Trans athletes in student sports - now I believe there should be no student sports. It’s a waste of educational resources to have a team run by the school system. I went to the football stadium in Allen, TX and I realized how messed up schools have become
I went to more than one high school in which the science classrooms were using worn-out microscopes and textbooks old enough that the teacher occasionally told us to correct bits in ink for the next user, while the football team always got the shiniest newest toys to bang their thick skulls together with.
Abolish institutionalized sports; I’m thinking, in favour of self-organized sports. Just remove the fucking money from it in education - remove the money funnel from education anyway - and watch people care less about composition and more about everyone being active and smiling.
Now it’s so specialized and out of control that the sports I did watch (Olympics and winter sports), have just become rich kid and genetic outliers’ talent shows.
Personal story: Ages ago I was in marching band in TX, so we had to visit multiple other schools to play against them.
Some of those stadiums, even 20ish years ago, were ridiculous. So much money that could have gone to much better programs, or even a publicly available stadium that aren’t locked to a specific school district. I left band before graduating.
no school sports - this is the most radical take I’ve ever seen on lemmy.
and i like it. I and I like sports. FWIW the town my brother in has no school sports… the sports are run by an independent volunteer org. Nobody gets paid. but i’m not sure it’s a good ‘model’ because their sports program is mediocre and their teams are average at best.
he’s actually trying to move his family to another town with better sports because he expects his kids to go to college on sports scholarship like him and his wife both did. and there is no way that will happen if his kids are bad sports teams.
i do think sports have educational value, teaching teamwork and discipline and health. i learned more from cross country and marching band versus everything else combined. but i definitely agree about the ridiculous funding disparity, though, no extracurricular should be getting more funding than core classes
my hot take is that sports and bathrooms shouldn’t be gendered. i understand the “seperate but equal” clause doesn’t include gender, but it should, given the better funding and accomodation boys sports get over all but the best girls teams. siloing off genders has catastrophic cultural consequences- “locker room talk” shouldn’t and wouldn’t exist otherwise, plus the whole trans rights thing that shouldn’t and wouldn’t be an issue
I agree that it shouldn’t be a part of compulsory school, even though I was in multiple sports and marching band. I argued this on the essay portion of my ACT back in the '90s and it was not graded all that well (despite my always getting top grades in English and writing classes).
I do think there should be community sports instead. Physical education and teamwork is important, but I don’t think it belongs in the school itself. This also can help bring communities together and also changes the focus from schools and their funding.
Post-secondary is a bit more blurry to me, though. Should scholarships for sports exist? Should sports be a part of universities and not communities or something? I would say it probably should still be at a community level with maybe different leagues. The only immediate thing I can think of that might be impacted is maybe sports medicine or similar classes that work with athletes?
Not even, it’s uniquely US South (saying this confidently because I’ve heard people talk about high school sports’ outsized place in Southern culture.) My high school’s football field was not a stadium, it had basic bleachers and doubled as the track (meaning it was something gym classes used regularly.) And that school was largely considered to overfund sports.
Once you have independent sporting clubs, they’re going to demand open leagues, and I really don’t know what will happen if USians learn en masse what they’ve been missing there.
I’m big into sports but this seems like a reasonable take – it’s already the case that none of the good youth soccer leagues are affiliated with schools, and it’s easy to see how you extend that model to other school sports. Also, having the NCAA be the minor league for the NFL is enriching NFL owners at the expense of our university system. The downside, of course, is that we’ll exclude children whose parents can’t afford to pay for club sports, which generally I’m in favor of moving public goods (like getting children active and learning how to cooperate) to be paid for by government rather than private enterprise, but I get it. I’m not sure how it relates to trans athletes in sports, though – you’re just kicking the can down the road to a bunch of laws and lawsuits about discrimination and participation in club sports rather than school sports.
Comments
Trans athletes in student sports - now I believe there should be no student sports. It’s a waste of educational resources to have a team run by the school system. I went to the football stadium in Allen, TX and I realized how messed up schools have become
Sports are actually good overall, but the overly strong focus and wasted money spent on them is absolutely ridiculous.
