many neocolonies of the West. When the old system of direct control and administration was replaced with the current system, generally, the natural resources that had been stolen through overt force remained in Western hands. This is why, even compared to Western neocolonialism, China is much better for the underdeveloped world.
But forget about China, if you’re going to whitewash the actual history of slavery and colonialism like this then I’m not interested in discussing anything further with you. Nothing comparable in scale and cruelty exists in the modern day (with the possible exception of Israel, being a holdout from “old-school” colonialism).
Uyghur slave labor camps say hi.
Socialism isn’t authoritarian when done right. It should follow what works for the majority, like Nordic models and other places have done well for the people and the measures show it. Good systems use science and research to lead policy for healthy people. It’s not dualistic but demands proof, and real truth withstands scrutiny. The bad examples became authoritarian and benefited the wealthy rather than the majority, but there are good examples to follow and not repeat the same bad histories. The good ones upgraded their education systems to teach critical thinking and other good things for a healthy society. They’re not perfect but try to improve and great policies to start with.
The Nordic countries are allowed to do what they do because the cost benefit calculation was that it was easier to secure their loyalty by allowing them some progressive policies (likewise, this is why the US historically invested in a handful of regions like Germany, Taiwan, and South Korea). But there are many countries in the global south that have tried to follow the Nordic model, the trouble is, they’re not allowed to because the cost-benefit analysis is different. When they try, the CIA overthrows them and installs a dictator who will enact exploitative policies and keep the cheap goods flowing. When they take steps to stop that from happening, Western leftists denounce them as “authoritarian.”
Science and research are followed in AES (actually existing socialism) countries. Look at the response to COVID, for example. While in the US, people where crowding into stores to panic buy toilet paper, Vietnam was delivering free groceries directly to the doorsteps of people under lockdown.
What are the examples of “bad” socialism “benefiting the wealthy rather than the majority?” Socialist states, including Vietnam, Cuba, China, etc have implemented policies that have improved people lives by any objective metric, literacy, life expectancy, doctors and teachers per capita, etc. Granted, they sometimes have little choice but to allow some economic concessions, as a condition to participate in the global market. China’s reforms in the 80’s lead to 800 million people being lifted out of extreme poverty, for example. When a country doesn’t make such concessions and gets sanctioned or blockaded, things tend to go very poorly for them, which also gets held up as a “failure of socialism.” Damned if you do, damned if you don’t.
If you actually evaluate AES countries, based on reasonable expectations or on what they had before, they are not failures at all. The problem is that people don’t understand the challenges and threats that they have to navigate, and so they have unreasonable, impossible expectations of them. Again, I wish we lived in a world where it was possible to simply copy-paste social democratic policies into the global south, but it isn’t. History has proven quite clearly that that isn’t the world we live in. Y’all just never bother to actually study the histories of global south countries, so you don’t understand the severity of the threats they face.
That you should always try to give people the benefit of the doubt. I grew up that turning the other cheek and taking the high road was righteous. It was freeing to realize that even though it might not be 100% someone’s fault; sometimes a racist is a racist, even if they’ve never had the opportunity to broaden their horizon. The alcoholic is choosing not to get help, even if they have a good reason to want to drink. That asshole is an asshole, even if their father beat them as a child.
I hadn’t realized what an emotional burden I’d taken on trying to excuse the bad behavior of others until I came to the realization I needed to stop.
I drink, and there is no help in the US.
Alcoholism isn’t an addiction: truly it is a disease. It starts as a mental issue that then turns physiological.
Then your body stops producing GABA inhibitors.
You see, with smoking, some people quit cold turkey. And that’s fine. But with alcoholism, quitting cold turkey could mean death: Amy Winehouse is an example. It is the culmitive hangover that sends your body into shock.
So to properly detox, it takes about three days of medical attention. They monitor your blood pressure, basically.
But even after release, you require about three more weeks of monitoring. This is the “pink elephant” phase.
My sister stayed with me for the first week, and while I knew she was familiar and I wouldn’t dare say it: I honestly didn’t recognize her. Literally. I had logic to know that I should know her; she was on my couch.
But I honestly just didn’t recognize her.
Now, that was me coming out of my worst point: a fifth and touch on another fifth, chased by 6-8 beers a day.
Thankfully from ASA, I got a chance to clean up. Obamacared!
But while sober, I didn’t have any support once the physiological side was done.
So the mentality that caused the dependence came back.
And this is why groups like AA and NA pair you with a mentor.
The truth is the mentee is also helping the mentor.
So, with another example, I smoke cigarettes. I smoke about a pack a day, if left to my own devices.
I went on a date last week, and she kept me so entertained that in five hours, I only smoked one cigarette. She was a social smoker and bummed one.
