To “eat your cake and have it too” is contradictory because that is the point. That phrase is meant to highlight a contradictory attitude or behaviour in another person, by creating a contradictory premise or image.
Which is why - whe spoken to the unreasonable party - it is usually preceded by “you can’t”, to indicate that the party is demanding that a fundamental rule of reality be bent or broken for them to have satisfaction.
As for usages that personally rankle me, it’s gotta be the Oxford Comma. It’s absolutely essential to ensuring that Hitler and Stalin aren’t the strippers.
And the phrase “it is what it is” is meant to be a stoic response to things that you yourself cannot control, and so you do the smart thing and don’t even try (at most you try to work around it). But the problem I see in modern civ is that most speakers are using it to leverage “learned helplessness” and to justify laziness. As in, the thing is something the speaker can control, they just don’t want to get off their fat ass to do anything about it.
In a similar vein, the oft used “pull yourself up by your bootstraps” has deviated from the intended meaning which is to facetiously suggest to do the impossible. Lately, I see it used as indicating the subject needs to develop some grit or already has it.
“It is what it is” is also a thought-terminating phrase, which is a concept more people need to know about. Just like knowing about common logical fallacies, it’s important for everyone to be able to identify bullshit when you hear it. I’ve seen people to use phrases like this to completely shut down productive and constructive conversation; it gets weaponized, and education is the only defense.
You had me up until the end. Sometimes it’s not that the person is lazy, but simply thst they’re suffering from an undiagnosed mental health condition. I used to have the same problem for the first 40 years of my life until I found the right medication. I was never lazy, my brain simply wouldn’t make enough of the chemicals I need that motivate most human beings, mainly dopamine. (No joke, I’m constantly screaming at myself to get up and do something, anything, but I just sit there and do nothing instead until the meds kick in.)
The most frustrating part is that in order to feel motivated enough to seek treatment, you need to be on meds. It’s a complete paradox. Only reason why I eventually went is because it was seek treatment or go homeless. So I chose treatment. Unfortunately a lot of people choose homelessness instead, and oftentimes it’s not their fault. They need medication they can’t get because their poor mental health won’t allow them to.
Comments
To “eat your cake and have it too” is contradictory because that is the point. That phrase is meant to highlight a contradictory attitude or behaviour in another person, by creating a contradictory premise or image.
Which is why - whe spoken to the unreasonable party - it is usually preceded by “you can’t”, to indicate that the party is demanding that a fundamental rule of reality be bent or broken for them to have satisfaction.
As for usages that personally rankle me, it’s gotta be the Oxford Comma. It’s absolutely essential to ensuring that Hitler and Stalin aren’t the strippers.
And the phrase “it is what it is” is meant to be a stoic response to things that you yourself cannot control, and so you do the smart thing and don’t even try (at most you try to work around it). But the problem I see in modern civ is that most speakers are using it to leverage “learned helplessness” and to justify laziness. As in, the thing is something the speaker can control, they just don’t want to get off their fat ass to do anything about it.
Agreed on all counts.
In a similar vein, the oft used “pull yourself up by your bootstraps” has deviated from the intended meaning which is to facetiously suggest to do the impossible. Lately, I see it used as indicating the subject needs to develop some grit or already has it.
“It is what it is” is also a thought-terminating phrase, which is a concept more people need to know about. Just like knowing about common logical fallacies, it’s important for everyone to be able to identify bullshit when you hear it. I’ve seen people to use phrases like this to completely shut down productive and constructive conversation; it gets weaponized, and education is the only defense.
You had me up until the end. Sometimes it’s not that the person is lazy, but simply thst they’re suffering from an undiagnosed mental health condition. I used to have the same problem for the first 40 years of my life until I found the right medication. I was never lazy, my brain simply wouldn’t make enough of the chemicals I need that motivate most human beings, mainly dopamine. (No joke, I’m constantly screaming at myself to get up and do something, anything, but I just sit there and do nothing instead until the meds kick in.)
The most frustrating part is that in order to feel motivated enough to seek treatment, you need to be on meds. It’s a complete paradox. Only reason why I eventually went is because it was seek treatment or go homeless. So I chose treatment. Unfortunately a lot of people choose homelessness instead, and oftentimes it’s not their fault. They need medication they can’t get because their poor mental health won’t allow them to.
Sign in to comment. Sign in