Skip to content

Comment on What linguistic hills are you willing to die on?

You are viewing one comment and its replies. View all comments · View the comment above

Comments

  • I used to believe similarly, but I’ve since changed my mind and believe such lists should actually just be rewritten. Its Wikipedia page has a great section about ambiguity explaining exactly how it can actually introduce ambiguity, or fail to remove it when it already exists.

    25
    • These are specific cases, and they’re right but I’d say otherwise it should only be omitted if timing is important–like with dialogue. Like just now, for example, there should be one after “right”, but it changes the timing when it’s dialogue. Otherwise, there’s no ambiguity.

      0
    • That was a good read, thank you

      7
    • Fascinating. It seems that the greatest potential for confusion emerges from any possible 3-item list. Thanks for sharing.

      3
    • Lists are good though!

      1
      • I didn’t say otherwise! A list can be written in a way that doesn’t have ambiguity, serial comma or not.

        8

Sign in to comment. Sign in