Skip to content

Comment on What linguistic hills are you willing to die on?

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments

Comments

  • Not sure this counts…

    but 's should only mean a letter is missing…

    Like, if you say “It’s” then you’re saying “It is” - but missing the “i” in “is” - so the ’ takes the place of the i …

    Saying “That’s Davids cup” should be fine. Why is there a possessive S? Why is it “That’s David’s cup”?

    The ’ is not taking the place of a missing letter and therefore shouldn’t be there.

    I mean, if the possessive is right - like “See Christopher’s car?” - then why is it wrong to say “The dryer lost it’s power”? The car is used by Christopher. The power is used by the dryer. Neither have the ’ replacing a missing letter, so neither should have it…

    4
    • Ok, so that’s Chriss car, over there. Names are spelled all kinds of ways, it helps keep it consistent.

      There’s also, to keep in mind, “the neighbours house” vs “the neighbours’ house” and “the neighbour’s house”.

      1
      • Yeah, Chris’ house works because you’re removing the second S (Chriss house)

        The neighbours one - first one is fine, second again drops the S, so needs the ’

        Third one, though - the ’ isn’t dropping a letter so I don’t like it.

        0
        • For names, how are we supposed to always know for sure how many Ss there are, or if there are any at all?

          To be fair, I do sorta get your point, and am contradictally somewhat ok with “hers” and “theirs”, but I dunno, it feels sloppy. The apostrophe is additional, at-a-glance clarity for no real cost, with an almost perfectly consistent rule outside of the aforementioned “hers” and related words.

          0
          • But it’s not really consistent…

            To my understanding, “David’s car” has an apostrophe because it used to be written, in ye olde times, “Davides car”…

            So the ’ denoted the missing “e”… But now it’s sort of redundant.

            While I’m at it, whyn’t use the apostrophe to remove letters more often?

            Why is “Won’t” sensible, but “Willn’t” isn’t?

            It’s just “Will not” missing the O, in the same way “Isn’t” is just “Is not” missing the O…

            0
    • To summarize you believe an apostrophe should only denote a contraction and never a possessive. I don’t hate this as a rule.

      0

Sign in to comment. Sign in