Skip to content
  • 0 points on What linguistic hills are you willing to die on? in !asklemmy@lemmy.world ·

    TL;DR;

    I explain multiple times i’m referring to an emotional reaction not a logical one.

    emotions aren’t always logical.


    ugh, ok fine, i never actually thought I’d find someone worse than me at reading context.

    I’ll go slowly.


    “on accident” can get all the way fucked.

    Standard reply to the question, a bit of colourful language, but nothing particularly contextually noteworthy as a standalone sentence.

    same with “addicting”, though technically correct

    A follow up, secondary example,

    I explain that i know it’s technically correct, thus positioning myself as someone who potentially understands the linguistic aspects of the statement they are making.

    I follow up with :

    I’d die on the that hill anyway because i hate it.

    A statement with emotional language implying i’m taking this emotional stance over the logically sound idea that the example is technically correct.


    you reply with

    Prepositions are arbitrary and don’t matter in the slightest

    I reply , in essence , with “i know, i don’t care , i’m sticking with the emotional response i previously stated.”

    To break it down:

    The question wasn’t “What truly important linguistic hills are you willing to die on?”

    Pointing out that the question made no mention of the replies needing to be being logically sound.

    As a small aside, i would mention that i consider the idea of “a hill you are willing to die on” to imply some level of emotional investment, not just logical, but that’s possibly a personal take so it might no be relevant here.

    I’m aware language is fluid, most of the rules are arbitrary, made up and will shift over time.

    For a second time , pointing out that i know what i’m stating isn’t a sound logical argument.

    Don’t care, “on accident” is rage inducing and can die in a fire.

    Explicitly pointing out that i’m disregarding logic in favour of emotion.


    You reply with:

    You’re moving the goalposts. While all of language is a fluid and arbitrary, prepositions are especially so. Definitely not rage inducing

    Missing the very explicit explanations of the meaning of what i said.

    Still not sure what goalposts you think were moved.

    I reply with

    no goalposts were moved, i answered the question as asked and explained my reasoning (or in this case lack thereof)

    Me pointing out i’ve already explained what’s going on.

    I specifically said that i know all of those things and that me knowing them doesn’t change my reaction.

    Just in case, i explain again, in different words, in case that helps.

    The rage isn’t carefully analysing the correctness of the language, the rage sees a stupid usage and does it’s thing.

    Pointing out that emotion doesn’t necessarily lead to logical statements.

    The rage is obviously hyperbolous, but at this point i’m not expecting you to have noticed that, in your headcannon just replace rage with “moderate annoyance”


    And so we get to now:

    Why is it stupid? Just because something is different doesn’t make it stupid

    In the context of this post :

    logically? you’re probably correct.

    emotionally? sure it can, because emotions aren’t necessarily logical

    outside of the context of this post, something that is different can absolutely be logically stupid, it’s heavily context dependent.


    I’m not going to explain it further, if you are still struggling with it i’m clearly not best placed to help you understand.

  • 0 points on What linguistic hills are you willing to die on? in !asklemmy@lemmy.world ·

    no goalposts were moved, i answered the question as asked and explained my reasoning (or in this case lack thereof)

    I specifically said that i know all of those things and that me knowing them doesn’t change my reaction.

    The rage isn’t carefully analysing the correctness of the language, the rage sees a stupid usage and does it’s thing.

  • 0 points on What linguistic hills are you willing to die on? in !asklemmy@lemmy.world ·

    ish.

    not american, if that answers the question.

  • 0 points on What linguistic hills are you willing to die on? in !asklemmy@lemmy.world ·

    The question wasn’t “What truly important linguistic hills are you willing to die on?”

    I’m aware language is fluid, most of the rules are arbitrary, made up and will shift over time.

    Don’t care, “on accident” is rage inducing and can die in a fire.

  • 6 points on What linguistic hills are you willing to die on? in !asklemmy@lemmy.world ·

    “on accident” can get all the way fucked.

    same with “addicting”, though technically correct I’d die on the that hill anyway because i hate it.

