260
What linguistic hills are you willing to die on?
Are there commonly used words or phrases that rankle you, or that have multiple ‘right’ usages, but you feel only one is actually correct?
I’ll go first, I have 3 big ones:
First, the plural of ‘roof’ is ‘rooves’. Hoof::hooves, calf::calves, half::halves, etc. Rooves, goddammit.
Second, you can’t eat your cake and have it, too. Conversely, you must have your cake in order to eat it. Thus ‘can’t have your cake and eat it too’ is nonsensical. No, I am not the Unabomber.
Third:
https://lemmy.ca/pictrs/image/04253717-dd29-43fd-b311-f52e07d011b7.png
Comments
You mean “On which linguistic hills are you willing to die?”
Kristen Schall in Last Man On Earth, because this is a joke.
Ending sentences with a preposition is widely regarded as ok, and the “rule” has been kept alive for some stupid reason by pedants who prefer to have their spoken word sound deliberately awkward.
Comes from snobbery about Latin being the only civilized language and wanting to import its grammar into unrelated languages. You literally can not construct a full sentence in Latin that ends in a preposition, only fragments.
The rule was probably made by the same knobs who decided that singular they was wrong
Irregardless is not a word. It is used in the same meaning as regardless, so just use the correct form.
It’s just “myriad”, not “myriad of”
“Scuzzm0nkey drank themselves to sleep every night to combat their myriad frustrations and anxieties.”
To “eat your cake and have it too” is contradictory because that is the point. That phrase is meant to highlight a contradictory attitude or behaviour in another person, by creating a contradictory premise or image.
Which is why - whe spoken to the unreasonable party - it is usually preceded by “you can’t”, to indicate that the party is demanding that a fundamental rule of reality be bent or broken for them to have satisfaction.
As for usages that personally rankle me, it’s gotta be the Oxford Comma. It’s absolutely essential to ensuring that Hitler and Stalin aren’t the strippers.
And the phrase “it is what it is” is meant to be a stoic response to things that you yourself cannot control, and so you do the smart thing and don’t even try (at most you try to work around it). But the problem I see in modern civ is that most speakers are using it to leverage “learned helplessness” and to justify laziness. As in, the thing is something the speaker can control, they just don’t want to get off their fat ass to do anything about it.
Agreed on all counts.
In a similar vein, the oft used “pull yourself up by your bootstraps” has deviated from the intended meaning which is to facetiously suggest to do the impossible. Lately, I see it used as indicating the subject needs to develop some grit or already has it.
“It is what it is” is also a thought-terminating phrase, which is a concept more people need to know about. Just like knowing about common logical fallacies, it’s important for everyone to be able to identify bullshit when you hear it. I’ve seen people to use phrases like this to completely shut down productive and constructive conversation; it gets weaponized, and education is the only defense.
You had me up until the end. Sometimes it’s not that the person is lazy, but simply thst they’re suffering from an undiagnosed mental health condition. I used to have the same problem for the first 40 years of my life until I found the right medication. I was never lazy, my brain simply wouldn’t make enough of the chemicals I need that motivate most human beings, mainly dopamine. (No joke, I’m constantly screaming at myself to get up and do something, anything, but I just sit there and do nothing instead until the meds kick in.)
The most frustrating part is that in order to feel motivated enough to seek treatment, you need to be on meds. It’s a complete paradox. Only reason why I eventually went is because it was seek treatment or go homeless. So I chose treatment. Unfortunately a lot of people choose homelessness instead, and oftentimes it’s not their fault. They need medication they can’t get because their poor mental health won’t allow them to.
“on accident” can get all the way fucked.
same with “addicting”, though technically correct I’d die on the that hill anyway because i hate it.
British?
ish.
not american, if that answers the question.
Prepositions are arbitrary and don’t matter in the slightest
The question wasn’t “What truly important linguistic hills are you willing to die on?”
I’m aware language is fluid, most of the rules are arbitrary, made up and will shift over time.
Don’t care, “on accident” is rage inducing and can die in a fire.
You’re moving the goalposts. While all of language is a fluid and arbitrary, prepositions are especially so. Definitely not rage inducing
no goalposts were moved, i answered the question as asked and explained my reasoning (or in this case lack thereof)
I specifically said that i know all of those things and that me knowing them doesn’t change my reaction.
The rage isn’t carefully analysing the correctness of the language, the rage sees a stupid usage and does it’s thing.
