Skip to content

Comment on What was the last major belief you took a 180 on? What caused you to change your mind?

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments

Comments

  • @Fallibilist@feddit.uk· · edited

    Not that I spent much time thinking about it in the past but the belief in free will was something I was disillusioned from by hearing Sam Harris talk about it and then reading his book on the subject.

    Now I believe there is just consciousness and its content. There is no “you” that’s separate from this process that’s authoring your decisions. Nah, everything follows from past events and the belief that you could have done otherwise is just an illusion. How could you have done otherwise. We already know what you did in this timeline. If we rewind back the universe without changing anything you’d just make the same choice again and again and again.

    I’d say it has made me a much more empathic person overall. Hating someone for example is no longer compatible with my world view. Not liking, sure, but treating people as if they chose to be this way and could choose to be different but won’t - that’s bullshit.

    Charles Whitman is a good example. Shot a bunch of people from a clock tower, left a suicide note saying he doesn’t know why he does this and tells doctors to study his brain when he’s dead. Well, they did and found a pecan-sized tumor near his amygdala that could very well explain this behaviour. Would you still hold Charles morally responsible after learning this? I wouldn’t. I basically just live as if everyone has a brain tumor.

    9
    • Ever read the novel Blindsight? The author has the same take on free will, but there are loads more concepts to unpack. I’ve probably read it 14 times and still find something new.

      The author notes in the back where he got his ideas and gives links to read science papers and write ups on any given subject.

      3
    • I’ve been reeling for a month after watching this Dr Sapolsky interview on that precise topic. Halfway through the book that gave way to the interview; I also feel more… humane? when judging people’s actions.

      1
    • Determinism is interesting, there are many different interpretations and discussions of it. But I avoid choosing any side because there are arguments for and against it. Maybe you like the buddhist interpretation of it, your views sound similar to it, like anatta and karma

      0
    • Making decisions based on history feels free to Me. If My decisions were a dice roll, if I could suddenly change and act completely differently? I’d feel less free. I like living in a mostly deterministic universe.

      0
      • There is no free will but there is an experience of freedom.

        We do things for two reasons; either you want to or you have to. There’s clearly no freedom in having to do something but it’s not exactly like you can choose your wants (and not-wants) either. However, your actions are still aligned with your underlying desires which is what gives the experience of freedom despite the fact that you did not author those desires.

        So yes, it’s still a voluntary action. We do stuff for a reason - it’s not fatalism I’m talking about where everything is pre-determined and stuff keeps happening even if you just sit and wait.

        0
        • Why would I want to change My wants? I have the free will to pursue My wants, I don’t want different wants.

          0
          • What you want and what you want to want are not always aligned. I want to sit inside and do nothing for the rest of the day after I get home from work. It’s not what I want to want but I don’t have the freedom to not-want it. I wish I instead wanted to work out, meditate, read and do woodworking projects.

            0
            • Oh, that kind of wanting. Yeah, I use occult techniques like meditation, illusions, and rituals to change those kinds of wants. But I do have to be careful, because sometimes I have those impulses to rest because I’m tired and I need rest. But if I judge an impulse unhelpful, oftentimes I can change it with magic.

              I guess I have more free will than you because I have more knowledge of how to alter My mind!

              0
              Continue this thread 2 more replies

Sign in to comment. Sign in