I with vocal hesitation gave her one. I really like this woman. I don’t want her to take back up smoking. Greater than my drinking, smoking is the biggest regret of my life.
But she kept me entertained and engaged that I wasn’t wanting whiskey, beer, or cigarettes.
I was happy. I had physiological nags, for sure, but she was removing the actual root cause of my behavior.
I know I have basically written an essay, but my point is that sometimes, in heavily specific arenas, you should give people the benefit of the doubt.
Get them engaged and feel love, and watch those worries just wash away.
And we are going to have dinner on Monday. Wish me luck. She might be my cure, and not leftover thanksgiving tips.
Good luck! May happiness and peace of mind find you regardless of the outcome.
It’s definitely something you have to be careful with. My ex basically used to it to financially and emotionally manipulate me.
I think it’s still healthy to an extent. My current conclusion is understand why someone behaves in a way doesn’t excuse it, just informs the actions you should potentially take.
This ties into a lot of the Boomer-hate out there.
Now, I don’t go out of my way to defend people who treat others poorly - I’ve been hurt by the generations before me as much as any Millennial has been. However, realizing just how shitty the parents of Boomers were to them really opened my eyes. My mother’s far from perfect, but her father was strict in a disturbing way. The control that fathers in the 1950/1960s had over their kids (in the US at least) seems to be glossed over nowadays, but in those times Dad was THE authority… and my grandfather personified that attitude.
Questioning what parents said meant “getting the belt” or other corporal punishments. I used to wonder how my mom went so long without examining the ideas she grew up with (for example, the tradition of married women taking their husbands’ names.) But now I can see that, for her generation, asking such questions was pretty much as invitation to a beating. Baby Boomers’ childhoods were soaked in indoctrination and obedience to authority.
It’s no small wonder that when Baby Boomers came of age, they turned around and followed the model they had growing up, except with them “in charge.”
Anyway, long story short: even our grandparents got fucked over long ago, we can all simultaneously be both victims and perpetrators, We Didn’t Start the Fire, yadda yadda.
After the October 7 attack I was very pro isreal. Of course it’s totally unacceptable for a neighbor to enter one’s territory and kill hundreds of innocent civilians. You can’t commit such an act of terrorism without consequences. However I have seen that the Israeli invasion has been all but moral and the use of the word genocide feels more and more justified. It has gone way over board and I have staunchly become anti isreal. The war was supposed to be a war on Hamas but the innocent civilians in Gaza have had to bear with unbelievable suffering which I no longer believe justifies the war.
What made you not realize the decades of Israeli aggression that caused October 7?
as someone who went through the same, it was mostly lack of attention. i had a vague idea that israel and palestine hated each other, and it was easy to understand from a perspective of israel taking palestinian land, but when you don’t think about it too much it’s easy to both sides it or feel like the supposedly western, supposedly democratic one has a point. i think a lot of people in the west had that vague, unrefined view when oct 7 happened, and it’s easy to stand with someone who just suffered a terror attack.
but it just kept being a focus in media, and the more you look into it, the clearer israel’s crimes against humanity become. and the crazy part is that the vague perspective of israel taking the land for themselves is absolutely correct, but when you see it for the real atrocity it is, rather than an abstract curiosity, it’s impossible to side with the occupiers if you’re not a bigot.
I can only add that, as much as I despise what occurred to Israel that day, it achieved their objectives in a way nothing else probably could have. It’s difficult to morally reconcile, but the evil they committed against Israel exposed a greater evil Israel was committing against them.
This is exactly how I see it as well, it brought the worlds attention to their situation and exposed Israel’s human rights violations and other atrocities to the forefront where as earlier it was easy to think of it as some local border dispute, now it’s apparent that Israel is a apartheid country that is trying to slowly genocide a group of people and will never agree to any peaceful solution. I hope that Americans get their shit together and force the next group of politicians that come to power to stop funding this amoral crime against humanity through their tax dollars
I was in the same boat (outside of being already critical regarding israels illegal settlements in the west bank). Main reason was that growing up in Austria, criticizing anything jewish was practically a taboo, and the only ones doing it publicly were the far right, which delegitimized all of it in public discussion. (Edit: This effect was surely even stronger in Germany. It’s actually an great development that german politics are wizening up, even if it’s a slow process)
It took their atrocities to make me realize how much effort Israels Zionists are putting into trying to tie Judaism/Ethnic Jews/Zionism together, so that blaming Israel can be countered by accusing anyone to be an antisemite. (I also have to say that for how good Israel is at Psyops, they really botched this one on the world stage.) I also realized that the conflict became a lot more one sided over the years; in the 80s and 90s there still was a push for a 2-state solution, and attacks in both directions were a common occurrence. Nowadays Israelis getting hurt is often the direct result of repressive action from Israels side.