Why is it stupid? Just because something is different doesn’t make it stupid
Peach it. I remember little kids saying “by purpose” and “on accident.” If you say them as an adult you are wrong.
“Since the inception” does not refer to the beginning of something, it refers to the release of Christopher Nolan’s 2010 dreamscape SciFi movie
He worked on the movie for 10years completing the script in 2008. So since inception should be recognised as 2008 and the inception of inception was 1998.
I think you’re wrong about “rooves.” It’s simply not a word. There are many irregularities & inconsistencies in the English language, and that’s one of them. You’re just gonna have to accept it.
But you’re right about hippie & hippy! I love it, so true.
It is, though.
https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/rooves https://lemmy.ca/pictrs/image/e91a4019-ebf3-45ad-bdb7-0827e968ce4d.jpeg
Oh fuck, LOL. Thanks, I hate it 🤣
Tolkien had to argue with his publisher to get them to approve ‘dwarves’ over the older spelling ‘dwarfs,’ for an example of that pluralization not always being consistent.
“She has a myriad of apples”
Myriad means ‘a lot of’ - so it’s like saying “ATM machine”
You dont say “she has a lot of of apples”
The correct phrase is “she has myriad apples”
To my knowledge myriad also requires the apples to be a variety of types. Fifty granny smith apples isn’t a myriad to choose from.
https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/myriad
Both are correct.
This can be applied to most of the stuff in this entire post. Pet peeve threads are not great for my linguistic sanity.
Both are considered correct.
However, I agree that the version you prefer is better.
Language is descriptive, and while I hate it, the fact that people say “literally” to mean “figuratively” makes it so.
Ugh dammit I ctrl+F’d for “myriad” before posting my own rant and didn’t see this
This is the most unhinged one yet
If you’re going to use thorn and eth, use them properly. Yes, I already have the person who uses just thorn on here blocked. It was a hard decision, but it was the right one for my sanity.
Have in the sense of possess. If you eat the cake, you no longer possess it. Have is present tense, as is eat. So you can’t do both at the same time, because once you eat the cake, there is no more left.
Mine is the Oxford comma.
At some point “but you understood me, right?” stops being a valid excuse for what amounts to unacceptable levels of illiteracy. Some people will say I have the potential to be racist or classist, but I’m not talking about those situations. I’m talking specifically about people who I KNOW could very easily handle just a little bit more but don’t even want to try.
Also using “…” as a period. Insane behaviour.
My own brother does this, among other punctuation mangling. It’s led to chat-based misunderstandings on multiple occasions, to the point where I have seriously considered giving him a copy of the “Oxford A-Z of Grammar and Punctuation” as a Christmas gift.
But how else can I signal my uncertainty over text…
I always thought it was that long pause where they think they’re sounding wise, or are waiting for some crowd to put the oooos and awwws in there.
“Less” is not a synonym for “fewer”.
Lay is transitive. Lie is intransitive. “Lay that down.” “You should lie down.” To be fair the tenses get screwy i.e. lie/lay/lain and lay/laid/laid.
Afterward, not afterwards.
Backward, not backwards.
Etc,
These are not actions. You cannot do them so cannot do multiple of them.
“It’s giving [noun].” It’s giving what?! “It’s giving Oreo cookies.” “It’s giving 2022.” Are we Tamarians? Did we forget the concept of a direct object? The word that’s missing is “vibes.” Is it that difficult to say “vibes.”
“It’s for aesthetic.” No, it’s for “aesthetic purposes” or “the aesthetic.”
Oxford comma is your friend.
Except when it increases ambiguity, rather than reducing it. The University of Oxford style guide recommends against it.
Jeez, I sure am late to this thread.
You scratch something that’s itchy, you don’t itch it.
In the US it’s canceled, not cancelled. Likewise, we say orient, not orientate. Orientate means to orient.
And as others have mentioned, pluralizing the wrong part of those combined nouns: right-of-ways instead of rights-of-way, for example. I hear engineers and planners, people who use this and other similar terms professionally, say it incorrectly all the time.
Exacerbate and exasperate do not mean the same thing. I’m exasperated by people exacerbating the decline of the English language.
I’m going to an orientation in an Oriental country to orient myself with the environment and with some other people who are already oriented there.
Ha I just felt like putting all those in a sentence. But yeah the problem is too many people have improperly created the word “orientate” because they get it confused with “orientation.”
