What do you think cost means here in this context.
Ok and I’ve try to see any of these protests affect change. When you factor in the cost it just doesn’t make sense. If anything i really believe protest are organized by the opposition. Like how they did back in the day to actually create anger towards the protestors.
The cost benefits do not add up. When pressed to show any, I often hear responses like yours where it’s very loose and vague. I think people love the idea of a protest and honestly it’s just a sunk cost fallacy right now.
It is much more effective and powerful to use digital spaces. But it need networks. To build the networks you need people to be active and I have only seen leftist convincing each other to log off and be less active online and to instead to these high risk activities like showing up to get their heads caved in by police meanwhile the opposition is using all the digital spaces that were abandoned to spread hate towards the protesters.
Trying to protest on today’s age without securing the channels we use to communicate is foolish. I think given what we know about the money behind a lot of modern things that it isn’t crazy to suggest that the left as a whole may have been led towards high cost low rewards activities to keep us occupied and out of the way.
Ok how do you measure the effect from the protest and could you achieve what you did with the protest with anything else to a greater effect with less effort.
What was the cost and reward here. Cause I don’t think you can actually measure the effect without having to get all hand wavy
How, how the fuck does this even work. I don’t fucking understand why people will go to great lengths to show up like this in a street in some random city with a goal like “reduce male violence”
Have you guys been on Facebook lately? They’re increasing a culture of male violence one bobs burger group at a time. You heard that right. Because the people who actually are using the data, and their wealth know that to get action you need to affect culture. You don’t affect jack fucking shit standing in the god damn fucking cold. You affect culture by slowly over time by spreading your culture as far as you can see while surpression the culture that is in opposition to yours. In a digital age when eye balls and ears are online, you go to the places people see. Fuck me i can flood a single page with my culture if I really wanted to and beat get a much further reach and affect in a couple weeks than this thousand or so people. Imagine what these people could do in a month if they instead went to the hate groups and flooded it with content to spread information and used mematic spread to grow and attract more people. You can even do it in your pajama with a coffee. But fuck no, instead drive 150km to so random city and stand around for 8hrs
Exactly. What i want is to be able to look into the bots and what they’re doing. I’m just surprised saying this out loud people are like “its not important” to me is literally the most important thing. We’re sitting here on lemmy with the most tech savvy people on the left and people are content with just having a place to read the daily “fuck Trump” post.
We should be looking at and exposing how these networks are working. Racism and right wing culture is growing so fast and rapidly. This blue wave isn’t a result of the left being preferred, it’s a result of the right fucking up and that’s something we should be weary of cause it’ll bounce back. It’ll bounce back because the right control all our digital space and have the eyes and ears of most people since the major platforms have seen these exodus. They can rapidly put information out now.
My thing is why isn’t there a bigger fight on the left to identify and jam this up. Why does it seem like we’re organizing a protest every 6 months but the online stuff were just sitting around.
I’m calling bullshit on this. The entire internet was built by people spending years building things and cracking them. The speed of solutions have only increased for us too. So why have those solutions stopped. This post isn’t about why don’t we have a Twitter or Facebook clone. It’s asking why didn’t we break the barriers they put up. 20 years ago a 16 year old would be up all night saying fuck Elon and finding a way around the thing they tried to implement. Even now the way people Crack drm. They’re wizards of you like at what is needed to Crack these cryptographic problems.
I guess what’s missing from my mind to yours is why would we do that. I just think the reason they walled this off is so they can run essentially race baiting and culture shifting content like modern cointelpro without opposition, us from getting in the way. If we could say find Facebook groups and collect data for whose posting when and how and what you start to see patterns and can expose the network. But the minute something like AI was out there and anyone could easily shift this massive amounts of data they locked it away and we all went ok that’s fine. So maybe I’m crazy, I know i sound crazy, but I fucking hate racists, I just think there’s so much more we could be doing as a group.
would say when most comments I saw online said some version of “don’t even argue with them, it’s like wrestling with pigs” is when I started to notice our spaces being given away.
I’ll be the first to admit I’m terminally online. With that comes alot of vibes, so I get this is vibes. But my experience is that leftists don’t like confrontation. I saw many spaces start out resisting when MAGA and racists began to show up, but they quickly lost interest and left. My instinct when I see a space getting turned is to stubbornly prevent it as much as possible. Other people have more common sense. But it’s almost always inevitable.
