Skip to content

Comment on Defending Gabe Newell, Doom and Quake veteran Sandy Petersen says "with Steam he is literally guarding the gates of Hell" and protecting us from "parasites" like Disney, EA, and Microsoft

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments

Comments

  • And it’s still a monopoly.

    You can say all those things, and then acknowledge, we are reliant on him alone because Steam has a monopoly market share. Ideally an entire industry should not hinge on one guy. That’s why monopolies are usually so awful that people think the word means we have to break it up. It doesn’t - we don’t - it’s still a monopoly.

    -2
    • @codydodd@lemmy.ca· · edited

      Indie game dev here (cofounded a workers cooperative to launch hermertia wars, early but exciting project, imagine Smash Bros meets AOE/warcraft3):

      Its not really too much of a monopoly if you set yourself up right.

      1. we are (due to our day jobs) able to set up APIs for our own store, our free to play game will have seasons and content on steam but same can be bought for a discount on our store, steam makes this seamless and doesnt discourage it.

      2. we set up our lobby/multiplayer logic to be swappable with others like epic, or direct ip as a backup.

      3. honestly in the brick and mortar days middlemen took 70% or more of our revenue. 30% but giving us a global audience is hella worth it.

      6
      • Neat. None of that changes how they have an overwhelming market share. We have a word for that.

        -3
        • We have a word for that.

          Footgun? There’s no other reason the other game publishers are screwing up this badly.

          4
          • None of it changes THAT they have an overwhelming market share.

            People find the weirdest fucking angles to stare straight at a superdupermajority and say “It doesn’t look like anything to me.” They are a textbook example, where the textbook says ‘it’s probably fine,’ and folks cannot get past step one.

            -3
            • We seem to be going at different angles, I agree. I’m aware they have a supermajority, I’m pointing out the only reason they have it is their competitors are all fucking idiots. It’s not like Steam is gatekeeping competitors from entering the market, unlike a lot of companies I could point at.

              3
              Continue this thread 4 more replies
            • Oh hey, Markdown preview lies, what fun. Can’t do a link like https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/monopoly#%3A%7E%3Atext=monopolies+created+purely,) without jumping through your ass, and then editing and saving changes how it works, because somebody mismatched where escapes happen.

              -4
    • And it’s still a monopoly.

      It’s not.

      0
      • Argumentum ad nuh uh.

        Hey, remember that Horses game? With the naked people on a farm. Why do you think the creator was worried about getting kicked off Steam? After all, it’s just one store.

        -1
        • @thingsiplay@lemmy.ml· · edited

          Lot of reasons why Valve is not a monopoly, but Valve dominates the PC gaming market.

          1. You can buy Steam keys on other shops. That means there can be other stores selling Steam keys, like your own webpage. And you have to pay Steam nothing, while they still host the infrastructure for you.
          2. If Steam was a monopoly, then no game could be sold on other stores. But we have GOG, Epic Games, itchio and even some custom stores for specific games.
          3. Some of the biggest videogames in history are not on Steam. If that Steam was a monopoly, then those games couldn’t sell well: Minecraft, League of Legends, Roblox, Fortnite or Valorant in example.
          4. With your next game purchase, you can without any issue buy the game on a different store than Steam. You don’t have to buy it on Steam. If the publisher decides not to sell it elsewhere, that is a decision by the publisher, not because they couldn’t it.
          5. Unlike on consoles or unlike Epic on PC, Valve does not do contracts to have exclusive rights to sell games on their platform.
          6. The platform itself is open. You don’t have to install Steam. You don’t have to install the operating system by Valve. You don’t have to use any of their hardware. There is no lockdown.

          Also: a) Valve did not do unfair tactics to gain the market share they have today, its all organically grown, b) even with this market dominance (which does not mean its a monopoly) Valve is not abusing its position, c) Valve does a lot of Open Source and allows even its competitors to use their services.

          3
          • 1, the fact they can do that without concern is a hint. 2, that’s not part of the definition at all. 3, you have to be as big as fucking Fortnite not to lose 90% of your customers. 4, that’s just 2 again? 5, that’s technically also 2 again; exclusivity is not what defines a monopoly. 6 is 5 is 2.

            Steam has super-duper-majority market share.

            That’s the only factor.

            That’s what the word means.

            Valve is not abusing its position, but it still has that position. You need a monopoly market share to even consider anti-competitive practices.

            Monopoly doesn’t mean there’s no competition, it means the competition does not matter. Not even Epic can get a foot in the door. They have one game that makes four billion dollars a year. They license the engine behind half of major games. You can rattle off their incompetent failures and say that’s why, but even if they’d done everything right, they’d be scrabbling for relevance, because mass adoption is durable. Same reason Twitter still exists. The bulk of customers will not check other stores unless they are forced to. To them, for whatever reason, Steam is PC gaming.

            If your game’s budget has a comma in it then you better be on Steam or you are hosed.

            -5
            • 2, that’s not part of the definition at all.

              It is. All the alternative stores are viable options. That is the opposite of monopoly.

              3, you have to be as big as fucking Fortnite not to lose 90% of your customers.

              I don’t know if its true that the game needs to be this big to not lose 90% of the customers. But that is not the definition we are trying to find. You just gave me right that there are games out there that can happily exist without Steam, because Steam is not a monopoly.

              A real monopoly looks like one where there is no alternative like Apple Store, or one where games like Fortnite can’t exist if its not on the Google Playstore. That is how a real monopoly looks like.

              4, that’s just 2 again?

              Point 4 was more about that you can decide to buy elsewhere. Not that the option just exist, but its you, to decide.

              5, that’s technically also 2 again; exclusivity is not what defines a monopoly.

              No we talk about exclusivity. No 2 again. Exclusivity of games is a different topic than having alternative stores at your disposal.

              6 is 5 is 2.

              No. I am talking about the entire system, not just about the stores. I am talking about the hardware that Valve does not control, the operating system.

              Steam has super-duper-majority market share.

              What does that mean? Where can we look at market share numbers?

              That’s the only factor.

              That’s what the word means.

              No. See my previous reply. Monopoly is not just having huge market share.

              Monopoly doesn’t mean there’s no competition

              Monopoly literally means there is no competition. Otherwise it would be competition and not a monopoly.

              Not even Epic can get a foot in the door.

              Epic literally has Fortnite, and an entire store with many games and millions of users. And that is only one of the competitors on PC which the user can freely choose, because its not forced to use Steam only. Which invalidates any reasoning about why Steam would be a monopoly. How does GOG and itchio exist? They would be bankrupt by now, if everyone was using only one platform and never buy anything else from their “competitors”.

              Same reason Twitter still exists. The bulk of customers will not check other stores unless they are forced to. To them, for whatever reason, Steam is PC gaming.

              That’s irrelevant and not how monopoly is defined.

              1
              Continue this thread 12 more replies

Sign in to comment. Sign in