  • 0 points on Reports of AI-related child sexual abuse material rise 8,400% in two years, data shows in !technology@lemmy.world ·

    That’s very interesting, i knew calculations like this existed but I’ve not seen one that easy to read before,

  • 0 points on Reports of AI-related child sexual abuse material rise 8,400% in two years, data shows in !technology@lemmy.world ·

    sorry I took a self reporting survey that claims to only be a self reporting survey as valid to an argument that I knew pedantic internet waffles would bad faith argue about so why not get ahead of it and include a source.

    Positioning yourself as a victim of big bad internet bullies who are picking on your extremely sound argument for no reason at all is certainly one way you could go.

    Claiming bad faith will probably require a well reasoned argument if you want to be taken seriously, so best to prepare for that also.

    In the future everytime I include a published source of any information I’ll include

    CAUTION: take all of reality with the possibility everything is made up and everyone is always lying into consideration! Careful! it might all be a lie! have you ever personally been to Cleveland? maybe it’s not real…

    The difference between:

    “highly plausible”

    and

    “this single, survey-based study suggests”.

    Ultimately it’s your call how you present your information.

    If you choose to present information in a way that that has previously garnered skepticism or comment, then expect potentially the same outcomes if you do it again.

    You can also continue to be upset when you get that kind of reaction, perhaps upset at the state of internet commenters is warranted, you do you.

    If you continue to be surprised however, that’s on you.

    Also everybody knows cleveland isn’t a real place, if you’re going to try and catch me with your made up geographic locations, at least pick something plausible, like Llanfair­pwllgwyngyll­gogery­chwyrn­drobwll­llan­tysilio­gogo­goch or Hooker

  • 1 points on Reports of AI-related child sexual abuse material rise 8,400% in two years, data shows in !technology@lemmy.world ·

    what point?

    The reply is still there, if you want me to copy and paste each point from that reply, i can, but it seems redundant.

    they said they thought science as a whole is corrupt and unreliable. they wrote a whole paragraph about it. what do you want me to dispute? that they think science as a whole is corrupt and surveys are made up? what’s the rebuttal possible? ‘well sir, surveys are possibly valid and not entirely made up.’ what do you want? there’s no substance to any of their claims beyond ‘I think it’s all made up and science is corrupt and therefore meaningless’.

    I think i see the issue i’m having, i thought you were legitimately deflecting out of an unwillingness to engage with the conversation.

    That’s my bad.

    I had a different take on their reply so i was seeing your reply through my interpretation of the post you were replying to.

    They are very negative about the current state of science as a discipline, the poor practices, corruption and rot that exists.

    I’m not seeing the general hatred of science though, just their perception the a lot of the current implementation of science is shitty.

    The main point i see them making is that you shouldn’t take a single (potentially suspect) result that is potentially influenced by all these shitty practices and claim “high plausibility” off of the back of that.

    They go into a little detail about their idea of good practices, but that can be inferred from their description of the bad practices.

    ‘OK, I don’t care if you feel that way, you’re allowed, good day’ and your coming at me like an obvious sock puppet that’s only interested in arguing nonsense instead of having ANY point about the subject at hand. good job.

    Regardless of my misunderstanding, my initial reply is still valid.

    Calling someone a sock puppet with no supporting evidence is weak.

    I was arguing that your interpretation of how science (and yes, surveys) are applicable here, was shaky and you might want to reconsider.

    If you don’t think that’s relevant, you’re entitled to your opinion.

    I totally agree with you and your correct on all points.

    just FYI, you can just say “i don’t want to talk to you anymore”,

    there’s also the block list if you really dislike me,

    i think there’s a lemmy(general?) etiquette option as well, something like /disengage , not sure how widespread that is though.

  • 6 points on Reports of AI-related child sexual abuse material rise 8,400% in two years, data shows in !technology@lemmy.world ·

    where did I make that claim?

    wow it sounds like you hate surveys and science. sorry about that.

    implying the points raised don’t have merit and are just the ramblings of a science (and survey) hater.

    I’m not trying to get you to agree surveys and science as a whole are valid.

    again, implying that somehow the points raised are only due to disagreeing with science (and again surveys for some reason)

    especially when the rest of your reply is just restating your original claim and not responding to any of the raised points.


