I’ve only seen Les Mis once, and that was the movie. Maybe the songs grow in you over time. But for whatever reason the songs didn’t hit for me. I didn’t mean to impugn it as a work of art, clearly it is beloved by many, many people. I love Anne Hathaway as an actress, and I Dreamed A Dream was a great song, but I can’t recall liking another song.
Not to pile on ya regarding your les mis stance, but I feel like your own point about how music can amplify the emotional weight of otherwise spoken words really really applies to les mis, and simultaneously doesn’t violate ops original complaint of it being a space filler.
Les mis generally clips at the same pace regardless of a musical or otherwise (Liam neeson and uma Thurman did a non musical movie, fantastic, and makes a great baseline comparison for pacing purposes)
Tons of it is straight dialogue set to music. Some are straight solos, but they’re all characters wrestling with some heavy shit. Who am I? I dreamed a dream. Stars.
One for sure can’t switch off their “people are saying critical things which advance the plot” ears. So many musicals, the musical numbers are fanfare and as a result a lot of people have been trained to kinda tune out a Lil’ bit. Fatal mistake for les mis.
Anyways, you don’t HAVE to like it, you’re allowed to not. Just surprised it made the “do not like” given your earlier explanation.
Edit: also I never saw the one with Hathaway. I saw a snippet and I could see Jackman and crowe just wouldn’t be able to nail the valjean javert and that’s CRITICAL.
I’ve only given it one chance and it’s fair to call me out. I’ve only given Cats one chance, as well. Phantom speaks to me on a level. As a young man, the idea that if I could just love someone hard enough they would love me back, was intensely appealing. Which is just to say that the first time I heard those songs I felt them in my core. Les Mis doesn’t have any story I can relate to not having seen it.
Also, I have to say that a huge chunk of the magic of Hamilton was just seeing the story come to life on stage. And I said I hate Wicked, but I don’t. I appreciate the story and seeing it on stage. But it’s about the stage rather than the music, although Popular is catchy as fuck. Defying Gravity is nothing without seeing it on stage.
It seems likely that if I ever gave Les Mis a fair shake, I would probably come to love it, once the story has taken root. But I can’t even speak the language for 1/3 of Moana songs and I find it beautiful.
It IS subjective, and I think you’re bang on about sometimes you really just vibe with some element of a story it just gets you.
And I’m super guilty of that (I say as if it’s a crime) so I’m sure my view of Les Mis is probably super biased. The central theme that a man isn’t defined by his past, but by his active commitments to his values… A full throated rejection of utilitarianism (which of course runs counter to peak 16 year old conception of philosophy)… God it hits. As hard when I was 16 as it does now.
The few lines as Valjean weighs intervening to protect a man on trial (for a crime Valjean himself committed decades earlier):
“How can I ever face my fellow men?”
slightly quieter
“How can I ever face myself again?”
Wilkinson NNAAIILLSS it.
So yah, some stuff’ll just vibe with you.
Cats is dogshit though. Just a parade of random cats. I don’t get it.
I’ve only seen Les Mis once, and that was the movie.
That’s your problem right there; most musical fans will agree with you that the movie sucks. Try seeing a live stage performance with real singers and see if it changes your opinion.
Comments
I’ve only seen Les Mis once, and that was the movie. Maybe the songs grow in you over time. But for whatever reason the songs didn’t hit for me. I didn’t mean to impugn it as a work of art, clearly it is beloved by many, many people. I love Anne Hathaway as an actress, and I Dreamed A Dream was a great song, but I can’t recall liking another song.
Not to pile on ya regarding your les mis stance, but I feel like your own point about how music can amplify the emotional weight of otherwise spoken words really really applies to les mis, and simultaneously doesn’t violate ops original complaint of it being a space filler.
Les mis generally clips at the same pace regardless of a musical or otherwise (Liam neeson and uma Thurman did a non musical movie, fantastic, and makes a great baseline comparison for pacing purposes)
Tons of it is straight dialogue set to music. Some are straight solos, but they’re all characters wrestling with some heavy shit. Who am I? I dreamed a dream. Stars.
One for sure can’t switch off their “people are saying critical things which advance the plot” ears. So many musicals, the musical numbers are fanfare and as a result a lot of people have been trained to kinda tune out a Lil’ bit. Fatal mistake for les mis.
Anyways, you don’t HAVE to like it, you’re allowed to not. Just surprised it made the “do not like” given your earlier explanation.
Edit: also I never saw the one with Hathaway. I saw a snippet and I could see Jackman and crowe just wouldn’t be able to nail the valjean javert and that’s CRITICAL.
I’ve only given it one chance and it’s fair to call me out. I’ve only given Cats one chance, as well. Phantom speaks to me on a level. As a young man, the idea that if I could just love someone hard enough they would love me back, was intensely appealing. Which is just to say that the first time I heard those songs I felt them in my core. Les Mis doesn’t have any story I can relate to not having seen it.
Also, I have to say that a huge chunk of the magic of Hamilton was just seeing the story come to life on stage. And I said I hate Wicked, but I don’t. I appreciate the story and seeing it on stage. But it’s about the stage rather than the music, although Popular is catchy as fuck. Defying Gravity is nothing without seeing it on stage.
It seems likely that if I ever gave Les Mis a fair shake, I would probably come to love it, once the story has taken root. But I can’t even speak the language for 1/3 of Moana songs and I find it beautiful.
Art is subjective.
It IS subjective, and I think you’re bang on about sometimes you really just vibe with some element of a story it just gets you.
And I’m super guilty of that (I say as if it’s a crime) so I’m sure my view of Les Mis is probably super biased. The central theme that a man isn’t defined by his past, but by his active commitments to his values… A full throated rejection of utilitarianism (which of course runs counter to peak 16 year old conception of philosophy)… God it hits. As hard when I was 16 as it does now.
The few lines as Valjean weighs intervening to protect a man on trial (for a crime Valjean himself committed decades earlier):
“How can I ever face my fellow men?”
slightly quieter
“How can I ever face myself again?”
Wilkinson NNAAIILLSS it.
So yah, some stuff’ll just vibe with you.
Cats is dogshit though. Just a parade of random cats. I don’t get it.
That’s your problem right there; most musical fans will agree with you that the movie sucks. Try seeing a live stage performance with real singers and see if it changes your opinion.
Sign in to comment. Sign in