If this makes you feel better about your poor attempt at a joke, I support it. You probably need this.
You thinking a light day is not far is not me missing nuance, painfully dim mental gymnastics 😂
Go visit it.
First part: thats fair, your wording above seemed to imply otherwise. Even if that was true, it wouldnt have painted you as anti-trans, if thats what you’re worried about here. You can respect someone’s identity while also growing apart from them as they change, happens along many axes. Axis’? I think axes.
Regardless, I dont think retroactively editing your thoughts at the time does them any meaningful favours or respect? You had no idea they were trans, why apply what you know now to a past you that didn’t?
Its how you feel about them now or since that matters, in this regard.
Your current vs previous perspective. You arent clairvoyant, and havent ever been. Else they would have been an ex much sooner or never had the opportunity.
You’re explaining your exs reality, the commenter above was explaining it from your perspective, you’re both correct.
Yeah agreed, but marketing and hyping is how you get people excited and how you get funding. I struggle to imagine how you’d ever remove that from the economic equation. It definitely can have its drawbacks.
Yeah I think your conclusion is pretty likely. Most tools started off inefficient and got more so, because a more efficient tool is more desirable. Broadly speaking.
I dont think its completely impossible that they (the big companies) eek out their existence long enough that their income overcomes their initial outlay. As I say, they arent static, they are still progressing both the software and the hardware. Ramp up their green energy investment, continue progressing the energy efficiency increases per token, consistent supply lines and competition in components and raw materials push prices down. All feasible. None guaranteed, but all feasible.
I guess I interpreted it as a full collapse because they’re implying that AI as a technology would disappear entirely, which at this point would require all computers to disappear or regress to a primitive state.
The topic here was the collapse of civilisation?
Companies having done that doesn’t make it fundamental to the technology. That’s just something a lot of people who base their worldview on article headlines parrot.
Don’t get me wrong, those practices are bad. But they come from the incentives and behaviour of the companies involved. The technology doesn’t require them. That’s a failure of a system that rewards companies for taking whatever they can get away with.
All of this is a capitalism problem, focusing on the technology is a distraction that will never achieve anything.
They can overlap. Price gouging means charging excessively high prices, especially when people have little choice during shortages or emergencies. Its basically demand based pricing, a fairly normal economic principle, taken to extremes.
Surveillance pricing means using personal data to estimate what you’re willing to pay and tailoring your price accordingly. Two people could be buying the same product at the same time and see different prices because the company thinks it can squeeze more out of one of them.
I think it may be something you have to see to believe, it is pretty depressing.
It is pal, the fact you could not dispute it and just swore at me says a lot.
“So we’re just using hypotheticals” meanwhile your entire argument depends on civilisation definitely collapsing, doing so later definitely being worse, and doing so now leaving humanity able to rebuild.
I offered a possibility. You’ve built a whole prescription for humanity around your predictions.
And your bike analogy involves slowing down and steering to avoid a crash. You’re advocating deliberately crashing because you’ve decided a worse accident is inevitable further down the road.
There’s a lot wrapped up in that certainty, and its a sentiment that does personally annoy me for several reasons: You’re assuming the problems you see won’t be meaningfully understood or addressed by anyone else, and that because you can’t see a workable solution, there isnt one. You’re treating the limits of your own foresight as the limits of what’s possible. Stop and consider whether you really consider yourself an unparalleled engineer and problem solver of the modern era. Dont tell me the answer, just ponder it.
Then, when it comes to your preferred scenario, suddenly humanity can cooperate, adapt and rebuild after civilisation collapses. Why does human ingenuity get to do so much heavy lifting after the catastrophe, but count for so little in preventing it? There’s a huge juxtaposition in that reasoning.
You’ve scrutinised the future you dislike for everything that could go wrong, and waved through the future you prefer on everything that could go right. That’s a very shaky basis for deciding everyone else would be better off enduring a collapse now.
And “if we shut down civilisation now, everything can come back” is doing an extraordinary amount of work there. How are you keeping people fed, water clean, medicines available and nuclear facilities maintained? Who’s coordinating any of that through the collapse you’re welcoming? Those are fairly significant details to skip on the way to “the earth can heal”.
You don’t get to dismiss uncertainty in my argument while treating the most optimistic version of your own catastrophe scenario as a certainty, that’s fucking nonsense.
I get that you’re concerned but this is irrational and you probably need to talk to someone serious if this is actually weighing heavily on you. If its just an idle rant, less so.
AI isnt going to end, the big dog companies might go down, but you can run very good ones on your computer these days. Helps to look into stuff, the unknown is always scarier than the known.
You aren’t exactly painting yourself as an oracle here. Spouting doom will always leave you correct eventually, but being wrong for decades beforehand doesn’t become insight just because something finally breaks.
Why are you so confident that deliberately accelerating a collapse makes it “more manageable”? If the dot-com boom had lasted long enough for actual revenues to catch up with valuations, the eventual correction could’ve been far less severe. Buying time can give the underlying technology a chance to deliver. It’s getting more efficient per token at an incredible rate, and there’s enormous pressure to improve hardware efficiency too. At some point, falling costs and growing paid usage could make the economics sustainable, though neither of us knows when, or whether, that’ll happen. You’re assuming that time can only make things worse, then treating that assumption as a reason to burn it all down.
Also worth noting the increase in power generation has pushed us to add 50% to our total global solar capacity in the last two years. That’s fucking awesome and unlikely to stop increasing suddenly.
I’m not saying nothing’s wrong, or that all these companies are good guys, fuck no. But confidently predicting doom now is no more convincing than all the previous prophecies that predicted doom.
None of that is going to be anything you’d actually want, at most its a game of pass the parcel where someone else leads the ai game meanwhile you are financially fucked for several years.
Your options in the industry right now are learn how to integrate it into your workflow in a way that you can still produce quality or exit the industry. Most rational people in positions of responsibility are looking at this as another industrial revolution (not as overhyped as it sounds, weve had several already in the past few decades.), digging your heels in wont stop it rolling in, its time to learn how to mitigate the drawbacks.
You’re free to, yes. That doesn’t mean you automatically know what that looks like or how to build your life around it.
“Do what you love” assumes someone already knows what gives them fulfilment. Plenty of people spend so long getting by that they’ve barely had the chance to figure that out. Give them financial security and you’ve removed a huge burden, but you haven’t automatically supplied direction.
That’s why I said employment isn’t the sole source of purpose. Having the freedom to find another one and actually finding it are two very separate things.
Working to survive is A purpose.
It is not the sole source, I would argue it may actually be one of the simplest in the grand scheme of things. It doesnt require much introspection or self awareness to know you need food and somewhere to live.
0 points on Elon Musk told the world he is ‘dark, gothic MAGA’ - now he’s trying to erase history in !politics@lemmy.world ·
You’ve got it backwards, he was never maga, he has his own agenda. Maga was just an incredibly convenient movement with a head he could far more easily manipulate with something he has in abundance. Money.
Not being maga does not make him a good guy with honest intentions.
You guys get too stuck in your ‘there are only 2 sides’ mentality sometimes and it can really hamstring your assessments.