Oct 7 might very well have been an false flag op in retrospective. It gave Bibi the chance to annex all of Gaza, Genocide be damned. It’s similar to Putins staged apartment complex attack.
Bibi received warnings from multiple sources that an attack was planned and yet weren’t troops moved away from the venue where it occurred in days before?
Yeah, the troops patrolling the border were told to stop patrols that morning!
It’s pretty much been confirmed that Netanyahu let it happen.
Then there’s this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hannibal_Directive
I cannot believe that the vaunted Israeli intelligence apparatus, perhaps the best on the planet, didn’t have a clue such a massive attack was coming.
One lesson here is that psyops only work in a nominal range of material conditions.
You can keep comfortable people from paying too much attention to a distant problem, but once daily life becomes too difficult, people’s pattern recognition starts seeing through it fast.
Also people are extremely sensitive to rates of change. The elites panicked and/or got impatient, thought they had it in the bag, and now the general public is more activated and cohesive than they have probably ever been.
US media has spun such a one sided narrative for decades that I never looked close enough to to catch on that it was whitewashing genocide. October 7th and the Israeli reaction was comparable to the US genocide of Native Americans both through the dehumanization and pbvious propaganda that I started paying more attention. The more details came out, including the apartheid state structure, the less I felt that there will ever be a peaceful two state solution when Israel is an expansionist culture that cannot accept or acknowledge the right to exist of the Palestinians whose land they stole, much less the soverignty of their neighbors.
I hope that since then you’ve done some research about the history of the region and conflict. Hamas was not unprovoked.
When I first learned that people were transitioning their gender, I was very much “live and let live,” but took exception at having to call people their preferred pronoun. It seemed like a rigged game to me, like they wanted you to guess at what their gender is, and if you got it wrong, you’re a bigot.
Then my wife was like “what harm does it do to call them what they prefer?”
And I thought about all the hurtful names people teased me with at school, and how I wished they would’ve just called me by my name.
So I said “OK,” and that was that. It hasn’t been as hard as I thought to recognize what people wish to be called. Unless you’re dealing with a “they/them,” then they gotta tell you. Or if you’re dealing with a butch lesbian that dresses boy-ish. On those occasions, I just try not to use any pronouns or talk to them extensively for fear of messing up.
FWIW, for anyone else who has these sorts of thoughts, most people trans/nonbinary people I’ve met don’t tend to get particularly hung up on it if you guess wrong.
They live in the same world you do, they own mirrors, they know how they look, and in a lot of cases they probably spend a whole lot more time agonizing over how they look than anyone else because they’re worrying about whether or not they can pass.
Just take your best guess and if they or someone else corrects you, just apologize and try to do better. You’re probably gonna fuck up, you have a lifetime of indoctrination in the gender binary to unlearn. It happens. I have a friend who’s been dating a nonbinary person for years and occasionally still messes up and uses the wrong pronouns, it happens. The femboy wearing a skirt probably isn’t gonna be offended no matter what pronouns you use for them. The butch lesbian with a buzz cut has probably already been mistaken for a guy 7 times today, it’s nothing new. Trans and non-binary people have probably spent most of their life using pronouns they don’t like, and sure they’d prefer you use the right ones, but it’s nothing new to them.
If you’re unsure when you meet someone and they don’t broach the subject off the bat, go ahead and spell out your own pronouns so they can feel safe to do the same.
Or just stick to they/them. It’s a little awkward sometimes, it takes some getting used to, but the only people I’ve ever seen get offended by it are bigots who I don’t mind offending anyway.
Sure, there’s some subset of the community that gets really huffy about it, and those people are just garden variety assholes who happen to be trans/nonbinary. They’re basically the same as the cis Karen type who for some reason gets a stick up her ass about not wanting to be called “ma’am,” or the guy who insists on correcting you that it’s “Doctor such-and-such” if you dare to refer to him as “mister.” It doesn’t mean you should go ahead and ignore their preference, but don’t put too much stock in their opinions either.
Don’t have fear. As long as you try and are respectful, it’s fine. Even though awareness about this is much better than maybe 20 years ago, a lot of people are still not used to it and are missing the necessary personal experience. Of course they might have difficulties adjusting. But as long as they are polite and try to improve, trans people can be expected to deal with it. Those who immediately call you a bigot are entitled assholes, imo.
It’s a fair common ground: you respect the identity of the trans person, and the trans person forgives you innocent mistakes.
I’ve felt like this. You already call people the name they asked you to call them, it’s like 3 extra brain cells work to just call them what they ask, way too much effort to mess with them or cause animosity.
While transitioning I’m sure they understand there will be genuine mixups.
My kids started saying “it’s not that deep” and seems to really fit here.
