That’s kind of my point. The second example isn’t a problem if it is just the parents’ names.
I’m definitely highly in favor of Oxford cons usage, but even if you pretend that not using it is definitely incorrect, it just makes it unclear. But given that there is a correct way to use it that way, if you see that sentence you would assume it’s just 2 people. Using it specifies that there are 4 people (or more, depending on how “parents” is potentially being used).
So the examples do point out a good reason to use it, and a good example of why you don’t want to not use it. But the way it’s wired sound like they’re saying the second version is wrong, when it could very well be totally correct.
To really nail down the point the list should’ve only included examples that would qualify for its usage, and show that when it applies, it should always be used.
Just a minor nitpick in the praying of the argument.
But I still can’t believe that it even could be correct not to include it. That’s what’s really wrong, not people’s choice to omit it. Oxford comma should be the rule. Unless someone can make a good argument otherwise, I will die on that hill.
Comments
Use the damn Oxford comma. Imakes the lists very clear.
This is a list with the Oxford comma. Let me introduce my parents, Jack, and Jill.
This is the dumb way, without one. Let me introduce my parents, Jack and Jill. Is this a list or are Jack and Jill the name of his parents?
Use the damn extra comma.
Doesn’t it require the list to have at least 3 items? For 2 the comma definitely doesn’t work. For 3, though, it definitely should be added.
First example still took four reads to realize there are four introductions.
That’s kind of my point. The second example isn’t a problem if it is just the parents’ names.
I’m definitely highly in favor of Oxford cons usage, but even if you pretend that not using it is definitely incorrect, it just makes it unclear. But given that there is a correct way to use it that way, if you see that sentence you would assume it’s just 2 people. Using it specifies that there are 4 people (or more, depending on how “parents” is potentially being used).
So the examples do point out a good reason to use it, and a good example of why you don’t want to not use it. But the way it’s wired sound like they’re saying the second version is wrong, when it could very well be totally correct.
To really nail down the point the list should’ve only included examples that would qualify for its usage, and show that when it applies, it should always be used.
Just a minor nitpick in the praying of the argument.
But I still can’t believe that it even could be correct not to include it. That’s what’s really wrong, not people’s choice to omit it. Oxford comma should be the rule. Unless someone can make a good argument otherwise, I will die on that hill.
I can’t tell if you actually dislike the Oxford comma and are parodying people who use it with an intentionally shitty example.
Instructions unclear. I’ve now concluded you are your own father.
Fuck your comma
[deleted]
Why are Americans so wedded to the Oxford comma?
Sign in to comment. Sign in