Look, I noticed this prior to 2016. I know at least one step in how they accomplished this. They built a network. They made some accounts like parent nodes connected to child nodes, and each one would build networks and sub networks in different areas. Then once those accounts had a good amount of real human followers, they connected the human followers together. Now they had a logistical supply line to disseminate information rapidly. The parent node drops a story and within hours its posted everywhere. Then your Dan Bonginos and Charlie Kirks and Shapiros boost it.
It isn’t organic. It didn’t just build itself, it was forced, and the left didn’t do anything similiar.
There were multiple steps where I saw the right building something, and to this day they’re still doing it. Why the fuck is there a Bobs Burgers group on Facebook who only posts about trans people in bathrooms. There’s one for every cartoon.
What i said is hyperbole sure, but like this api issue, I feel like things are oddly silent and I’m worried while the right are building things, we’re destroying them thinking we’re building them.
So you left but the world is still on these fascist billionaire tools. Their kids are on their learning. They will be adults one day. So running away to lemmy is great for a minute. Are you ready for the next generation raised on nothing but MAGA and heritage foundation digital spaces?
You can say fuck em all you want but I think we’re making a huge mistake right now and it’s terrifying to me how people don’t see it and or actively encourage it
What do you mean by work around?
Because these spaces now generate so much racism and anti science and anti leftist trash that it leaks into every part of culture and society. I watch kids on their phones all day. They don’t go to lemmy. They go to Facebook, TikTok, Twitter, Reddit. Everybody here is saying left leaning users all left so what is left? What content are the kids today seeing and learning and building their world views from? I get you don’t personally like it. But are you ready for these kids to be voting and running for government and being your coworkers and employer in the next 10 years?
Sure but more of us do here don’t we? I would have thought more people here would share ways to collect it. If we still had access I bet we would have learned alot about how the propaganda is spreading. Who, what and where it was originating from. It’s just strange to me there isn’t a ton of interest in it. Like barely any.
I took people saying they’d punch a nazi to mean they would be willing to fight nazis. Instead I kind of feel like people saw nazis take over their places and went ok we’re going to go over here now.
Whereas I see fighting back as finding out how many comments are needed to tip a post in favor of the left wing, and kicking the nazis off the platform or stopping thier momentum. You know fir mah lazer shit. Leftist coordinate back in the day. Today it’s just not happening.
I just feel like the moment arrived and we were asleep.
First is the counterculture comment. I’ve thought alot about this and I think lemmy has done the opposite. You mentioned regaining control, censorship and payments which are all structure issues. But look at this place. What was actually created here? I’d argue it may even be worse then reddit.
The golden days of reddit and the internet existed for one reason, because they were everything you described. People had control. We had tools that let regular people create and post whatever they wanted, and also control the spaces we participated in. It was essentially a more socialized platform. But eventually reddit and the others wanted to make money, so they drifted toward removing those controls. YouTube removed the downvote button, then brought it back, but now it doesn’t do anything. It gives users the sense they’re doing something but its theater. Reddit and the others did the same. In the end everything was there to serve corporate interests.
Mods were given massive powers because it’s easy to appoint a producer or marketing team as a faceless mod who controls the space. That took away the communities freedom to grow organically. It also opened them up to political interests, like r/canada where a user became a mod, turned out to be a nazi and proceeded to only allow racists. That is exactly what lemmy recreated. It didn’t rebuild what reddit was in it’s best years. It rebuilt the features that allowed corporate control, censorship and the selling off of communities, and nobody questions this. Things are only good now because lemmy isn’t big enough yet. It’s a poison pill waiting to turn because we never addressed the original problems. We just found a new place.
So here’s what I think needs to change. Lemmy should reject mod control measures in favor of community based powers. Mods shouldn’t control communities. Control should be with the people in them, and mods should be there only to handle the most serious issues. Whatever power mods do keep should be transparent so everyone can see whats being removed and why.
Second, you didn’t know what I meant by collecting, analyzing and disrupting. I just mean learning.
My question back to you is this. Take anti vaccination groups, communities that defend rapists, or some of the most vile stuff online. Do you think those are just regular people showing up organically, or do you think there’s networks and information supply lines feeding each other?
I struggle to tell if other people see this the way I do. When you say you’re confused about why we would collect information, analyze it and disrupt things, it makes me think we’re living in two different worlds. It’s like trying to bring up vaccinations on Facebook. I feel like i want to learn a lot of things in life and right now to me this take over of our digital spaces is the most important. So I’m just always taken back when I’m asked “why would you want to”
I don’t think there’s much of a counter culture here. Where is it? I see reddit just with smaller communities.
