The Oxford comma provides clarity and should always be used, even when the extra clarity isn’t needed. Like a turn signal–you still use it when no one else is around. Just make it a habit.
I used to believe similarly, but I’ve since changed my mind and believe such lists should actually just be rewritten. Its Wikipedia page has a great section about ambiguity explaining exactly how it can actually introduce ambiguity, or fail to remove it when it already exists.
These are specific cases, and they’re right but I’d say otherwise it should only be omitted if timing is important–like with dialogue. Like just now, for example, there should be one after “right”, but it changes the timing when it’s dialogue. Otherwise, there’s no ambiguity.
I was initially going to ask you to space out your em-dash so as to keep with the grammatical pedantry — as that looks terribly incorrect to me — but, upon glossing over the Wikipedia article on dashes, this appears to be a matter of debate. Some style guides — such as those of Chicago and Oxford — say that em-dashes should always be set closed, as in your comment. Others — such as the New York Times and AP — have it set open when used parenthetically, as in mine. TIL.
(I don’t usually use that many em-dashes in sequence; I’m just overusing them due to relevance. I agree with the Oxford comma sentiment.)
As long as that fits your current employer’s style guidelines, go ham, but em and en dashes do have different uses and to intentionally conflate them is kinda insane.
Their username implies that they’re from the UK, which would match with a number of publishers using spaced en-dashes and not em-dashes. Wikipedia lists Cambridge University Press, Penguin Group, and Routledge as examples of publishers for whom this is the house style, with the Oxford style guide noted as an exception.
How to fail your English exam. There’s no comma after “and” unless absolutely necessary (ergo it’s an Oxford comma). It’s also like this in a lot of other languages. That’s just how it is, I don’t make the rules.
No fucking shit. The Oxford comma goes before the “and”.
And you have it backwards, you should always add the Oxford comma for lists, because it’s less confusing. See the examples about strippers, Hitler, and Stalin
Your last comma should be a semicolon (or a period with the following word capitalized). A comma cannot join two independent clauses (or at least typically isn’t supposed to, anyway).
Comments
The Oxford comma provides clarity and should always be used, even when the extra clarity isn’t needed. Like a turn signal–you still use it when no one else is around. Just make it a habit.
Oxford Comma Club represent!
Club member chiming in!
Give me my Oxford comma or give me death!
Fuck yes
I used to believe similarly, but I’ve since changed my mind and believe such lists should actually just be rewritten. Its Wikipedia page has a great section about ambiguity explaining exactly how it can actually introduce ambiguity, or fail to remove it when it already exists.
These are specific cases, and they’re right but I’d say otherwise it should only be omitted if timing is important–like with dialogue. Like just now, for example, there should be one after “right”, but it changes the timing when it’s dialogue. Otherwise, there’s no ambiguity.
That was a good read, thank you
Fascinating. It seems that the greatest potential for confusion emerges from any possible 3-item list. Thanks for sharing.
Lists are good though!
I didn’t say otherwise! A list can be written in a way that doesn’t have ambiguity, serial comma or not.
I honestly didn’t know that some places/people don’t use the comma there. I thought that was just how you are supposed to write things.
You’re my kind of person. 🫵🫶
I was initially going to ask you to space out your em-dash so as to keep with the grammatical pedantry — as that looks terribly incorrect to me — but, upon glossing over the Wikipedia article on dashes, this appears to be a matter of debate. Some style guides — such as those of Chicago and Oxford — say that em-dashes should always be set closed, as in your comment. Others — such as the New York Times and AP — have it set open when used parenthetically, as in mine. TIL.
(I don’t usually use that many em-dashes in sequence; I’m just overusing them due to relevance. I agree with the Oxford comma sentiment.)
I’m an editor. All em-dashes are immediately replaced with en-dashes and spaces around said dashes.
As long as that fits your current employer’s style guidelines, go ham, but em and en dashes do have different uses and to intentionally conflate them is kinda insane.
Their username implies that they’re from the UK, which would match with a number of publishers using spaced en-dashes and not em-dashes. Wikipedia lists Cambridge University Press, Penguin Group, and Routledge as examples of publishers for whom this is the house style, with the Oxford style guide noted as an exception.
I learned in college that they should not have spaces. I also prefer it that way.
I would assume most people prefer what they first learn unless talking about something objective.
Mom’s spaghetti sauce. Dad’s version of that bedtime story. Grandma’s version of that lullaby.
I agree entirely, except I call it the serial comma, because Oxford comma makes it sound like a regional dialect foible.
Preach it!
I wish my language supported the Oxford comma.
I use commas like I use black pepper, I fuckin love black pepper, and, I toss them shits, willy, fuckin, nilly.
I don’t love it, but it’s a lot better than no punctuation.
I don’t really use them like that. But, I do like thought breaks.
How to fail your English exam. There’s no comma after “and” unless absolutely necessary (ergo it’s an Oxford comma). It’s also like this in a lot of other languages. That’s just how it is, I don’t make the rules.
No fucking shit. The Oxford comma goes before the “and”.
And you have it backwards, you should always add the Oxford comma for lists, because it’s less confusing. See the examples about strippers, Hitler, and Stalin
Yeah. I know. But I adapt how I type to how others do, within reason. Because I’m autistic, but I’m not that autistic.
Your last comma should be a semicolon (or a period with the following word capitalized). A comma cannot join two independent clauses (or at least typically isn’t supposed to, anyway).
Sign in to comment. Sign in