I just don’t use pronouns if I’m not sure, because I’ve never seen anger on the level of someone whom I’ve inadvertently misgendered, and it doesn’t seem to cross people’s minds that maybe I’m not a mind reader.
Gender neutral language is just best overall in this scenario.
Assuming this means avoiding gendered pronouns, I agree.
In a vacuum, theoretically, our language would simply be easier without gendered pronouns. But it would be idealistic for me to therefore assert everyone should just always use neutral pronouns and be alright with that. I know some people who intentionally signal their gender feel invalidated by neutral language, so it would be insensitive and pointless for me to disrespect their preference.
In all the societies I’m in, my approach is to default to neutral unless/until someone specifies preferred pronouns or clearly indicates their gender. I haven’t had anyone, progressive nor reactionary, object to this behavior.
That’s also my experience.
People don’t get pissy about neutral language. 🤟😎
Check these fields on a common job application form. Top row? Fine. The rest? I’m not taking that person seriously.
https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/6fa3afc9-8b5b-42f9-9dfc-24bc11bdd6b5.png
“I’m a special little elf and I insist you address me as such.”
Yeah I really try to be inclusive but I’m with you here, that shit is whack. You’re not a fucking bionicle. We’re all trying our best to be nice to you and your new identity, but if you ask me to call you a fairy, I’m going to laugh in your face. I’ll feel bad about it later, probably, but I will do a spit-take in the moment.
Calling it now: The top three stick and the rest will be laughed about it 20 years, if not 10.
Enjoy your permabans, transphobes.
At this point it gets so specific that I don’t get how it is different to a name.
I’m already bad at remembering names so that is just another layer.
I wish just for one that you can use on anybody and it is right.
My religion.
I took a very long sort of a pilgrimage to test my faith and find myself. I found out I believed in myself a hell of a lot more than a god that either doesn’t exist, doesn’t care, or can’t help.
I would share more, but this was an extremely personal and very painful moment for me. I don’t feel comfortable telling the entire story to anyone but my close friends.
literally yesterday a book changed my mind about how much alcohol I’m comfortable consuming
since I’ve started getting horrible hangovers in my 30s I’ve limited myself to 1-2 drinks in one evening, once a month or so, and that worked for me
the book detailed how alcohol absolutely wrecks your sleep. yeah i think I’m done drinking for the rest of my life now lol
Congratulations. You have had one of the healthiest epiphanies you will ever have. I relate very much, although I am probably twice your age. I wish I had that realization 30 years ago.
If you ever have a strong urge to drink again, if it’s legal where you are, a light dose of THC might satisfy you instead. It’s not for everyone, but that’s worked very well for me.
Again, congratulations. Getting away from alcohol is a move so healthy, you should be proud of yourself for it.
thanks :]
ah, i enjoyed THC when I got to try it in a legal state. sadly psychosis runs in my family and I decided even that much fun wasn’t worth the risk
I’m very lucky I’m nerdy enough to get “high” off of just goofing around with friends (and lucky I have the friends!)
Ok I’ll be the one. What book?
Why We Sleep – Matthew Walker
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Why_We_Sleep
That progress is inevitable.
gestures wildly
Progress is inevitable. The problem is the person(s) in charge determines the definition of the word “progress” at that moment.
Change is inevitable.
I used to be a dyed-in-the-wool optimist. Now, I’m an avowed cynic, and most people don’t realize it because I’m generally a cheerful person and that serves to mask it somewhat.
My entire adult life has corresponded to the regressive post-9/11 loss of economic and civil liberty that has drastically impacted the poor and working class in America.
Thing is, I truly believed in Obama. I went to a rally where Michelle spoke in September 2008. In late October, Obama dropped by for a rally, and there were so many of us that the organizers had to cut the line off and we had to sit on a nearby hill and just listen. I was 100%, absolutely certain that real, lasting change was coming.
But nope. Our two wars became seven. (That we know of.) Occupy was brutally crushed by the NYPD with Obama’s tacit approval. Police became militarized, even after Ferguson. Torture continued and the War on Terror continued unabated, despite Obama having a mandate to end it. No one from Wall Street that crashed our economy for profit went to prison, even though a foreclosure crisis followed. Life began to become unaffordable and the minimum wage stayed at $7 an hour. Despite having the votes to universalize health care, Obama made it more expensive instead. The cherry on top was that Obama gave us Tom Homan.
All of these problems have continued and worsened in the decade since 2016, despite both parties having total power for years at a time.
Now, no matter who we elect at the federal (and mostly state) level, I know things are never getting better.
My only power is local. Thankfully, my city is doing good things, so there’s that, but if I had the money to do so I’d leave this country completely and reside abroad instead.
The “Hope/Change” rugpull from Obama was pretty devastating. There was so much to believe in.
Sign in to comment. Sign in