Yes, thank you for being much more concise with it than I was able to be
Yeah, Chris’ house works because you’re removing the second S (Chriss house)
The neighbours one - first one is fine, second again drops the S, so needs the ’
Third one, though - the ’ isn’t dropping a letter so I don’t like it.
Not sure this counts…
but 's should only mean a letter is missing…
Like, if you say “It’s” then you’re saying “It is” - but missing the “i” in “is” - so the ’ takes the place of the i …
Saying “That’s Davids cup” should be fine. Why is there a possessive S? Why is it “That’s David’s cup”?
The ’ is not taking the place of a missing letter and therefore shouldn’t be there.
I mean, if the possessive is right - like “See Christopher’s car?” - then why is it wrong to say “The dryer lost it’s power”? The car is used by Christopher. The power is used by the dryer. Neither have the ’ replacing a missing letter, so neither should have it…
0 points on What linguistic hills are you willing to die on? in !asklemmy@lemmy.world ·
But it’s not really consistent…
To my understanding, “David’s car” has an apostrophe because it used to be written, in ye olde times, “Davides car”…
So the ’ denoted the missing “e”… But now it’s sort of redundant.
While I’m at it, whyn’t use the apostrophe to remove letters more often?
Why is “Won’t” sensible, but “Willn’t” isn’t?
It’s just “Will not” missing the O, in the same way “Isn’t” is just “Is not” missing the O…