Are there communities of people discussing how to scrape Facebook or Twitter in order to collect analyze and disrupt?
Ah bummer. I find things wrong here and there. My favorite is when you don’t do anything and ask if it’s sure. Sometimes without any new input it’ll say “you’re right I’m totally wrong the answer is…”
I just see it as a tool. I don’t have much luck searching through endless forums or documents for hours just to find the section i need is worthwhile. I can at get to a direct answer and if it’s wrong I troubleshoot like I do anyways.
What’s an example of a technical issue?
I use it more to rubber duck and also scaffold or search Google and it self to link me to things that I then can read. Other times if I’m reading something and I don’t understand I’ll again feed it into it and then talk it through with it. It’s so much faster than trying to do it with search engines now
Absolutely same experience.
This is a bit of a tangent, but I find I’m at odds with a lot of things lately. I’m just miserable lol. One example is I love to learn new things. As an example I learn coding. Early on there’s great resources. Very clear videos of new content creators who have answers. Over the years everybody wants to code. Now the content creators explode. The content slowly over time becomes less useful. Now when I search I have millions of videos on the same thing because they’re all chasing the one video that week whose metrics were the highest. Soon searching for educational videos is super difficult. It’s a broken system.
AI is like that early day now so it’s still fun to use and gets right to the heart of the problem I’m trying to solve and it’s interactive. That’s how I learn. I have a conversation. I’m sorry it’s killing the world. But I’m honestly done being a leftist hero I thought I’d be when I was younger. I’m so tired and I just want to learn stuff and I’m tired of every new thing that comes out being some evil according to the latest lefty gripe.
Look at bitcoin. It fucking sucked. Still sucks. But if any of us invested in it years ago we’d be retired. But we were all here telling each other to stay away. What did that get any of us? Pride? Digital acceptance that we all complied with the latest hater trend? We’re still poor and crypto still exists. It was just an eye opener to me that people online are holding each other back. Id rather use the tools I have to better my position. If it works then it works and I’m not going to let the faceless amorphous body of haters hold me back.
Use ai
0 points on Hundreds of men lead protest to urge other men to help reduce violence against women in !world@lemmy.world ·
The math on protests has changed
I’m not saying don’t protest. I’m saying the math has changed. I look at it like a thermodynamics problem. How much energy goes in and what do we get out? A protest takes so much organization. People have to travel, take time off, risk their health, risk arrest. And the reward lately has been almost nothing. This isn’t the 70s anymore where seeing a million people marching would be shocking and attention grabbing. I can get 1 million people out to check out a girls butthole. It’s just not the same world.
Here’s the thing that doesn’t make sense to me. If you think you can get people to physicaly show up to a protest then it only makes sense it should be easier to rally them digitally. If you don’t think you can do it online but you think you can do it in the street then you’re not thinking logically. It’s way less effort and a better payoff to secure an online presence and watch pages shift then to go stand in a street for a few hours and go home.
And without that presence you can’t even say what the protest is about. The opposition will say it for you. Ask yourself why patriot front and others are gaining cultural significants with a van full of racists. They secured the online channels first. So when they show up they control the messaging, and that is proven to work at changing peoples opinions. It is bad out there. Facebook, twitter and even reddit now that everybody left. The racism, the sexism, the hate. It’s growing because its unchecked.
We know groups like heritage foundation and TPUSA and random billionaires have the time and resources. They have research like cambridge analytica and more. Its crazy to think the only people that got radicalized was MAGA. The left fell for the propaganda too. We left the public squares. We convinced each other to leave the technology and spaces we used to control, and then we tried to fight back in ways that are high cost and low reward.
So I think we need to change what we’re doing. Not forever, just for now. Get back out there and have fun with it. Argue, troll, learn the tactics they’ve been using on us and return fire. The algorithms arent a light switch. Its not on for MAGA and off for the left. It’s about engagement, and guess what that means. People on the left see more right posts and vice versa. Thats a great starting point. Real people, no fake accounts, just coordinated.
Lemmy should be where we build the networks. Where’s our libs of tiktok moment? Where’s our 4chan moment where we find a flag by clouds and flights? Something is lacking on the left and we need to fix it.
Then, when we’ve built it back up, we protest. But without doing the ground work first its all cost low reward.