Skip to content

Comment on What linguistic hills are you willing to die on?

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments

Comments

  • My hill is: you can’t make sweeping pronouncements about what is “correct” or “incorrect” about a given English sentence, because something that is an error in your dialect of English is just as likely to be correct usage in another dialect. You can say things like “that sounds strange to my ear” or “I would never produce that sentence,” but there are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio, than are dreamt of in your dialect.

    2
    • This is descriptivism taken to an unrealistic extreme. People are not obliged to be neutral linguistic researchers in everyday life!

      2
    • You can if you’re a teacher and you’re grading papers.

      Formal English exists and in certain contexts certain usages are entirely correct, or incorrect.

      But if you go to a bar and start lecturing people on how they talk being grammatically wrong, you’re just a dick.

      And in another languages, the some grammar features and usages are only for the written word and never used in speech, they have formal distinct grammars for written vs spoken. English doesn’t have this.

      2
    • you can’t make sweeping pronouncements about what is “correct” or “incorrect” about a given English sentence.

      Snot troo u kant juss maek shittupppppp… n xpek evre1 tu no whut it meenz, if u kaint reeddis snott my prollem

      -1

Sign in to comment. Sign in