English is a spoken language. Writing is just a notation system for the language, not the language itself. We learned to speak before we learned to write. Many approaches to English, and language generally are a text first approach, which is fundimentially backwards.
In other news,
If you eat the cake, you no longer have the cake. That’s the point of the saying. The two actions cannot coexist. If you want to have the cake you must not eat it, and if you eat the cake you no longer have it. The two events are not chronological in the order they are said. Both have and eat share the same tense.
Furthermore,
Double negatives for emphasis is a valid construction in certain dialects of English. If you correct someone or deliberately misinterpret them on this, it doesn’t make you right it makes you an asshole, and I don’t want nothing to do with you.
If you have eaten the cake, you no longer have the cake. While you’re eating it you also have it, same as you have a life while living it. No one can take a bite of cake and truthfully say they don’t have cake now.
Comments
English is a spoken language. Writing is just a notation system for the language, not the language itself. We learned to speak before we learned to write. Many approaches to English, and language generally are a text first approach, which is fundimentially backwards.
In other news,
If you eat the cake, you no longer have the cake. That’s the point of the saying. The two actions cannot coexist. If you want to have the cake you must not eat it, and if you eat the cake you no longer have it. The two events are not chronological in the order they are said. Both have and eat share the same tense.
Furthermore,
Double negatives for emphasis is a valid construction in certain dialects of English. If you correct someone or deliberately misinterpret them on this, it doesn’t make you right it makes you an asshole, and I don’t want nothing to do with you.
If you have eaten the cake, you no longer have the cake. While you’re eating it you also have it, same as you have a life while living it. No one can take a bite of cake and truthfully say they don’t have cake now.
The point is you no longer have the cake once it’s been eaten. It’s not a difficult concept or a trick.
If that’s the meaning, the saying should be, “You can’t have your cake after you’ve eaten it.”
To be pedantic, why don’t you have it anymore? You’ve eaten it. It’s a part of you. Arguably until death at this point.
I do get your point, though.
Sign in to comment. Sign in