Skip to content

Comment on What linguistic hills are you willing to die on?

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above

Comments

  • By the same logic you should say jay-pheg, since the “p” in jpeg is photographic.

    Or “scub-uh” instead of “scoo-bah” since the ‘u’ in scuba is “underwater”.

    Or “lah-zer” instead of “lay-zer” for laser because the ‘a’ is “amplification”.

    Point being: the acronym does not borrow the sound of the originating word elsewhere in English, so I don’t find the argument “hard g because graphics” compelling.

    4
    • Sure, but it’s reasonable to assume a G is pronounced as a hard G. It’s not reasonable to assume that a P without a following H is pronounced as an F.

      That being said, the creator of GIF prefers “jif” as the pronunciation. Even though he created it, I’m still sure he’s wrong… 😜

      5
      • @josephc@lemmy.ml· · edited

        Sure, but it’s reasonable to assume a G is pronounced as a hard G. It’s not reasonable to assume that a P without a following H is pronounced as an F.

        Fair. But I did give several other counterexamples that don’t rely on said assumption.

        EDIT: typo

        3
      • I’ve always thought of this as one of the greatest trolls of all time.

        1
      • I think the pronunciation of the g depends on context. In gif, the context points towards soft g because of all those examples.

        0

Sign in to comment. Sign in