    “this person must hate science and surveys” is the contextual equivalent of someone saying “hey perhaps we should not allow children to work 12 hour days in factories” and you replying with “this person must hate freedom”.

    It’s completely ignoring the point and claiming victory anyway.

  • 7 points on Reports of AI-related child sexual abuse material rise 8,400% in two years, data shows in !technology@lemmy.world ·

    Questioning the validity of methodologies and results is a core part of the scientific method.

    “It has surveys, so it must be legit” is not.

  • 1 points on Reports of AI-related child sexual abuse material rise 8,400% in two years, data shows in !technology@lemmy.world ·

    True. But over 1500 responses is a massive sample size for a survey like this.

    Genuine question, based on what?

    Like, I’m just seeing a number, I’ve no idea if it’s big or small in the context of this area of study.

    I’d be interested to know why that’s considered a good result.

    I haven’t read the actual study yet, but I would assume they filtered out things like one person submitting a thousand responses.

    Agreed, I’d assume a basic level of scientific rigour.

  • 4 points on Reports of AI-related child sexual abuse material rise 8,400% in two years, data shows in !technology@lemmy.world ·

    Aside from the other good replies you have around the subject, i’ll address something more fundamental to your argument.

    you can’t just dismiss an argument because the study is small.

    You absolutely can dismiss a study for being too small. In some cases you really should.

    If you can’t procure and retain a meaningful sample size, then you shouldn’t be running the experiment (or more usefully, designing an experiment that works with smaller sample sizes, or one that uses a demographic where you can get adequate sample sizes).

    It’s one of the reasons why participant gathering is usually done up front.

  • 0 points on What are some popular movies/tv shows that you did not care for? in !asklemmy@lemmy.world ·

    Goodfellas i could do, has been a while though, might have to go for a rewatch.

    The departed was stellar, if you can deal with subtitles(or terrible dubbing, if that’s your thing), i would recommend the original movie on which it’s based, Infernal Affairs.

  • 2 points on What are some popular movies/tv shows that you did not care for? in !asklemmy@lemmy.world ·

    It sounds like an interesting story

    The actual story was never the issue, what i saw of the acting, directing and production values was good as well

  • -1 points on What are some popular movies/tv shows that you did not care for? in !asklemmy@lemmy.world ·

    It’s not really about a conflict of ideology, as i said, i do understand it’s a thing, i even understand why it’s a thing (to an extent).

    It’s also not about it being fictional, i have the same issue with it in real life, it just doesn’t tend to be so concentrated in my day to day life.

    Closest example i can think of is that it’s like watching media that heavily features something in which you are an expert, but does so in such a way as to be noticeably bullshit.

    It’s jarring enough to take you out of the flow of the movie/show.

    If you’ve any experience with programming, it’s things like this

    Or like being a huge sports fan, but the media you are watching clearly doesn’t understand the rules of the sport it’s depicting.

    Suspension of disbelief wasn’t quite the correct phrase (that’s on me), it’s more like a cognitive stutter.

    Somebody doing something because of inherited loyalty or “for the family” without any supporting reasoning feels like watching someone firing 50 rounds with a 6 chamber revolver ( apologies if that’s the wrong terminology, I’m not a gun person ).

    is it critical to the story that this details is right ? not necessarily, but if it happens constantly throughout the story it can ruin the enjoyment (for some people at least).

    I want to be clear that I’m not claiming to be an expert in loyalty or anything, it’s just far enough away from my expectations that it’s jarring, it’s almost certainly some weird hypersensitivity of mine.

  • 8 points on What are some popular movies/tv shows that you did not care for? in !asklemmy@lemmy.world ·

    The godfather.

    Tried multiple times, couldn’t get in to it.

    I don’t like mafia stories in general so that probably goes a long way to explaining it.

    Fervent organisational/inherited loyalty doesn’t make sense to me ,so anything based upon that ruins my immersion.

    To be clear, I understand that it’s a thing and why it happens, it’s just so ridiculous as a concept I can’t usually suspend my disbelief enough to enjoy the media.

    Goodfellas, I could get through, godfather was a bridge too far.

  • 2 points on What are some popular movies/tv shows that you did not care for? in !asklemmy@lemmy.world ·

    Did you watch all the way to the end ?