General intelligence doesn’t imply never making errors or hallucinating facts that simply aren’t true. Humans do that all the time. I know the topic isn’t particularly popular here but I feel like most people aren’t quite giving LLMs the credit they deserve. They’re far from perfect and riddled with glaringly obvious issues in both a technical and moral sense but they also do perform pretty damn good for what they are. Will it lead to general intelligence? Who knows, but based on what I’ve seen I’m sure not getting more confident that it absolutely won’t.
And llms have no chance of becoming anything similar
I don’t think we have the grounds to make this kind of absolute statement. How could anyone possibly know? I’m fine with people proclaiming even extremely high confidence for it being the case but to say it absolutely is so without leaving any chance for the possibility of being proven wrong just seems arrogant.
AI being conscious or actively wanting to harm us isn’t the scenario most people worrying about the alignment problem are concerned about. The worry is that it ends up destroying us as a side product of something else it does. In a similar way humans destroy an anthill where we want to put up a house. We don’t do it because we want to harm ants.
1 points on Skynet likely never achieved self awareness or super-intelligence, so Terminator is actually just a cautionary tale of AI in an idiocracy. in !showerthoughts@lemmy.world ·
Yes, or an example I personally like to use that’s slightly less cartoonish than Bostrom’s Paperclip Maximizer is one that might ironically also come from him: getting into a self-driving taxi and telling it “to the airport, as fast as possible” and then you arrive 3 minutes later with the car completely wrecked, terrified out of your mind, covered in shit and vomit and with a 5-star wanted level. You got what you asked but not what you meant.