I LOLOLED
Its funny how people come to radically different conclusions on one topic:
Conservatives: Omg gEnDeRs! What would we do if a boy and a girl touched, jaysus would rain hellfire on us
LGBT+ Allies: Trans Women are Women
Egalitarians: Gender shouldnt matter
This guy: ABOLISH SPORTS
But still lowkey an interesting take +1
When you find out how much of the education budget goes to the sportsball team instead of the educating it’s not such a radical take.
I went to more than one high school in which the science classrooms were using worn-out microscopes and textbooks old enough that the teacher occasionally told us to correct bits in ink for the next user, while the football team always got the shiniest newest toys to bang their thick skulls together with.
Abolish institutionalized sports; I’m thinking, in favour of self-organized sports. Just remove the fucking money from it in education - remove the money funnel from education anyway - and watch people care less about composition and more about everyone being active and smiling.
people in the usa would rather give up their guns and their right to vote than their sports.
[deleted]
Now it’s so specialized and out of control that the sports I did watch (Olympics and winter sports), have just become rich kid and genetic outliers’ talent shows.
Personal story: Ages ago I was in marching band in TX, so we had to visit multiple other schools to play against them.
Some of those stadiums, even 20ish years ago, were ridiculous. So much money that could have gone to much better programs, or even a publicly available stadium that aren’t locked to a specific school district. I left band before graduating.
no school sports - this is the most radical take I’ve ever seen on lemmy.
and i like it. I and I like sports. FWIW the town my brother in has no school sports… the sports are run by an independent volunteer org. Nobody gets paid. but i’m not sure it’s a good ‘model’ because their sports program is mediocre and their teams are average at best.
he’s actually trying to move his family to another town with better sports because he expects his kids to go to college on sports scholarship like him and his wife both did. and there is no way that will happen if his kids are bad sports teams.
i do think sports have educational value, teaching teamwork and discipline and health. i learned more from cross country and marching band versus everything else combined. but i definitely agree about the ridiculous funding disparity, though, no extracurricular should be getting more funding than core classes
my hot take is that sports and bathrooms shouldn’t be gendered. i understand the “seperate but equal” clause doesn’t include gender, but it should, given the better funding and accomodation boys sports get over all but the best girls teams. siloing off genders has catastrophic cultural consequences- “locker room talk” shouldn’t and wouldn’t exist otherwise, plus the whole trans rights thing that shouldn’t and wouldn’t be an issue
I agree that it shouldn’t be a part of compulsory school, even though I was in multiple sports and marching band. I argued this on the essay portion of my ACT back in the '90s and it was not graded all that well (despite my always getting top grades in English and writing classes).
I do think there should be community sports instead. Physical education and teamwork is important, but I don’t think it belongs in the school itself. This also can help bring communities together and also changes the focus from schools and their funding.
Post-secondary is a bit more blurry to me, though. Should scholarships for sports exist? Should sports be a part of universities and not communities or something? I would say it probably should still be at a community level with maybe different leagues. The only immediate thing I can think of that might be impacted is maybe sports medicine or similar classes that work with athletes?
Not only would amateur sports leagues helps schools to focus on education, they would be a massive boon to the obesity and loneliness epidemics.
I think that’s an American-centric view. It’s uniquely American to build a stadium for high school sports.
Not even, it’s uniquely US South (saying this confidently because I’ve heard people talk about high school sports’ outsized place in Southern culture.) My high school’s football field was not a stadium, it had basic bleachers and doubled as the track (meaning it was something gym classes used regularly.) And that school was largely considered to overfund sports.
That’s like saying the arts are a waste, it’s a “I don’t like it or see the benefit so it shouldn’t exist” scenario
Once you have independent sporting clubs, they’re going to demand open leagues, and I really don’t know what will happen if USians learn en masse what they’ve been missing there.
I’m big into sports but this seems like a reasonable take – it’s already the case that none of the good youth soccer leagues are affiliated with schools, and it’s easy to see how you extend that model to other school sports. Also, having the NCAA be the minor league for the NFL is enriching NFL owners at the expense of our university system. The downside, of course, is that we’ll exclude children whose parents can’t afford to pay for club sports, which generally I’m in favor of moving public goods (like getting children active and learning how to cooperate) to be paid for by government rather than private enterprise, but I get it. I’m not sure how it relates to trans athletes in sports, though – you’re just kicking the can down the road to a bunch of laws and lawsuits about discrimination and participation in club sports rather than school sports.
Sign in to comment. Sign in