Skip to content

Comment on What linguistic hills are you willing to die on?

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments

Comments

  • Language is used for communication. As long as your idea is being effectively conveyed to your listener, nothing else matters. It doesn’t matter if it’s “illogical” or “technically incorrect.”

    0
    • Maybe, but what do you mean by that statement?

      2
    • To some degree your point has merit, however… (and you knew there’d be a however), construction matters for clarity, and prevents misunderstanding.

      When someone uses a plural form of a pronoun when they’ve already indicated singular elsewhere, I’m going to question what they’re saying.

      1
    • Don’t come here with logic and linguistic knowledge

      0
    • Many times it is not. And the more times it’s used “incorrectly”, the more unclear the communication becomes.

      -1
    • sometimes being illogical and incorrect is the only way for the listener to understand it.

      -2
    • “Cars are used for transportation. As long as you’re effectively conveyed to your destination, nothing else matters. It doesn’t matter how much you inconvenience others. It doesn’t matter if your car is ‘street legal’ or if you follow ‘laws’.”

      -3
      • Terrible analogy.

        2
      • Driving poorly endangers others around you. Communicating clearly but with stilted, unconventional, or inconsistent grammar does not pose a threat to anyone.

        -1

Sign in to comment. Sign in