And I love how you came up with so many examples right off the top of your head. I have several linguistic pet peeves too but I only notice them when they happen. Can’t recall them in hot take forums like this.
I’m a stenographer by trade, so I listen to people butcher this goddamn language in a daily basis.
‘Less’ is for uncountable items. ‘Fewer’ is for countable items.
If you could care less, you do care, at least a small amount. If you couldn’t care less, you do not care.
‘Or’ is not exclusive. There is no ‘and/or’. English does not have an exclusive or, unless ‘one of’ or ‘either’ are involved. I use ‘xor’ (exclusive or, borrowed from computer terminology) to express this, and I think others should too.
Do not use ‘literally’ unless you mean what you are saying literally.
Use tone tags in informal writing; it helps!
Use the Oxford comma.
The last item in a list should be preceded by the word ‘and’.
‘They’ is a perfectly acceptable singular pronoun, even though it is syntactically plural while semantically singular, because it has been made standard by use. Just use they.
If you are using archaic English syntax, use it correctly. Do not pull a Zestiel and something like “thou words ringeth true”. It would be “thy words ring true”. ‘Thou’ and ‘thee’ are not interchangeable. Consider this table:
[1]: ‘Mine’ and ‘thine’ were used before ‘h’ and vowels, much like ‘an’ was (and is).
[2]: ‘You’ had replaced ‘ye’ for most plural uses by 1600, adding more ambiguity to the English language.
Edit: grammar
I’m 100% on board with this one. Every major economic epoch in the last 500 years (or more?) has left a profound mark on our language. Just consider how many phrases and terms you use that apply to books, sailboats, railroads, cars, electricity, and more. We’re already well underway with information technology terms (“delete” is used instead of “remove” a lot these days), so why not add a few more?
I’m glad you agree!
It seems sensible to me.
According to your table it should be “thy words ring true”, words is third person plural. Anyway, I think it would probably be closer to “thy words ringen true”.
The third person plural possessive was “their”.
What I am using here is not a third person plural of any kind.The pronoun is a second person singular possessive, so it would be ‘thy’.The verb would also be ‘ringest’ because the present tense verb ending for second person singular was ‘-est’.‘-en’ was not a present tense verb ending of any person or plurality.
Edit: I was incorrect on one count.
“Thy” is a possessive determiner, it accompanies “words” which is also the subject of the sentence and is third person plural. You can replace “thy” with a different determiner such as “the words ring true”, or replace “thy words” with a pronoun “they ring true”, not “you ring true”.
I see your point. You are correct, then, about the person. There would not be an ‘-en’ ending, however. It would just be “thy words ring true”.
There is this Youtuber I watch who pronounces the “x” in “1.5 x damage” as “X”, not as “times”. I find that weird, yet don’t know enough if this is regional, or if the “x” really doesn’t stand for “times” in this phrase (any more?).
Saying 2 “ecks” has been around at least thirty years in the US
Common: I always use “beg the question” correctly.
Rare: “the Hoi polloi” is a tautology. “Hoi” means “the”
Purposefully to mean ‘intentionally’ or ‘on purpose’. It has a subtly different meaning.
On accident, in place of by accident.
Flavorful instead of flavorsome, the pre-existing word with that meaning.
People who criticise someone else’s “pronounciation”.
We need to drop the phrasing “for a period of time”. Instead, we can just say “for a time” or “for a while”.
In just about every case, “period” is doing zero work, making this a tad more cumbersome. It’s also redundant, as the use of “time” in this context already has a beginning and an end. A single point in time is just “a moment” or even “in an instant”, so there’s no ambiguity here. There’s just extra words.
Similarly, I’m annoyed when someone describes a period of time and says “time” at the end. “Three days time”, oh, good thing you said time or I would have thought you meant three days weight
3 days time is 72 hours, as opposed to 3 calendar days.
9AM Tuesday to 9 AM Friday is 3 days time but spans 4 calendar days.
If you could care less, you care a bit. If you couldn’t care less, you don’t care.
This and “could of” instead of could’ve raise my blood pressure
Yes, that’s annoying too
“Orientate” is not a word. The original actual word is just “orient.” The noun form is “orient”+“-ation”, not “orientate”+“-ion”.
Is this a bit like “conversate”?
It’s not ‘oh’, it’s ‘zero’.
Sign in to comment. Sign in