Skip to content

Comment on What linguistic hills are you willing to die on?

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above

Comments

  • No, while you’re eating cake you must also have it, because you can’t eat what you don’t have. You can’t have it after you’ve eaten all of it. The saying doesn’t mention a minimum quantity. The last bite of cake is still cake.

    0
    • You didn’t eat the last bite of cake. And you no longer have the cake that you ate.

      Ipso facto, can’t have it and eat it too. Unless you’re experiencing some sort of weird time dilation that lets you exist in different moments simultaneously.

      0
      • I agree the point isn’t difficult, but to have the meaning you want it to have, the saying should be, “You can’t have the part of your cake you ate.” I’m eating popcorn right now, but looking the bag I can see I have popcorn. I just took a drink of water and I still have water. I spend money and I also have money. The one sure thing is that I’m done with this topic.

        0
      • Why don’t you have it anymore? After you eat it, it is a part of you. Arguably until death. 😄

        0

Sign in to comment. Sign in