The problem with defending the purity of the English language is that English is about as pure as a cribhouse whore. We don’t just borrow words; on occasion, English has pursued other languages down alleyways to beat them unconscious and rifle their pockets for new vocabulary.
The problem is that even Esperanto has dialects and diverges. The longer a language is around, the more innovation that’s going to happen bringing diversification.
There was a whole intellectual project in the early 20th century to create a ‘perfect’ language that is logically complete. Bertrand Russell being one of the biggest proponents.
It doesn’t exist because it can’t exist. There is no such thing and it project was abandoned thanks to Wittgenstein who destroyed the project and Russell’s work. His early work supported Russell’s project, but he ‘betrayed’ him in his later work, and Wittgenstein’s later work became the predominate model for philosophy of language in mid 20th century.
The world moved on, but a lot of silly people think such a language must exist because they can imagine it existing… as an ideal in their head, it’s basically the linguistic version of the theory of forms.
Lol so you want people to reject millennia of passed down oral tradition and instead learn something that was opinionatedly made up (and never adopted for a reason)?
This is a hilarious misunderstanding of how humans behave. We will sooner have world peace than do anything remotely like that. Probably couldn’t even happen if somehow a dictator ruled the entire world and mandated it under penalty of death.
I currently do. And all the linguistic variety spread throughout that country kinda proves my point. You can enslave people and force them into a language, and even then they’ll still change it drastically and import words they used to use in their native tongues.
Comments
All historically formed languages are complete shit. We need something logical and predictable like Esperanto.
Esperanto works, if you compare it to Indo-European languages. To a Finno-Ugric speaker like me, it is not that logical nor predictable.
Nobody wants that.
I said “need”, not “want”.
Nobody needs or wants that.
Sorry, but I’m with username1 on this
The problem is that even Esperanto has dialects and diverges. The longer a language is around, the more innovation that’s going to happen bringing diversification.
There was a whole intellectual project in the early 20th century to create a ‘perfect’ language that is logically complete. Bertrand Russell being one of the biggest proponents.
It doesn’t exist because it can’t exist. There is no such thing and it project was abandoned thanks to Wittgenstein who destroyed the project and Russell’s work. His early work supported Russell’s project, but he ‘betrayed’ him in his later work, and Wittgenstein’s later work became the predominate model for philosophy of language in mid 20th century.
The world moved on, but a lot of silly people think such a language must exist because they can imagine it existing… as an ideal in their head, it’s basically the linguistic version of the theory of forms.
That’s quite the hill to die on. Why not Esperanto’s daughter Ido or one of the other Esperantidoj? (-j as a plural marker was a bad move tbh).
Lol so you want people to reject millennia of passed down oral tradition and instead learn something that was opinionatedly made up (and never adopted for a reason)?
This is a hilarious misunderstanding of how humans behave. We will sooner have world peace than do anything remotely like that. Probably couldn’t even happen if somehow a dictator ruled the entire world and mandated it under penalty of death.
You never lived in any empire-tier country? People love language unification. That’s convenient.
I currently do. And all the linguistic variety spread throughout that country kinda proves my point. You can enslave people and force them into a language, and even then they’ll still change it drastically and import words they used to use in their native tongues.
Sign in to comment. Sign in