Skip to content

Comment on What linguistic hills are you willing to die on?

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments

Comments

  • @farmgineer@nord.pub· · edited

    plural of ‘roof’ is ‘rooves’.

    I agree here.

    Second, you can’t eat your cake and have it, too

    If you eat it, you no longer have it. It’s like ‘a gingerbread house is either lodging or food, but can’t be both; if you eat it, you can’t live in it’.

    Hippie Hippy

    I’ve never heard of ‘hippy’.


    I would add ‘staves’ as the plural of ‘staff’.

    My more controversial take is that we should end some of the irregularity. I don’t think there’s any solving orthography vs pronunciation, especially when everyone thinks it will be their pronunciation but in reality no one would agree.

    • all verbs become regular and simple. Simplify the language. People can be smited without having to worry about smote or smitten. Verbs that are used less are already undergoing this simplification anyway.
    • stop stupid plurals. All plurals are just -(e)s. No more weirdness. I would have felt differently could I have had a pile of boxen, but now we have to herd oxes.
    • similarly, ax all the negation prefixes except -un or even just simplify to -u (I’m digging this in Norwegian). Anaerobic? Nah, Uaerobic.

    More unhinged:

    • no more apostrophes for possession: one must use “x of y” construction
    • lists are now done in mathematical set notation and the oxford comma dilemma is solved, over, and done
    2
    • I agree completely.

      I’ve never heard of ‘hippy’.

      I apologise. You’re going to start noticing it now I’ve pointed it out.

      3
    • You make a good point about the issues with simplifying.

      I think most people don’t understand that spelling for many words was established long ago, while the pronunciation has drifted.

      Just look at the differences between American and British English.

      1

Sign in to comment. Sign in