Skip to content

Comment on What linguistic hills are you willing to die on?

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above

Comments

  • joddammit I knew it !

    20
    • Fucking hell. I need a tall glass of gin. Maybe some ginger candy. Maybe I’ll fight a giraffe.

      9
      • @davidgro@lemmy.world· · edited

        I gave a girl a gift of a gigabyte of giddy giggling gibbons. Gifs of course. Made in Gimp.

        5
        • I’ve found it’s more commonly a soft g if the end of the syllable is soft, like gin, gym, giraffe, and giant and hard if the end of the syllable is hard, like gift, gig, gimp. Since “if” is softer than it is hard it’s gif (soft g) for me.

          -1
          • I hadn’t noticed such a pattern, but maybe. Still, several of the words I used end in a way that seems softly to me - girl, giggle/giggling, giga (the prefix, since the ending can be anything), gibbon. And I’m not sure I agree that the t in giant is a soft sound.

            So it’s not a strong pattern at least.

            To me it seems like the closest English word to gif is gift, so it should sound similar. (Of course that’s not a strong pattern either, plenty of words are spelled identically but still sound different)

            Really I think it’s just up to personal preference. I happen to disagree with the creator of the format.

            1
      • @SystemDisc@feddit.org· · edited

        But the first word is graphics, not giraffics

        6
        • By the same logic you should say jay-pheg, since the “p” in jpeg is photographic.

          Or “scub-uh” instead of “scoo-bah” since the ‘u’ in scuba is “underwater”.

          Or “lah-zer” instead of “lay-zer” for laser because the ‘a’ is “amplification”.

          Point being: the acronym does not borrow the sound of the originating word elsewhere in English, so I don’t find the argument “hard g because graphics” compelling.

          4
          • Sure, but it’s reasonable to assume a G is pronounced as a hard G. It’s not reasonable to assume that a P without a following H is pronounced as an F.

            That being said, the creator of GIF prefers “jif” as the pronunciation. Even though he created it, I’m still sure he’s wrong… 😜

            5
            • @josephc@lemmy.ml· · edited

              Sure, but it’s reasonable to assume a G is pronounced as a hard G. It’s not reasonable to assume that a P without a following H is pronounced as an F.

              Fair. But I did give several other counterexamples that don’t rely on said assumption.

              EDIT: typo

              3
            • I’ve always thought of this as one of the greatest trolls of all time.

              1
            • I think the pronunciation of the g depends on context. In gif, the context points towards soft g because of all those examples.

              0
      • Go gargle gonads. Gif. :)

        0

Sign in to comment. Sign in