This is a Commonwealth English versus North American English thing. You may wish to take this into which one of those is “correct”, if any, but I’d say that’s pushing at the boundaries of the scope of this thread.
Doesn’t Shropshire Don’t the West Country accents in the UK and that area also drop the H there? I’m thinking of Phil Harding from Time Team specifically, heh.
But Phil is from Wiltshire, not Shropshire, and has a (strong) West Country accent which features h-dropping.
This isn’t an element of standard British English, though - people speaking carefully or in formal settings don’t generally do this, but it is common in many British accents in colloquial speech. This is different than the herb thing: in standard British English it is pronounced with an h, and someone from the West Country who normally dropped their h’s would pronounce it in herb if they were speaking carefully, whereas an American would not. Similarly, nobody in Britain pronounces an h at the start of “hour” (unless they’re being silly on purpose!)
Funny thing about this. My grandfather’s name is Herb, and when I was a kid I was in speech therapy to work on the ‘r’ sound and the word herb came up. I pronounced it with the ‘H’ and when my therapist corrected me I looked at her super serious and said “Oh no, I know how it’s pronounced, that’s my grandpa’s name”. Then I learned how the plant word was spelled.
Comments
Herb is pronounced with the H
But if I’m wrong then I guess I’ll go to “ell” cuz H is silent
Honestly, I tell my Heirs this every Hour.
In truth, I have informed my legal successors of my estate this, for each reoccuring one - twentyfourth of a calandar day.
I’ll join you in ell. We can share an otel room there.
It would be my honor.
This is a Commonwealth English versus North American English thing. You may wish to take this into which one of those is “correct”, if any, but I’d say that’s pushing at the boundaries of the scope of this thread.
Doesn’t ShropshireDon’t the West Country accents in the UK and that area also drop the H there? I’m thinking of Phil Harding from Time Team specifically, heh.Fellow Time Team enjoyer!
But Phil is from Wiltshire, not Shropshire, and has a (strong) West Country accent which features h-dropping.
This isn’t an element of standard British English, though - people speaking carefully or in formal settings don’t generally do this, but it is common in many British accents in colloquial speech. This is different than the herb thing: in standard British English it is pronounced with an h, and someone from the West Country who normally dropped their h’s would pronounce it in herb if they were speaking carefully, whereas an American would not. Similarly, nobody in Britain pronounces an h at the start of “hour” (unless they’re being silly on purpose!)
Yeah, coffee hadn’t kicked in yet. I realized it was West Country and came to post back here. Thanks for the additional info!
Funny thing about this. My grandfather’s name is Herb, and when I was a kid I was in speech therapy to work on the ‘r’ sound and the word herb came up. I pronounced it with the ‘H’ and when my therapist corrected me I looked at her super serious and said “Oh no, I know how it’s pronounced, that’s my grandpa’s name”. Then I learned how the plant word was spelled.
https://youtu.be/wDR5j30spfI
Sign in to comment. Sign in